Footbal Vs Soccer

Which is the Harder Game to Play

Youranter
SOCCER vs FOOTBALL

Soccer is called football in Europe and the UK. It is called soccer here and football is called, well, football. Due to some nasty letters to the editor recently, I thought I'd take it upon myself to explore this subject.

Let's start with the names. In soccer, you can use your feet or your head to guide the ball. Because the ball is normally moved using a foot, we arrive at the term 'football'. Pretty clever, these Europeans, eh? In Canadian or American 'football', you have three or four chances to move the ball, only one of which might involve using your foot. You don't necessarily have to punt on third or fourth down. Because of the possibility you might punt, the game is called 'football'. Huh?

American football grew out of English style rugby, which is called rugby not football. Apparently, rugby rules were too complicated for the Americans so they changed them and added a few (?) pounds of padding to protect their precious bodies. The NFL didn't appear on the scene until some 30 or 40 years after rugby was brought to North America and somehow rugby went from rugby to football with its chances of the ball contacting an actual foot being lowered to 25% at best.

A lot of American football fans swoon at the idea of players weighing 275 - 300 lbs. putting on all sorts of shoulder pads, hip protectors, cleats (different ones for grass and astroturf), special helmets, jocks, etc. and going out to play for 10 minutes before the other line takes over to provide offence or defence, as required.

Soccer fans swoon when their favourite player goes the distance, playing both offence and defence, of 90 minutes dressed in shorts, shin pads and a cup.

Gee, I wonder which sport is harder to play?

I admit that I am prejudiced towards soccer. Coming from a European background with a father who played semi-pro soccer, I guess it's a no-brainer. I also played some soccer in my time and believe you me, I think I would rather have played football. At least I would have had some padding and the chance to catch my breath and recuperate while the other line was out there. Fifteen minutes of a half-time breather in soccer just didn't do it for me.

My wife is an avid soccer fan and refers to football players as 'girly-boys'. I try to argue with her, put she has a hell of a good point. I've gotten pix in my e-mail showing legs of soccer players broken with bones sticking wide out, and it hurts me just to look at them. I retired from soccer myself after cracking three ribs. Football players go on the DL when their manicures aren't to their liking.

How do you argue against something like that?

Published by Youranter

I'm just a working stiff with opinions who would like to share them.  View profile

99 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Sean Lind4/5/2011

    This is possibly the worst piece of writing I have ever read. I wrote a similar article "football vs football" which I was hoping to find some similar articles to link to... and found this hunk of trash.

    If you want a more humorous approach to this old debate you can find my article here: http://bettingchoice.co.uk/blog/football-vs-football-the-name-debate-settled

  • alex12/31/2010

    the reason they wear protection is because they are babies, they don't wanna play the game like the Europeans actually did it. even with all the protection, they get tired after 2 min. they are all chickens

  • isaac9/16/2010

    real soccer players dont wear cups

  • daveeee9/12/2010

    I love soccer... it is a rough sport too.. yes a bit less brutality but also less padding...
    football is more brutality but more padding..

    i play foot ball all the time its fun.. playing against big guys is fun.... they cant catch me when i run the ball!!

  • Bill8/7/2010

    american football is harder to play because you carry over 20 pounds of equiptment and hit harder than any other sport does... so American football vs Soccer... Strength: American Football, Endurance: Soccer, Power: American Football, Speed: Soccer, Size: American Football... and overall athletic ability: American Football...
    Why? American Football players have the best overall strength and quickness(quick feet, hands, etc)... soccer player are just fast and have good footwork

  • Dan8/7/2010

    American Football added protectionafter people were being killed out on the field...

  • whaaaa.....8/4/2010

    I've played football/soccer for many years now, and I can tell you, there is no use of a cup. did the author of this article use a cup in his footballing days?

  • Zox7/22/2010

    Great idea :| to take sport which name is RUGBY and change it to FOOTBALL - the name of another sport that already exists! Ohhh, Americans...

  • blueshifter7/4/2010

    "The games are called football because they are played ON foot, as opposed to sports played on horseback."

    What you've just typed is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent comment were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this comment board is now dumber for having read it.

  • The man6/29/2010

    You wife didnt call me a girly-boy when I shoved my dick down her throat.

    The reason football players wear pads is because we hit harder than rugby players.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.