Have We Given Away Our Freedom to Celebrate Christmas?
Including a Quote from Ben Stein, a Jew, on the Celebration of Christmas
While Wal-Mart had many customers while we were in there, it just didn't seem like Christmas. Being busy, I didn't think a lot about it, but there just seemed to be an overall depression among people, unlike any Christmas I can remember. For some reason it reminded me of being in a store one time when the power went out.
The girl who checked me out was someone I knew well, and as I approached the check-out stand after putting all my purchases up on the belt, she sighed loudly and said, "I am so tired."
I said that yes, I had just been thinking how tired they all must be by now.
She said, "Yes, and they've already let all the Christmas help go. I feel so sorry for them because I'm sure they all needed the money."
I asked why they had been let go and she said, "Low sales."
Having seen the store full of people, I found that to be a strange answer. So I asked why the sales were low.
She said, "No Christmas spirit, no music, no Christmas trees up, nothing in here to even remind anyone it is Christmas."
Of course there were Christmas trees for sale, but no others elsewhere in the store as there have always been before. Seems the manager had decided against Christmas decorations and music for fear of "offending someone" and perhaps getting the store sued.
I asked if all the Wal-Mart stores were doing the same and she said she wasn't sure, that someone had said they had called the main office and they were leaving it to the discretion of each store manager.
All I know is, Christmas around here is different from any time I can remember in my life. And I don't like the change.
Driving home, I saw nothing to remind me of Christmas till I reached our hometown. A couple in our church owns a tire shop and on a big sign out front they had put, "Happy Birthday, Jesus." One of my friends said the city has put up the Christmas decorations on the light poles, but in my depressed state, I failed to see them.
Turning into our driveway, I didn't see the big lighted cross in our 9-foot arched window, with the cross outlined in red and the arch outlined in gold lights. The reason I didn't see it was because I've been too lazy this year to put it up.
I put up a minimum of decorations this year because I just didn't want to have to turn around and put them all away afterwards. I tell myself that it's been a hard year, that I haven't felt all that well and have been concerned about my daughter, but what it all boils down to is that I've just become really lazy.
I never before thought that whether or not I did any decorating made any difference to anyone else. But after that experience yesterday, I know it does.
The thing that really bothers me is that it seems everyone around here has succumbed to the pressure put on us by the ones that might be offended.
Look guys. Christmas is a Christian holiday and as Americans we have a right to celebrate it as we always have. We don't ask the Muslims or anyone of any other religion to neglect celebrating their holidays. The atheists don't have their own holiday, except maybe the first of April, but that's their choice. A business has a right to put up any decorations they please and play any music they please, within reason, without fear of harassment. Every time we give in to fear of a lawsuit or persecution because someone is "offended," we're giving away our freedom as Americans.
I was recently sent an email that contained a quote from Ben Stein, a Jew. It was so noteworthy that I thought I would pass it on for anyone who hasn't seen it to share.
Please read (below) and enjoy it. As for me, I'm going to get up from here and dig out that big cross and put it in my front window. Then I plan to hunt up some more lights and decorations and put them out to tell the neighbors and the world that I'm exercising my rights as a free American to celebrate the most important holiday in the Christian faith.
I wish each and every one of you a very merry Christmas. And to Ben Stein, Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukah, and thank you very much!
(The following was written by Ben Stein and recited by him on CBS Sunday Morning Commentary.)
My confession:
I am a Jew, and every single one of my ancestors was Jewish. And it does not bother me even a little bit when people call those beautiful lit up, bejeweled trees, Christmas trees. I don't feel threatened. I don't feel discriminated against. That's what they are, Christmas trees.
It doesn't bother me a bit when people say, 'Merry Christmas' to me. I don't think they are slighting me or getting ready to put me in a ghetto. In fact, I kind of like it.. It shows that we are all brothers and sisters celebrating this happy time of year. It doesn't bother me at all that there is a manger scene on display at a key intersection near my beach house in Malibu . If people want a creche, it's just as fine with me as is the Menorah a few hundred yards away.
I don't like getting pushed around for being a Jew, and I don't think Christians like getting pushed around for being Christians. I think people who believe in God are sick and tired of getting pushed around, period. I have no idea where the concept came from, that America is an explicitly atheist country. I can't find it in the Constitution and I don't like it being shoved down my throat.
Or maybe I can put it another way: where did the idea come from that we should worship celebrities and we aren't allowed to worship God as we understand Him? I guess that's a sign that I'm getting old, too. But there are a lot of us who are wondering where these celebrities came from and where the America we knew went to.
Published by Pat Burroughs
How to Pick Your Own Last Minute Christmas Trees from a Tree LotDo you know how to pick your own perfect Christmas trees? They should be green, have most of their limbs, and preferably not rain down pine needles when you give them a little s...- Artificial Aluminum Christmas TreesAluminum Christmas trees are making a comeback, both newly made and vintage aluminum trees that have gathered dust in attics. Here's how to find and buy an artificial aluminum Christmas tree .... but first, some of th...
- When Christmas Trees AttackHaving never celebrated Christmas as a kid I knew nothing about Christmas trees and the dangers of them.
Fresh Real Pre-Cut Christmas Trees - Milwaukee, WisconsinBest places to buy Fresh Real Pre-Cut Christmas Trees in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
The History of Christmas TreesA quick history of how Christmas trees became tradition.
- Parents, Ben Stein is Protecting Your Children!
- Ben Stein
- How to Celebrate Christmas with a Jesse Tree: Week Two
- Top 5 Places to Buy Fiber Optic Christmas Trees for Families
- Best Deals on Christmas Trees in Wilmington, North Carolina
- Real Christmas Trees: A Guide to the 3 Most Popular Types
- Top Three Potted Christmas Trees




23 Comments
Post a CommentAgree with you, Pat, our freedom is not negotiable. After all we were all born free. Although, the vast majority, millions, of South Africans only obtained our freedom just over fifteen years ago. But as you will as a christian agree that, we are only free, if the Son has set us free. Then, we are free indeed. So whether we celebrate Xmas or not, we are free to do so or not to do so.
Such intelligent and meaningful writing, Pat! Thank you..
Zach, are you a Catholic and don't think you've been pushed around? I have nothing against Catholics. I think as a group they're pushed around at times, and by the way, I consider Catholics to be Christians, as they definitely believe in Jesus Christ.
Ah, well the Wal-Mart situation was a bit different than I imagined then. If this was a decision made privately by a manager, that isn't the same as it being a rule to maximize profits. I certainly agree that he should be cooperating with the Salvation Army, and that if he denied them access because of their Christmas theme he is being absolutely ridiculous. I have, by the way, walked in a Christian's shoes. Nobody has ever interfered with my religious practice, and the only disrespect I have ever found came from Evangelicals who do not approve of Catholicism. I have no doubt, however, that you have a reason behind your belief that Christians are pushed around, so I suppose we'll have to agree to disagree.
And by the way, Merry Christmas!
Thanks, Zach. Yesterday I was back at that same Wal-Mart and a different checker, who I didn't know, wished us a Merry Christmas and said the manager would probably try to fire her if he heard her say it, but she was going to say it to everyone she checked out. And she had had many thank her for it. She said it was the manager's choice not to have any music or decorations, and that she guessed I had noticed no Salvation Army bell ringer out front, as the manager wouldn't allow that either. My niece says the Wal-Mart in the town she lives in has it all, and two other Wal-Marts we've been in lately did at least have the bell ringer out front. So it's a manager thing, not a corporation thing. As for Christians not being pushed around, you should just walk in the shoes of a Christian for a while and see.
As for Stein's comments, he's right not to like people getting pushed around because of their religion. He seems to imagine, however, that Christians find themselves getting "pushed around" for being Christian more than any other group find themselves pushed around. It just isn't so.
You all seem like perfectly nice folks, but this is a bit silly. We're in a recession; the sales at that Wal-Mart are bad because sales everywhere are bad. The girl at the cash register may have thought it was the lack of decorations, but she was mistaken. I promise you, that corporation has spent a fortune working out what decorations, if any, increase sales. If they though it would net an extra dollar in profits, the halls would be decked. Privately owned businesses are not obligated to purchase decorations and pay to have their employees put up just because some people like them. Some stores do it, others don't. Welcome to America.
As for the lawsuit fear, there isn't one. Courts don't punish people for their private decorations. I don't know whether fewer homes are decorated, but if people choose not to, they're not giving up a right. They're choosing not to exercise one in this particular instance.
As for Stein's comments, he's right not to like people getting pushed
I"m glad you added Ben Stein's take on this because it added so much to this article. I do think store managers are scared and confused in this economy (and some have told me so) because they don't know what their customers want. THey are confused and so are the customers. There are secular people who celebrate Christmas but not as a religious holiday. Materialism runs rampant. People just don't know what to make of it all. Excellent, thought-provoking article.
I agree way to much emphasis is put on pleasing a minority of people. I agree that we should celebrate the peace and love of the season. And I guess I'll get off my lazy you know what and put my decorations out, too.