The following is a favorite peanut butter fudge recipe that is very easy to make as your homemade Valentine's Day candy. You can use any homemade fudge recipe, or even a recipe for marshmallow treats. If you use marshmallow treats as your homemade Valentine's Day candy, just follow the recipe as directed then press the mixture into the greased heart shaped cookie cutters.
Peanut Butter Fudge
2 cups granulated sugar
2/3 cup milk
1 cup marshmallow creme
1 cup creamy peanut butter
2 teaspoons vanilla
Mix the sugar and the milk together in a two quart saucepan. Stir well until the sugar is dissolved. Cook to soft-ball stage, 235 degrees Fahrenheit. (If you do not have a candy thermometer, you can use the cold water method. To test the homemade fudge, you will need a small bowl with cold water in it. Drop a spoonful of the mixture into the cold water. Use your finger to push the candy into a ball. If it forms a soft ball that holds it's shape in the water, it has reached the soft ball stage.) Remove from heat. Stir in fluff, peanut butter, and vanilla. Pour into greased heart shaped cookie cutters. Cool completely. Gently lift each one off the wax paper, and wrap in colorful plastic wrap.
Published by Pam Freer
Pam considers herself to be a free spirit, prefering to march to a different drummer. She can often be found scrounging around thrift stores and yard sales. She also has a love for animals (thus a vegetari... View profile
- How to Make a Heart Shaped Cookie on Valentine's DayValentine's Day is not complete with out getting those delicious heart shaped cookies. In order for anyone to get those delicious heart shaped cookies someone has got to make them. Why not let it be you?
- Craft Valentine's Day Candy Flower TreatsChildren who wish to give a sweet treat to all their friends on Valentine's Day will enjoy making this candy flower treat. Inexpensive enough to make for an entire class, this craft is made from a lollipop and an...
- The Best Valentine's Day Candy Choices for People Who Hate ChocolateEven though you may be counting down the days for your chocolate truffle fix, your valentine may not be so excited. If your sweetheart isn't quite so sweet on chocolate any time of year, here are the top Valentine's D...
- Guilt-Free Valentine's Day CandyChocolates, cookies, and cakes are all typical Valentine's Day treats. But, did you know there are guilt-free options you can choose for your partner and yourself?
- Alternatives to Valentine's Day CandyValentine's Day is a time for flowers, romantic dinners, and heart-shaped boxes of candy, or is it? Do you really have to surprise your partner with the same old box of Valentine's Day candy every year?
- Merciless Murder: A True St. Valentine's Day Tale
- Valentine's Day on a Budget
- The Top Places to Eat Homemade Ice Cream in Newton, Massachusetts
- Homemade Valentine's Day Chocolates Anyone Can Make
- Valentine's Day Apron Craft Project
- Create Valentine's Day Candy Gift Pots
- How to Make a Valentine's Day Candy Card
- Skip all those fancy boxes full of expensive chocolates, and make your own Valentine's Day candy.
You can pour your homemade fudge into greased heart shaped cookie cutters.



