Grammy Judges Jilt Justin Bieber for 'Unknown' Esperanza Spalding in Best New Artist Upset

Spalding First Ever Jazz Artist to Win Best New Artist Grammy

Nancy Tracy
With all of the egg-hatching, pluming feathers and other gimmickry at last night's Grammys, the stunning announcement of Esperanza Spalding (Esperanza who?) as Best New Artist of 2010 rocked the house more than Mick Jagger's jaunty swagger. Despite the fact that both Spalding and Bieber have a lot of hair, the difference between these two nominees for Best New Artist is like that of a National Geographic nature documentary vs. "Sarah Palin's Alaska." One is real; the other is made to seem real.

Like a bouncing tennis ball, the 53rd Annual Grammy Awards show sprang back and forth between highly manufactured musical pageantry and more organic, natural performances. The two ladies, for instance, Lady Gaga and Lady Antebellum, were prime examples of this duality. Lady Gaga dramatically emerged from an enormous egg to sing her "Born This Way;" Lady Antebellum female singer Hilary Scott sang the trio's Best Album winning song "Need You Now" straight up, as unadorned as a peahen.

You Tube phenomenon Bieber is an example of the more packaged musical performer of today. His every career move is calculated with the strategic precision of a military operation. Spalding, a child musical prodigy, took only a couple of voice lessons, confiding to Nu-Soul magazine, "(I) learned a lot from singing in the shower." Her natural hairdo and choice of the non-sexy bass as her musical instrument shows she is more about being authentic to herself than being a pop star.

While pop music wannabes perform on MTV, Spalding shows up in unexpected places. She was hand-picked by President Cool himself, Barack Obama, to perform at his 2009 Nobel Prize awards ceremony in Oslo, Norway.

When she performed on the CBS Late Show with David Letterman, as shown on You Tube, an awestruck Letterman told musical pal Paul Shaffer, "You were right Paul. (She's) the coolest person we've ever had on the show." That coolness factor did not escape the Grammy judges, who dribbled past the popular Bieber to spotlight the uniquely talented Spalding, a self-described "jazz nerd," according to The New York Times and the first ever jazz artist to win the Grammys Best New Artist award.

Bieber fans were aghast at the Grammy judges' choice, mistakenly "beliebing" that one wins a Grammy based on how many Twitter followers they have, according to Popeater. "So the Esperanza Spalding has only 8 thousand followers on twitter and how many does justin bieber has?" tweeted a bugged Bieber fan.

Though Spalding and Bieber are both talented performers, Bieber is more like Twinkies to Spalding's made-from-scratch cake. Last night, it appears, the Grammy judges proved they were hungry for something fresh and natural.

More From This Contributor:
Camille Grammer: Victim or Vixen?
Can Willow Smith Avoid Child Star Curse?
Oprah and Madonna: Can Celebrities Really Be Spiritual?


Note: This was written by a Yahoo! contributor. Join the Yahoo! Contributor Network here to start publishing your own articles.

Published by Nancy Tracy - Featured Contributor in Arts & Entertainment

Nancy Tracy is a Yahoo! Featured Contributor for arts & entertainment. She enjoys writing about a variety of topics from psychology to politics to popular culture. Her article on "Transient Global Amnesia" w...  View profile

17 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Thomas Lane2/21/2011

    I really liked the Hilary Scott simile.

  • Theresa Wiza2/20/2011

    While I'm not a fan of jazz, I heard her voice on the Grammys. She was sensational. Justin Bieber is everywhere. I even saw him on a recent C.S.I. episode. It's good to know that you don't have to have yourself packaged and promoted to get noticed as a great talent.

  • L. R. Laverde-Hansen2/17/2011

    Revenge of the jazz nerds! Great work - as usual.

  • Claire Luna-Pinsker2/15/2011

    Bieber is a teeny bopper idol, Spalding crosses generations with music that's more mature and vocally challenged. Thanks for sharing.

  • Eric Hetvile2/15/2011

    What a scandal! "Spalding" doesn't even rhyme with "fever"!

  • Abby Greenhill2/15/2011

    Nice job.

  • Charlotte Kuchinsky2/15/2011

    I honestly don't get the hype about Bieber anyway.

  • Anne Stjern2/14/2011

    I'm a so pleased that an true artist was chosen to receive the award over a stage mother's Youtube creation. The kid may be cute but 'artist', I don't think so. Thank goodness for judges with an ear for music!

  • L B Woodgate2/14/2011

    Nice report Nancy. I love it when Grammy judges make adult choices.

  • Mike Oberg2/14/2011

    Popularity doesn't make you talented. I admit I had heard of Spalding before last night, but I have heard her now and she is very good!

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.