Fifty Thought-Provoking Books with Micro-Reviews and Ratings

Meeting (and Exceeding) the Christine Zibas Challenge

Nancy Miller
In August 2009, Associated Content Contributor extraordinaire Christine Zibas published Fifty Favorite Books and Their Six-Word Reviews. This clever article provided titles, authors, and micro-reviews for fifty books recommended by Ms. Zibas. Frankly, it was as much fun reading her teensy reviews for books I was familiar with as it was learning about unfamiliar books. Based on the comments, others felt the same. Her most clever micro-review may have been the one for Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen: "All men should be Mr. Darcy." Here, here!

Ms. Zibas issued a challenge in her second sentence: "I hope a lot more readers will do this." I don't know if "a lot more" readers responded to the call, but below is my response. In fact, I am exceeding her challenge by providing not only micro-reviews of fifty books, but also ratings. These are not my favorite fifty books; in fact I did not like some of these books. My list includes fifty books appropriate for a general readership that I have read and remember. My list includes many of my favorites, but also some clunkers I will warn you about.

Each book is rated on a four-star scale as follows:

**** Highly recommended! Read it soon!

*** Recommended, read it if it appeals to you

** OK, read it at your own risk

* Not recommended, avoid it if possible

Fiction is noted with an "(F)" and non-fiction with an "(N)". Without further ado, here is the list:

The Metamorphosis**** (F)
Franz Kafka
Man becomes insect, body and soul.

Open**** (N)
Andre Agassi
Image is everything, except on court

Charlotte's Web**** (F)
E.B. White
Some pig, some spider, some story!

Little Women*** (F)
Louisa May Alcott
1800's, Massachusetts sisters growing up

Thank You for Smoking**** (F)
Christopher Buckley
Greed, hypocrisy, high jinx, and smoking

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society*** (F)
Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows
Survived German occupation with books, friendship

The Long Walk Home** (N)
Nelson Mandela
Important but endlessly detailed saga, long!

Emma**** (F)
Jane Austen
Young busybody: growing pains, finds love

The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People*** (N)
Steven Covey
Obvious but profound, re-read it often

Gift from the Sea*** (N)
Anne Morrow Lindbergh
Wealthy woman, tumultuous life, seeks respite

Notes from a Small Island**** (N)
Bill Bryson
Transplanted American retraces introduction to Britain

Northanger Abbey**** (F)
Jane Austen
Gothic horror meets Georgian youthful romance

Life of Pi* (F)
Yann Martel
Forget awards, it's tedious, frustrating allegory

Nicholas Nickleby*** (F)
Charles Dickens
Characters, subplots, tragedy, redemption, ultra Dickensian

Dewey: The Small-Town Library Cat Who Touched the World*** (N)
Vicki Myron and Bret Witter
Charming to a fault, easy read

The Little Prince**** (F)
Antoine de Saint-Exupery
Planets, kingdoms, whimsical, excellent life lessons

Les Miserables*** (F)
Victor Hugo
The dense original: story without music

1984*** (F)
George Orwell
Future society imperfect, big brother watching

Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close: A Novel**** (F)
Jonathan Safran Foer
Boy seeks answers, healing after 9/11

Dispatches from the Edge:
A Memoir of War, Disasters, and Survival
** (N)
Anderson Cooper
Global ambulance chaser successfully avoids introspection

The English American: A Novel**** (F)
Alison Larkin
Cross-pond adoption, personal discovery, autobiographical

My Freshman Year*** (N)
Rebekah Nathan
Anthropology professor goes undercover, studies natives

Mutant Message Down Under*** (F?N? ambiguous!)
Marlo Morgan
American woman learns wisdom of aborigines

Gone with the Wind**** (F)
Margaret Mitchell
Sweeping civil war drama, must read!

American on Purpose*** (N)
Craig Ferguson
Zany Scottish comic gets serious, poignant

As I Lay Dying* (F)
William Faulkner
Grim, morbid, was there a point?

The 9/11 Report: A Graphic Adaptation*** (N)
Sid Jacobson and Ernie Colon
Not a comic book, exceptionally powerful

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's (or Philosopher's) Stone**** (F)
J. K. Rowling
Boy wizard, launch of fabulous franchise

The Bookseller of Kabul*** (N)
Asne Seierstad
Nuanced portrait of Afghani patriarch/bookseller

The Glass Castle**** (N)
Jeanette Walls
Stunning memoir, triumph over childhood deprivation

A Woman in Charge: The Life of Hillary Rodham Clinton*** (N)
Carl Bernstein
Watergate sleuth unearths facts, connects dots

Maisie Dobbs**** (F)
Jacqueline Winspear
Female detective in London between wars

An Unquiet Mind*** (N)
Kay Redfield Jamison
Prominent psychiatrist confesses her own bipolarity

Ladder of Years*** (F)
Anne Tyler
Baltimore wife runs away, starts over

The Killer Angels*** (F/N)
Michael Shaara
Gettysburg battle novel eerily authentic, moving

Seeing** (F)
Jose Saramago
Citizens submit blank ballots, government over-reacts

On Writing *** (N)
Stephen King
Prolific novelist reveals tricks of trade

The Flame Trees of Thika*** (N)
Elspeth Huxley
British girl growing up in Kenya

Growing Up*** (N)
Good TImes
Russell Baker
Journalist's mellow memoirs, Baltimore, London, New York

Moo**** (F)
Jane Smiley
Hysterical send-up of state college life

The Doonesbury Chronicles**** (F)
Gary Trudeau
Collection of classic Trudeau, sheer genius

A Room With a View*** (F)
E. M. Forster
Wonderful film based on wonderful book

Carpool*** (F)
Mary Cahill
Clever first novel, suburban mid-life crises

Excellent Women*** (F)
Barbara Pym
Subtle comedy of manners, Britain 1950's

Nickel and Dimed:
On (Not) Getting by in America
*** (N)
Barbara Ehrenreich and Frances Fox Piven
Difficult lives of the working poor

A Plague on Both Your Houses**** (F)
Matthew Bartholomew Chronicles #1
Susanna Gregory
Murder mystery series, Cambridge University mid-1300's

The Kings of New York*** (N)
Michael Weinreb
NYC public high school chess team

White Widow*** (F)
Jim Lehrer
Texas bus driver has disconcerting fantasies

Boomsday**** (F)
Christopher Buckley
Outrageous proposal to solve Social Security crisis

The Last Lecture**** (N)
Randy Pausch and Jeffrey Zaslow
CMU professor realizes his childhood dreams

DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL CONNECTION:
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.

Published by Nancy Miller

Nancy Miller is Associate Director of Academic Advising at a major public university. Previously she worked in health care and social security policy for the US government. She has been a writer and editor...  View profile

  • Christine Zibas issued a challenge for other CPs to publish book lists with micro-reviews.
  • This is my list!
  • My list includes not just "favorites" but also some books I read and did not like. See ratings.
None of the books on my list duplicates a book on Ms. Zibas' original list. They are disjoint sets. This gives you 100 books to consider reading!

4 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Maria Roth2/19/2010

    I've read some of these. I get the feeling you like Jane Austen as much as I do. :)

  • Patti Walden2/13/2010

    Great list!

  • Christine Zibas2/13/2010

    I am so happy that you decided to do this. I hope that other people will take up the challenge. I have read many of the same authors as you, albeit different books by them. And I loved seeing Barbara Pym's name on your list. I adore her writing and haven't read any of her books since I lived in London...you really brought back a happy memory for me! Now, what to do about that "Life of Pi" book sitting on my shelf to be read?

  • Nancy Tracy2/13/2010

    We've read a lot of the same books, and I agree with your stars on almost all of them; e.g., hated Pi, loved Glass Castle. Your micro-reviews were strangely addicting and fun to read!

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.