Gay Rights: Why is Discrimination with Sexual Orientation Different Than with Race or Gender?

Kyle
Should gays have the right to marriage? This question is the topic of many debates and there is no clear cut answer. I believe that there are a few factors that can help determine what rights gays have in American society. While I do not know about the rest of the world I do know that in America there currently is no legislature defending gays from discrimination. I know that there are many people who feel very strongly that they should have their rights protected and there are also many people who feel they shouldn't have any rights.

I the past there have been laws passed to protect against discrimination because of race and sex. Something these characteristics have in common is that they are natural, people are born with the color skin they have and they are male or female. You have no choice whether you are white or black, or whether you are male or female. However, while many studies have been done no one knows for sure whether you are born gay or you choose to be gay. If it can be proven that homosexuality is not a choice then there is no argument about whether they should have protected rights or not. This does not mean that if it is determined homosexuality is a choice they should have no rights, it will just be harder to get them.

One question that should be looked at is whether or not being gay affects your abilities to do the same things as heterosexual people do. I believe that gays can do the same work just as well as anyone else. If there were an issue that they couldn't they could be discriminated against, but I don't think they have any real disadvantage.

Not allowing homosexual people to marry is a form of discrimination which makes it much harder for gay couples. They cannot receive the benefits that married people get because they can't get married. This affects many things such as health insurance; because they are not married employer health insurance will not cover both people in a homosexual relationship because they aren't technically a dependent. This is not fair and should be changed.

In the end, I believe the reason gays are still discriminated against and not protected by laws is because homosexuality is not understood. I cannot understand why anyone would be gay, but I still feel they deserve to have their rights protected. Whether it is a choice or genetic causes that make someone homosexual they do not deserve to be treated worse for their sexual orientation.

Published by Kyle

I am a real estate investor in Indiana. I have several units which I rent out. I am also a student at Indiana University, studying accounting, real estate, and sociology.  View profile

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Dave2/4/2008

    I can say as a straight man that my sexuality is not a choice. I don't have the option of being attracted to other men. I simply don't feel it. If someone told me the attraction I felt for women was wrong and I had to resist, i don't think I could do it. You simply don't choose who you are attracted to. I think anyone who can truely believe it is a choice probably has issues with their own orientation they need to resolve.

  • Rae12/24/2007

    well mr. pepper. i think you're dumb!

  • Jowel Marquez11/25/2007

    Well, we are all people. I don't get why some people should be discriminated either by gender, race or whatsoever.

  • Dewey R Mason II10/25/2007

    Oops, being BABTIST, sorry there, its late, err, early.
    Anyway, I'll stay out of your church, but you have to stay the hell outta my bedroom. Otherwise its gonna be a scrap.

  • Dewey R Mason II10/25/2007

    If being Gay is a choice, what difference does it make in whether or not they recieve protection under the law? Assume for arguments sake it is purly a choice to be made. So is being Baotist honey, as I was raised as such, but CHOSE to run like hell when I was old enough to see it for what it was. What religion one chooses to be is prtected, why not which sexual orientation one "Chooses" to be. Who cares if its a choice? If we get to pick and choose who gets rights, we loose ours.

  • Monique Finley10/5/2007

    I can't speak for anyone else, but I was born a lesbian. My arguement for GLBT rights is simple... I was raised the same way straight people are raised, same fairy tales. I want the same happy ending.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.