1. Be from the South. So far, each American Idol winner has been from the South: Texas, Oklahoma, Alabama, and North Carolina. This year, only one final contender is from the South - Melinda Doolittle, from Tennessee - but she's very strong. There is a theory that this is because Southerners are more likely to have text messaging capability for voting. I think it has a lot more to do with #2 --
2. Sing in church every Sunday. Every American Idol winner to date has recounted stories of singing in church. This makes sense. There are few other places we go in our daily lives where singing has a large part. In church, American Idol hopefuls can also get professional help; most churches of any size have ministers or assistants with musical training or even music degrees who can teach aspiring young singers the proper way to breathe and project. And in the South, an awful lot of young people go to church.
3. Have an outgoing personality. To win American Idol, you must stand out from the rest of the group. Every single winner to date has had a unique and outstanding personality, seeming a little larger than life. There has been great variation in those personalities - the girl-next-door, the goofy guy, the fierce diva - but every single one has seemed to exaggerate the already-existing personality.
4. You must show growth over the show, both in your singing talent, onstage persona, and glamourous appearance. Looking at every American Idol winner so far, it is amazing how different they look at the end of the show when compared to the beginning. Carrie Underwood went from somewhat plain, though cheerful, to an adorable girl-next-door. Fantasia went from a sort of ghetto-chic to polished glamour. And if Jennifer Hudson had not persisted in wearing her friend's fashion designs - which alas did not flatter her - she might have won American Idol as well as her much-more-impressive Oscar.
5. You must be supportive of your fellow singers, but you also must know the value of your own talent. There are three basic types of singers that make it to the finals: the spoiled self-centered divas (male and female), the very supportive admirers of all the other singers, and the singers who are supportive and loving of their competitors, but who focus primarily on their own developing talents. The third type - nice, but focused - seem to be the ones who win.
6. You must have genuine talent, and have nurtured it. Every winner of American Idol so far has been a brilliant and talented young singer. Most of them have had some professional training. Only by having the great singing tools to begin with and by learning how to use them properly can you win the American Idol title.
Published by Jamie K. Wilson
Jamie K. Wilson is the wife of a US sailor and mother of two teen boys, one Marine, and two beautiful baby girls. The family hails from Louisville, Kentucky originally. View profile
American Idol Winner Taylor Hicks Proves Why He Won A review of the debut album by the American Idol.- Former American Idol Winner Ruben Studdard WedsThe wedding of American Idol second winner Ruben Studdard.
- American Idol Winner Jordin Sparks Signs with Record LabelThe producers of American Idol will be releasing a new show this fall, involving bands instead of individual singers. Before that happens though, there is news about the most recent winner of American Idol, Jordin Spa...
- Review of ZZ Top with David Cook on American Idol The bearded duo, and drummer Frank Beard, performed "Sharp Dressed Man" with American Idol winner David Cook, whose own beard has a lot of catching up to do.
- David Cook is Named American Idol Winner on May 21stDavid Cook was proclaimed this year's American Idol at the Nokia Theater in Los Angeles on Wednesday night, May 21st.
- Ranking the American Idol Winners
- Who Will Win American Idol?
- Why Jordin Sparks Might Win American Idol
- Top 10 American Idol Fan Sites: Official and Nonofficial
- American Idol Winner Ruben Studdard Got Engaged to Girlfriend Surata Zuri McCants
- American Idol Malakar: The Sanjaya, Sunjaya, Sanjay and Sunjiya Express to Success
- American Idol: Season Five
- American Idol winners tend to have a few things in common.
- Nice guys tend to finish first in American Idol.
- In the end, it comes down to both talent and polish.

9 Comments
Post a CommentInteresting take on this show.
I loved Melinda. I like Jordan as well, but feel Melinda was the better singer overall. Great anaylsis.
I never thought about them evolving over the course of the show. Good idea for an article.
Excellent analysis.
I think it's just too close to call! I use Dialidol.com all the time because I just can't wait for the results; for the semifinals, they couldn't call it either, though Melinda scored highest by just a little bit. This is a very interesting year. (and yes, Jordin is the most adorable six-footer I have ever seen!)
Thanks fer the info
Even though Jordin isn't from the south, I'm banking on her winning. Even though I absolutely loved Melinda and Lakeisha (sp?), Jordin has been my pick from the beginning. She's cute, sweet,kind, witty, has a beatiful voice, and also has a great personality. Blake, on the other hand, let's face it, he's different and all, but he really wasn't in the same league as the top three girls. I would really be shocked if he won it.
I thought Melinda had it too! Oh, well, just means that my #1 requirement to win isn't always true; the winner will be from Arizona or Washington State. GREAT show last night, though.
Good article! It really is amazing how the show takes people set one way and makes them into something else America can fall in love with. This is a tough one now, I really thought Melinda was going to make it to the finals.