How Will Christians Respond to Dumbledore's Coming Out?

Chadd De Las Casas
Will the literary industry's world be turned upside down by the revelation that Professor Dumbledore, the head of Hogwart's School for Wizards and Witches, prefers the company of males? It seems unlikely - and I personally think it's an excellent example of literary maturity on the part of J.K. Rowling. However, the book series has long been criticized by Christians across America, feeling that they are attempting to lure children into Satanism, Paganism, Wicca, and Black Magic. Rowling has denied these claims - telling the Associated Press rather that the book series encourages people to "question authority".

In the midst of a national clash over the ability for gays to marry to begin with, how will these hard line Christian groups react to this revelation? Fundamentally it has clearly had absolutely no impact on the story telling - save for an instance where the Associate Press reports that the film version of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince had to have a script edit due to a reference to a past female love. Though speculation has constantly been abound, this should not necessarily be considered unique to the Head of Hogwarts, after all, the internet is flooded with Spock-Kirk fan fiction of a questionable nature.

Many have read the book series and had never been clued into the head master's sexuality - perhaps because the position he played was not one where physical or emotional relationships had any real bearing on the over all story. His position of dignity was much like the officer in a battalion - what he did in his own time, behind closed doors, mattered very little and was never brought up by those beneath him. What mattered was that he was the final authority in his specific school.

This made J.K. Rowling's strict adherence to this otherwise unknown trait of such a beloved character impressive in many ways - as she stayed true to her character both on and off the pages.

But it is more than a little humorous to imagine the imminent cries and wallows of those who already believe that the book has the sole intent of corrupting their children. The Malleus Malificarium does not precisely have an edict on how to deal with homosexual headmaster wizards - though it may be easy to assume that these parents will read this as an indication that their children are at the risk of themselves becoming homosexual. Much like the accusation that video games induce violence, there is a belief that children exposed to such a character will quickly don their broomsticks, wizard hats, and begin singing Barbara Streissand.

Perhaps the most amusing thing about that, however, is that the sexuality of Dumbledore is never truly brought into consideration except outside the "fourth wall". Without the inquiry of a curious reader at a reading outside the book, this revelation may very well have died with the author in the future.

As a Christian, I personally urge fellow Christians to look upon it for what it is - an excellent piece of literature and an achievement of a mature author to remain so loyal to a character as such. However, as is the case with the entire series, it will probably befall the same claims that it has always befallen.

I predict Dumbledore being transformed in many peoples' eyes being transformed into Ray Buckey - and Hogwarts into the McMartin's Pre-School for Wizards and Witches.

Published by Chadd De Las Casas

I was born in Valencia, California in 1987. It's ironic that I turned out to be a writer, since my first exposure to it was an essay about why I hate writing. I am also the owner of the Content Producers Wiki.  View profile

85 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Leseratte12/28/2007

    Rowling couples human beings with monsters. But Gryffindors and Slytherins may not come together. Blablabla, Mrs. Rowling.

  • Heather B.12/28/2007

    If only human beings had genitalia then explain Hagrid's parentage: giant mother, human father.

  • Keri Withington12/2/2007

    I had already written an article about this when I read yours. The biggest surprise, to me, was that people were so shocked.

  • Dawn Thompson11/29/2007

    Does it matter if he was gay? I am Christian and I do not care one way or the other if he was or not. Was Rowling trying to stir up some controversy among Christians? Was it a publicity stunt? Why do that in the end? Harry Potter has been popular even without the "gay" part.

  • D.S. Williamson11/17/2007

    Good article, but I'm confused. I thought only human beings had genitalia in Harry's world. Without genitalia, can you really be considered gay or straight? Maybe Rowling is confused too...

  • Kathy Weaver11/14/2007

    I appreciated your article because you are Christian and intelligent/open-minded about the Harry Potter issue! I enjoyed reading this...thanks!

  • Thomas Beckham11/7/2007

    Honestly I have to question whether Rowling knew from the beginning that Dumbledore was gay or did it become convenient at the end of the Harry Potter series. Because, for the life of me I never saw anything about the whole series that even comes close to hinting that he was, which makes me think that maybe she didn't know herself. And I am sure I am not alone on this, or else it wouldn't be such a big surprise to a world of Harry Potter fans. Just me thinking, but to your article, I know christians who bashed the series in the beginning and now they have the entire collection, so conformity does play a role, I believe. Good article.

  • Kelly Renea Russ11/6/2007

    I'm about two chapters shy of finishing book 7 and I haven't seen a need to think of Dumbledore as gay. It doesn't really make any difference to the plot line, which is what I care about. I just want to read a good, entertaining book.

  • Colojuno11/6/2007

    I am so glad to have read your article! I am Christian, and I LOVED the books. I encouraged my children to read them. NOT ONCE did I think of Dumbledore as gay. It wasn't the point of the stories. I think there are too many things out there that people don't want to really see is happening, so they take something like this, and make a huge deal out of it.

  • Chadd De Las Casas11/5/2007

    Someone will have to explain to me how answering a question in an open forum is considered a publicity stunt. I truly think some people see situations in their own contexts, rather than the actual contexts in which they occurred.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.