The bill which passed on Tuesday states that wearing a burqa or niqab in public could result in a 150-euro (190 USD) fine, citizenship classes, or both. Furthermore, the French government holds that anyone who forces a woman to wear a such garments could face one year in prison and a 15,000-euro (19,000 USD) fine. CNN reports the French legislation deeming such an act as, "a new form of enslavement that the republic cannot accept on its soil."
Abroad, groups such as Amnesty International have condemned the bill claiming it is a violation of a woman's rights to expression and religion. Furthermore, some legal experts claim that the ban on burqas, though it could uphold women's equality rights, could also be walking the line of being unconstitutional. However, on French soil, the people are overwhelmingly in favor with 80% approving of the bill. Similar statistics can be found in other European countries such as Spain and Germany.
The bill is set to go to the Senate in September where it is also expected to pass. If the bill is made into law it would take effect six months after passage, in hopes that authorities could convince women to voluntarily stop wearing the garments. Furthermore, France would become the first European nation to enforce a ban on burqas and niqabs.
France has a Muslim population of about 5 million, the largest of any European nation. Whereas head scarves are worn regularly, some estimates suggest that a very small fraction of Muslim women in France where a burqa or niqab style face veil.
The main body representing French Muslims does not completely disagree with the ban, as they believe such garbs to be unsuitable within the French republic. However there are still fears that this kind of legislation could fuel some anti-Muslim sentiments. Yahoo News reports Malika Hamidi, the general director of the European Muslim Network, as stating that the ban's supporters are "playing up a feeling of fear of Islam." Hamidi claims that this is a crucial issue, especially because Europe is currently concerned with a changing identity, struggling to manage a growing diversity, and facing an economic crisis.
The issue of French identity is a multi-layered one. Just last year national debates were sparked as to what it means to be French. Furthermore, the French have previously had difficulties with assimilating immigrants with the most notable instance being the riots in 2005. In regard to religion, the French have had bans on religious articles such as crucifixes for quite some time. However with this new legislation many things will be brought into question concerning not only French identity and values, but those of other nations as well. When do women's rights come into play in a religious issue? How far is too far in terms of secularism? How can a nation's constitution be violated and upheld at once? These are questions that affect much of the legislation in the modern world and attaining the answers is never easy.
Published by Amanda Abella
A freelance writer since 2009, Amanda Abella has had work published on Yahoo News, eHow, Miami Examiner, Environmental Graffiti, The Smart College Grad, and Handmade News. She also runs a Gen Y personal deve... View profile
Niqab Wearing Woman Expelled from College French ClassImmigration officials expelled an Egyptian woman from a required francization course because she didn't want to remove her niqab. Clarifying the issues involved, as the woman fi...- Sarkozy: Burqas Not Welcome in FrancePresident of the French Republic Nicolas Sarkozy has said something that no French President has ever said before and no American President would dare say. He has denounced the wearing of the burqa as incompatible wit...
- What to Wear?Governments and religion around the world have drawn swords to rule what attire people can wear. Whose business is it? Should government ban or promote the wearing of religious apparel or standards of dress?
- Craigslist RnR: Religious Freedom and Cultural Discomfort What is the place of Burqas in the land of the free?
- How the French Government WorksRead this article if you are interested in finding out how the French government works.
- Franch Parliament Approves Ban on Burqa-style Islamic Face Veils
- Should it Be Legal to Prohibit the Wearing of Muslim Face Veils?
- Banning the Burqa: The Surprising Argument Surrounding Islamic Veils and Dress for...
- France to Ban Burqa but Build Giant Mosque
- French Lawmakers Expected to Pass Controversial Burqa Ban
- French President Nicholas Sarkozy Bids to Ban the Burqa
- France Likely to Ban Burqas Worn by Muslim Women





5 Comments
Post a CommentHi - your article popped up when I published mine on same issue - thought I'd stop by and say hi!
I agree with a lot of what you guys are saying. I have many friends in Europe and they have been telling me for years that many European countries have been struggling with how to assimilate immigrants into their society. It is a very complex issue and I do not think it is going away any time soon.
This is a very complicated issue because Europe is struggling with Muslim issues going back to the Danish cartoon of 2005. The main problem with Muslim traditions is that they cannot be separated from Islam nor can their legal policies. This makes everything that Muslims do suspect of political agendas.
Anyone can be hiding behind the burqa!! In these times of terrorists, it is for the safety of the people. Why would women want to hide their faces, anyway? Who the hell said that a muslim woman needs to hide her face? I don't think it is in the Quran. I think all European countries and the rest of the world should ban the burqas. Let them wear a scarf.
Good article. The burqa ban in France may be a controversial issue of course, but in the same time I find it fair. Muslim population from France are mainly originating from North-African countries -- Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, Libya, countries where French is spoken as official language or second language of communication. If these people want to live in France, they should be able to embrace French culture, French social habits, they should be able to adjust to French society. And if that means not wearing a burqa in public, then so be it.