God Gives Jesus Camp an Oscar Nomination for Best Documentary
Is it God's Will that the Film Win an Oscar?
The documentary is an exemplary documentary in that there is no commentary from the filmmakers. I have no idea what their stance is on the subject, if they are from an Evangelical Christian background or nonreligious one. It is truly a documentary in the sense that only what is filmed is presented, no agreement or disagreement with what is being shown.
The only disagreement was from an Air America radio host who happened to be a former minister and against the particular type of Christianity being taught at this camp. These clips are probably the only things that didn't seem to work within the documentary. There wasn't equal time spent with the radio host, nor much explaining what exactly his views are. The film would have been just as well made and unbiased without them, if not more so. But he is as "intolerant" in his views as the children at the Christian camp are taught to be in theirs, just reversely so.
Jesus Camp documents a camp in North Dakota that children (and some of their families) go to to get closer to God. It is an evangelical Christian camp with guest speakers and a few select children speakers. The documentary focuses on a few children and camp director, their experiences at camp and follows them into their lives away from camp.
What is frightening is that this film is a documentary and these things are real. Don't get me wrong; I grew up Christian, that isn't what makes it frightening. But it is the extreme to which the people - the children - are taking their faith. They only listen to Christian music, watch Christian television, and read Christian books. They are taught science has no answers and is stupid. They are forming a bubble around their lives and worldview that can only prove to hurt them later. When they are in their teens and someone offers them a square, will they know enough to reject the offer or will they be so ignorant about life outside their bubble to not know and take it? There is a difference between having a strong faith and denying the existence of anything not a part of that faith.
At the camp, no messages of God's love are shared. Instead the speakers share messages of politics through a religious avenue - smashing mugs to demonstrate the break of power of evil on our government or duct taping mouths to demonstrate the value of life. The mix of religion and politics makes this film terrifying. Our future generations are growing up being fed this hodge-podge under the guise of Christ and not being taught to think for themselves. It is celebrated to be in a trance and speak in tongues or be so overwhelmed by emotions that children can barely breathe through their tears.
No longer are Christian children taught messages of the Good Samaritan or how faith as small as a mustard seed can move mountains. No longer is God our shepherd and we his herd. Now children are being raised to be warriors for Christ, part of God's army. Uncontrollable convulsions, hysterical tears, and speaking in tongues are badges of honor - the proof of one's faith.
But in showing all of this, Jesus Camp strangely has a tinge of hope about it. Hope that these children will grow up and become more compassionate in their passionate faith. Without saying a word, that is the only hope you can come away from the documentary thinking. We can hope these children give up their desire to be martyrs and instead hope to be beacons of light and hope, helping those in need - like the Christ they worship.
Published by Erin McMaster
I am a freelance filmmaker who likes to share my opinions on pop culture when given the time. View profile
- Conservative Radio Host Shelly Wynter Trumps McCain Supporter in Showdown on CNNThe Republican supporter who begged Senator John McCain to "Take It To Obama," stormed off the CNN set when conservative radio host, Shelley Wynter, questioned his support of McCain.
- A Critique of the Film Jesus Camp A critique on the movie Jesus Camp and Evangelicalism.
Bob Dylan Joins XM Radio: Music Legend Shines as First-Time Radio HostFor decades, he's been Bob Dylan, folk hero. Now it's time to get a taste of Bob Dylan, radio host.- Why Evangelical Christian Voters Will Not Abandon the Republican PartyMany pundits have predicted that evangelical Christians will abandon the Republicans this year, most likely by simply not voting. I say there is no way that will happen.
- The Biography of Delilah, Famous Syndicated Radio HostDo you listen to Delilah on the radio? When I'm writing in the evening, I enjoy listening to her show myself. Read this informative article and find out about the woman behind the voice!
- Summer Camp Changed My Life
- Jesus Camp: A Must See Film for Anyone Concerned About the Future of America
- Decaying Corpse of Missing Gay Former Radio Host Found in His Crawlspace
- Jesus Camp - Real Life Horror Film
- Jesus Camp: Exposing the Ironies of American Evangelicals
- Where Would Jesus Study? Choosing a Quality Evangelical Christian College or Unive...
- Evangelical Christian Women and Depression


3 Comments
Post a CommentI did see this film and I did think there was a political agenda attached to it by way of the the movie opening with the announcement of an open seat witht the judges and the closing of that seat being taken. The radio announcer did state his view as well when he commented on the scary possibility of evangelicals taking over the country. He was truly troubled by that thought. Also, your comment about what children are no longer being taught is pretty bold. This is one documentary showing one youth group in one denomination and during one week of summer camp at that. I would argue that the majority of children are learning of the Good Samaritan and other Bible stories as well as ways to live their lives as a Christian and what to avoid because of that lifestyle choice. I do agree with you that our children need to be taught about the world and not sheltered from it for the very reason you stated. But, don't you think we do need to teach them how to live rightly for the Lord and ho
Thank you for an informative article. I had not heard of this documentary until I happened upon your article here. I'll certainly put it on my list of movies to view. It is very scary to see how Christ's message can be so convoluted by so many, in so many ways. I gues it goes to show that we're all out here fighting the same fight that has been going on since the beginning of time. Great read and thanks for the head's up on this film. I gave you 5 stars - not just for a great article, but because Christians don't get enough good press and you were courageous in taking one.
I've seen this tape at the video store. Maybe I need to rent it after this review. I'm not sure how I feel about the subject itself until I do. But your article is well written and informative. Thank you!