How Receptive Are You to New Ideas?
Most People Think that They Are More Receptive Than Their Boss Is
The results indicate that most people consider themselves to be much more receptive to new ideas than their bosses are. So whereas 95% of people think that they would welcome or consider ideas from outside their department, only 77% thought that their manager would.
If they had implemented a new policy and someone suggested there might be a better way to do the whole thing, then 52% of respondents would consider the suggestion carefully and be prepared to try it. However they thought that under similar circumstances only 18% of bosses would do the same. Similarly when it comes to implementing other people's ideas, 94% of respondents said they would give the credit to the person who came up with the idea. But only 73% thought their boss would do so; 27% thought the boss would claim the credit.
When faced with a difficult problem for some time respondents believed that they were more likely to look outside their department for ideas (43%) than their managers were (24%). They thought that the managers were more likely to ask the department to make more suggestions or to try some more of their own ideas. The most common things that were seen to be preventing new ideas from being adopted were lack of time and money, poor communication and a variety of cultural issues including risk aversion and fear of failure. A picture of poor leadership in this area emerges.
Overall people see their managers as being less open to new ideas than they are. This begs the question - do people become less receptive as they move up the management chain or is it a perception issue? Do we view ourselves as more receptive than we really are? Are we just as bad as our bosses but we don't see it?
Click here to view the full report.
Paul Sloane leads workshops on creativity and lateral thinking
Published by Paul Sloane
I am a Speaker & Author of books on lateral thinking puzzles, leadership & innovation. I help organisations to improve creativity and innovation. I give keynote talks and I facilitate brainstorms and worksh... View profile
- Coaching Youth Soccer: How Does a Youth Soccer Player Learn?To be effective when coaching youth soccer, it is important that the coach has an understanding of how a young player learns. The youth soccer coach needs to be aware of the following factors before he starts coachin...
- From Movie to YuppieMovies, doctors, gays, and yuppies. Silverlake is not your ordinary city. It is a uniquely neutral entity which resembles a buffer zone between Los Angeles to the east and the San Fernando Valley to the north. This ne...
- 5 Things to Love About the Pacific NorthwestSome of the best things the Pacific Northwest has to offer.
How to Knit for Your Family's Mental HealthHandwork such as knitting or whittling opens doors to talking and teaches children valuable lessons about work.- 8 Easy Ways to Supplement Your Craft Income While Doing What You Enjoy!Do you sell your crafts? Wouldn't it be nice to have some ways to supplement your income when crafts sales are slow? Give these ideas a try!
- Poll: Pharmacists Should Prescribe Drugs
- How to Use YouTube to Get More Visitors, Sales and Free Advertising for Your Website
- How to Succeed with Your New Years Resolutions
- Crafting a Non-Fiction Proposal: How Much Do You Know About Your Competition?
- Are You Thinking About Getting a Tattoo?
- Think Your Way to Good Health!
- What Does Your Handwriting Say About You?
2 Comments
Post a CommentTal, I guess you are right. Sex, driving and creativity - three things that everyone thinks they are good at!
Paul,
I believe that if you'd reverse the question, and ask manager whether their employees are open to new ideas, you'll discover that the managers would rate themselves higher than the employees.
In general, people rate themselves higher than they would rate others (in a general category) - especially if asked on creativity, originality, and innovation. Obviously, if you ask them about a particular individual to compare against, they might be more objective. But when generalizing, they'll probably rate themselves higher.
What would be interesting to see is what makes employees MORE accurate in their perceptions about themselves. So ask them about their perception, find some objective way to check that perception vs. reality, and see who has a more accurate perception vs. others. Then you know who is "telling the truth". :-)
Cheers,
Tal