How to Win Any Argument Without Blaming

Scott Schlimmer
How to Win Any Argument Without Blaming Tip #1: Blame Yourself

First, blame yourself. This may sound odd, but you will gain a big advantage by blaming yourself. Rest assured, your opponent is going to blame you. By blaming yourself, you will have a better idea of what's going on in your opponent's head, and will be able to anticipate the things he or she says.

Now your instinct will be to blame yourself, decide the reasoning is weak, and then go on to blaming the opponent. This doesn't do the trick, and only hurts you. Your opponent won't stop there. You need to go through the reasoning and blame yourself, even if it does seem invalid.

You'll be surprised how many times you'll blame yourself, think it through, and then realize that your initial thoughts weren't as correct as you thought. You can't always be right, so this step will help you realize when you're wrong. You haven't argued your side yet, so you can quietly back down without losing face. Part of winning every argument is not taking place in arguments you're going to lose! It's important you think this through before arguing; otherwise you'll be locked into your position and cannot back down without losing face. (Ethical side note: If you realize you are wrong, at any point, please stop arguing.)

Finally, by blaming yourself, you can better consider (and of course refute) what your opponent is saying.

How to Win Any Argument Without Blaming Tip #2: Don't Talk, Listen

In too many arguments, one side says something, then the other side says something else, and then monologue circles into oblivion. This doesn't work, so you won't do this.

Instead, you won't talk at the beginning. Your opponent has some points in his or her head, and will want to express these points. Until the person has expressed these points and believes you understand them, that person will not listen very well to your points. Nor will the person accept your points, regardless of how technically correct you are.

So listen. Listen until your opponent doesn't want to talk anymore. Find out everything they think. Ask questions, but make sure these are genuine questions to gain more information, not challenges disguised as questions. Aside from calming and disarming your opponent, your listening will give you a great deal of information on your opponent. You can use this information to better form your argument.

Also, reiterate the person's points often. This will show you that you're listening, which will cause them to better listen to you. Also, it will show that you understand the person, which makes your arguments appear stronger (in fact, understanding your opponent's arguments probably truly makes your arguments stronger).

Finally, agree with your opponent as much as you can. If necessary, find the most insignificant thing to agree with. Once you agree with them, they'll be more likely to agree with you. The more of your opponent's points you can agree with, the better.

How to Win Any Argument Without Blaming Tip #3: State Your Case, But Not Too Soon

Once the opponent feels heard, you've agreed, and the opponent realizes you understand where they're coming from...then, and only then, should you start stating your case.

It's probably wise to repeat their points that are relevant. Say how you understand where they're coming from. You just want them to see where you're coming from. The more you can integrate their words and their points in your case, the more your case will feel like their own. This will help you "win".

How to Win Any Argument Without Blaming Tip #4: I think

Try to stay away from "I think..." statements. These words water down your points, and can easily be refuted with an opposing "but I think..."

Finally, try to genuinely care about what the opponent has to say. You can't fake this, nor can you fake the listening and the understanding. The best way to win an argument is to genuinely care what the opponent has to say, truly consider it in your opinion, and then form your opinion accordingly.

Published by Scott Schlimmer

Keep thinking big and advancing the world's knowledge!  View profile

25 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Scott S4/1/2007

    Thanks for the compliment!

  • Murielle Stephenson3/27/2007

    Hey, I really liked this one Scott. It is true, after all why is thre such a need on our part to win an argument? And as you saaid, if you disarm the person by taking the blame you win, without ever arguing. Great advise.

  • Scott S3/13/2007

    Diana: Please re-read. I'm not advocating that anybody take the blame or become a scapegoat. Stacey: Thank you for the compliment!

  • Stacey P.3/13/2007

    This is an amazing article! Thanks for the advice, I think these tips will help me to communicate better with my boyfriend!

  • Diana3/6/2007

    to the contrary, if you continue to take blame, even for what your not responsible for, you could be made a scapegoat, and this can be bad, because once you start taking blame for everything, you can start to think you are responsible for everything, especially what is not even yours.

  • Scott S3/6/2007

    T.P. - That's very interesting. I'm glad I could help reinforce! I wonder if I should read Gray's book. However, I would think these tips would work equally well with men and women. I'm curious how Gray included them in a book highlighting differences in men and women. Good look building that foundation. From your proactive start, I'm sure you'll do well. Tina: I'm glad you liked the tips!

  • Tina Wettin3/6/2007

    Great tips.

  • T.P. Lentz3/6/2007

    It's interesting that I happened to stumble onto this article today... I've been reading "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus" in a hope of better understanding myself and the woman I've become quite attached to... she's a most important part of my life, and for the first time ever, I really want to take the time necessary to build a solid foundation. Your article here certainly reinforces Gray's book, and coming from a "regular person" it helps me believe that Gray's philosophy really does work. Thanks!

  • Scott S3/3/2007

    That's an important tip too. Remember your wife is aways right!

  • chris davisson3/3/2007

    nice work. i use those same tools when i argue with my wife, the problem with me is, my wife is right 60% of the time, lol. seriously though, this is a good artice.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.