GWU/Battleground Poll: John McCain Down by One

Mark Whittington
The GWU/Battleground Poll, run by Republican strategist Ed Goeas of The Tarrance Group and Democrat Celinda Lake of Lake Research Partners, has John McCain just one point behind Barack Obama, the two candidates at 48% and 47%.

Just a few days ago, the same poll had Barack Obama ahead of John McCain by thirteen points. How to account for the sudden and massive tightening of the polls?

First, the initial shock of the current economic crisis seems to have faded a little and people have had a little time to digest it. It is a general rule that people tend to blame the party in power, which is presumed to in this case be the Republicans since George W. Bush is in the White House, for economic problems. Hence, Barack Obama has ridden a wave of popularity for the past few weeks.

But people also are coming to realize the heavy involvement of Democrats, such as Barack Obama, in causing the economic crisis. They are also noting that economic times have been pretty good under President Bush up until the capture of the Congress by the Democrats.

Two other incidents have occurred to shake public confidence in the ability of Barack Obama to be President. The first had to do with a man now famously known as Joe the Plumber. The second came out of the mouth of Barack Obama's own running mate, Joe Biden.

When Barack Obama accosted Joe Wurzelbacher in his front yard in Toledo, Ohio, Joe had the temerity to ask the candidate a question. What's up with you wanting to raise my taxes? Barack Obama had a telling response. Barack Obama wants to raise taxes in order to "spread the wealth." In other words, take money from some people to give to others. In other words, socialism.

The second incident took place more recently when Senator Joe Biden announced to a group of campaign doners that Barack Obama would be "tested" within six months of becoming President by the enemies of the United States. Biden further suggested that Obama's response would not be entirely popular.

Both incidents played into the anxiety people feel about Democrats. They tend to be foreign policy weaklings and economic bullies. They'll appease the enemies of the United States while stripping people of their income in order to give it to people they prefer to have it.

Most Americans find both approaches more than a little off putting. Hence the collapse of Barack Obama in the GWU/Battleground Poll and his slower decline in most other polls. That means that the confident prediction of the inevitability of President Obama may have been a bit premature.

Source: Battleground Poll, Realclearpolitics

Published by Mark Whittington

Mark R. Whittington is a writer residing in Houston, Texas. He is the author of The Last Moonwalker, Children of Apollo, Dark Sanction, and Nocturne. He has written numerous articles, some for the Washington...   View profile

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Paul 10/30/2008

    The GWU/battleground Poll has been one of the thy most accurate in elections,in the range of 1%...it's bi-partisan..I like to go by polls that have showed past great accuracy.

  • Stacy T 10/22/2008

    The fact that the Battleground Poll consistently seems to favor McCain far more than the other polls has already been looked into. It seems that the Battleground poll interviews comparatively huge numbers of elderly people without properly weighting their results to account for the numbers of the overall population, like most polls do. it's not surprising that they interview a disproportionate number of elderly, since they're easier to reach at home, and younger people have cell phones rather than land lines. But most polls adjust for these problems in their final calculations, and Battleground doesn't. So only rely on the Battleground polls if you think that over 30% of voters will be over 65, and only 29% will be 18-44, despite the fact that voters in 2004 were 19% over 65, and 43% were 18-44. AND this doesn't account for the remarkable uptick in youth voting registration in 2008.

    http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2008/09/whats-wrong-with-battleground-poll.html

  • rpfree 10/21/2008

    Battleground is a bi-partisan poll and is self policing. Battleground has by far been the most accurate poll since 1992 (last four elections), less than 1% every time. And I am a Democrat we must all face realities. Check it out...

    http://www.tarrance.com/files/TTG-Vote-Projections-and-Results.pdf

  • Literary Corner Cafe 10/21/2008

    I agree with the poster below me. I tend to trust Pew Research as well, and any poll that has McCain down by only one point is, as the poster below has said, simply wishful thinking.

  • Rrrrriiigggghhhhhttttt 10/21/2008

    Or it could be a huge stretch from a very questionable poll. I tend to trust Pew Research, as statistical research is all they do, and their poll out today has Obama ahead by 13 points.

    One poll showing McCain down by one is simply wishful thinking.

  • Kim Linton 10/21/2008

    Very well written as always Mark.

  • K. Karl 10/21/2008

    I'm with you Sadie. I get more news from Mark than the news channels!

  • Sadie Kay 10/21/2008

    I think I will just stop watching Fox and read your news. I like yours better!

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.