The Who
Forty years earlier, The Who released their third album, "The Who Sell Out." On the cover was Townshend applying a giant-sized roll-on deodorant to his bare armpit, and Roger Daltrey bathing in a tub filled with Heinz Baked Beans. At the time, of course, this was meant to be a jab at advertisers and the crass commercialization of rock music.
To Townshend's credit, it did take forty years for him to cash out. As for Keith Moon, he's probably still rolling in his grave.
Other Rock Legends
To their credit, other rock legends have remained steadfast in refusing to license their music; those include Elvis Costello, Bruce Springsteen, and John Fogerty. "This Note's for You", a Neil Young song, needles those musicians who have sold out. John Densmore has even blocked the efforts of the other two surviving members of The Doors from licensing the group's music.
In an article in "The Nation", Densmore mentioned turning down a $1.5 million offer from Apple Computers to used "When the Music's Over" in an ad. He said, "Apple is a pretty hip company. We use computers. ... Dammit! Why did Jim (Morrison) have to have such integrity?"
Other Sell-Outs
It's been said that the first blatant rock legend sell-out to Madison Avenue occurred in 1987 when the original Beatles recording of "Revolution" was used in a Nike ad.
In 1995, the Rolling Stones' "Start Me Up" was used for the launch of Microsoft's Windows95.
In 2002, the Beatles' song "Tax Man" was used in an H&R Block commercial. And worst of all, "All You Need is Love" advertised Luvs Baby Diapers.
In Defense of Selling Out
Surviving members of Led Zeppelin have claimed that the reason they allowed "Rock and Roll" to be used for a Cadillac commercial was to keep their music in front of the public only because the radio conglomerates refuse to include Zeppelin music on station playlists. Sir Paul McCartney agrees.
Indie Sell-Outs
Not letting current young bands off the hook, in 2007, American Airlines and Citibank co-sponsored a Mary J. Blige concert for Citibank members only at the House of Blues. Mitsubishi has used songs from fiercely indie bands like the Buzzcocks, the Fall, and Clone Defects. And then don't forget all those massive corporate-sponsored multi-cities mega-concerts like Vans Warped Tour, Rockstar Energy Drink's Taste of Chaos Tour, and the Honda Civic Tour.
SOURCES:
"Paul McCartney, is that you?", Seth Stevenson, Slate, URL: (http://www.slate.com/id/2126568)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/release/gpzf/
"Atlas Shrugged", George Varga, San Diego Union Tribune, URL: (http://www.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20070301/news_lz1w01who.html)
http://www.rollingstone.com/rockdaily/index.php/2007/07/23/worst-rock-sell-outs-ever/
"Selling records or selling out", Bill Flanagan, CBS, URL: (http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/02/26/sunday/main1346174.shtml)
"Selling out sans guilt", Eric Kelsey, Utne Reader, URL: (http://www.utne.com/webwatch/2007_306/news/12646-1.html)
"The day the music died", Jake Dudas, Common Dreams, URL: (http://www.commondreams.org/scriptfiles/views03/1031-07.htm)
"Pop artists go commercial", Donna DeMarco, Insight on the News, URL: (http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1571/is_23_18/ai_87917223)
"Riders on the Storm", John Densmore, The Nation, URL: (http://www.thenation.com/doc/20020708/densmore)
Published by Elliot Feldman
I'm a veteran television writer (Match Game, Hollywood Squares) and cartoonist (Los Angeles Reader) I've also written for online versions of Jeopardy and Trivial Pursuit. View profile
- Top Ten Songs by Led ZeppelinLed Zeppelin's top ten songs in my opinion.
- Paul McCartney's Solo DebutThis one features Paul McCartney as a one-man band. He played all the instruments, wrote all the songs, and produced the whole shebang.
- Top Ten Songs by the WhoThe Who was most prominent during the "flower power" hippie days of the 1970,s but matured into a masterful rock band in the 1980's. The musical genius of Pete Townsend and the hard-hitting vocals of Roger Daltry hav...
Did Paul McCartney Abuse Heather Mills?the facts (as reported by the media in the Paul / Heather Mills Divorce)- The Seven Most Important Beatles Songs by Paul McCartneyPaul McCartney is too often marginalized by modern rock critics. This article is about seven of his most influential and important songs as a Beatle.
- Book Review: The Who Sell Out
- The Who's Tommy: A Complex Portrait of Disability
- Top Ten Songs by the Who
- Top Ten Songs by the Who
- Top Ten Songs by the Who
- Top Ten Songs by the Who
- Selling Out or Getting In?





5 Comments
Post a CommentIf an artist is in need of the cash, then it's not really a problem. Bottom line is that no matter what kind of financial situation an artist is in, if he or she wants to utilize songs in such a commercial fashion, then it's perfectly OK.
I seem to remember Burger King using a song by the one-hit wonder Modern English entitled "I Melt With You". Seeing as the band probably wasn't making much money otherwise, I say "why not?" Gotta put food on the table. But it was mentioned that one of the band mates is a vegetarian, so therein was the only conflict.
Funny thing is Ads do not usually entice me to buy anything. But I am more apt to watch one featuring a song. I think it is smart business sense that earns them cash, rather than being "sell outs".
Excellent piece. Wasn't it Michael Jackson, the owner of the Beatles publishing rights, who authorized their songs to be used? My favorite one is HP uses the Kinks song - People Take Pictures of Each Other - for its digital photography equipment. Anyone who knows the words to that song realizes that Ray Davies is lampooning those who waste too much time capturing the moment rather than enjoying the moment.
Thank You fer sharin' your insights. ;-}}>
Hey Elliott-
From one oldies fan to another - Rock on!
David