At the end of the 2009 NFL season in a piece I cannot find at the moment, I compared Cleveland Browns head coach Eric Mangini with Tom Coughlin, current head coach of the New York Giants. Coughlin, a hard-nosed head coach notorious for riding his players and running grueling practices, was on the outs with the team after another disappointing playoff performance. He was eventually given a one-year reprieve by the Giants, largely because there wasn't anybody out there to take his place. Giants running back and future Hall of Famer Tiki Barber was done with Coughlin, however, and retired from the league.
We all know what happened the next season. Coughlin loosened up a bit, Earth, Wind and Fire dominated opposing defenses and the New York Giants won the Super Bowl. Tom Coughlin and the Giants front office were all geniuses.
The Cleveland Browns aren't winning Super Bowl XLV (probably). The past moves made by Eric Mangini as head coach of the Cleveland Browns, as well as his recent "shift in personality," make me believe that maybe, just maybe, Mangini has had a plan all along.
Mangini replaced the fired Romeo Crennel, a player-friendly coach beloved by practically everybody on the Cleveland Browns roster, in January of 2009. Mangini, like Coughlin, is known for running players into the ground, picking them up by their nostrils and doing it all over again. Both NFL rookies and veterans complained about Mangini. Several players, including offensive threats Kellen Winslow and Braylon Edwards were shipped out of Cleveland. Eric Mangini was a mad man in the eyes of Browns fans, a coach hellbent on destroying the team.
Sometimes, a team needs to be destroyed in order to build it up again.
The Browns finished the 2009 NFL regular season on a four-game winning streak, which included notable victories against the Pittsburgh Steelers and Jacksonville Jaguars. "Big deal," you say. A 5-11 overall record is nothing to get excited about. On the surface, that's a true statement. Look deeper, though, and you'll find a franchise taking baby steps toward improvement.
Running back Jerome Harrison is the most obvious example of this improvement. Much to the disappointment of both Harrison and Cleveland Browns fans, Mangini decided to not utilize Harrison for much of the first half of the year. The coach believed Harrison was under-performing both on the practice field and the classroom (meetings, watching film, etc.). Harrison responded by stepping it up Mondays through Saturdays, impressing his coach and finding his way back on the field on Sundays. You may remember Harrison's 286 yards and three touchdowns performance from last December. In the final three games of the season, Harrison rushed for 561 yards and five touchdowns.
Thanks, in part (at least), to Mangini.
It appears that Eric Mangini is now in the "2007 Tom Coughlin" phase. On just the fourth day of Browns training camp, Mangini surprised his players by canceling on-the-field practice. Those on the Browns roster heading into the 2010 NFL season have remarked that they've noticed a change in Mangini's coaching style and personality.
Perhaps Mangini was aware that the 2009 Cleveland Browns were a lost cause. By weeding out the weak, can't-hack-it players, Mangini was creating a football team tough enough to last against the Pittsburgh Steelers and Baltimore Ravens of the NFL. Unlike Tom Coughlin, Mangini doesn't have to win a Super Bowl in order to keep his job. Going 7-9 against this schedule would be just fine with me.
For more: Follow NYGExaminer on Twitter
Published by Zac Wassink - Featured Contributor in Sports
A gimmick sports writer with a love for Tottenham Hotspur, New York Red Bulls, US Soccer, Adelaide Crows, Juventus, Middlesbrough, New York Giants, New York Mets, Cleveland Browns, Cleveland Indians, Chicag... View profile
Cleveland Browns 2009 Season PreviewWith a new coach and very different personnel the Cleveland Browns hope to rebound from their disappointing season last year.- Breaking: NY Jets Coach Eric Mangini Fired; Coaching Interviews BeginNY Jets football coach Eric Mangini was fired today after the Jets failed to make the playoffs.
- Eric Mangini Fired After Jets Complete Another CollapseEric Mangini was supposed to be the genius that took the Jets to the top, and they were supposed to get there this season. But the season ended quite different, which cost Mangini his job today.
- Do the Cleveland Browns Have Any Hope in 2009?A preview of the 2009 Cleveland Browns season.
- Cleveland Browns 2009 PreviewA preview of what to expect from the 2009 Cleveland Browns
- Cleveland Browns Fire GM Kokinis: Now What?
- Cleveland Browns Should Bring Eric Mangini Back for 2010
- Eric Mangini Right Man for the Job in Cleveland?
- Eric Mangini Goes Back to His NFL Roots with the Cleveland Browns as Head Coach
- Cleveland Browns Interested in Derrick Ward
- Preview of the 2009 Cleveland Browns
- Cleveland Browns Rookie Safety Larry Asante Video Highlights




2 Comments
Post a CommentFor the second time in the last two games the opposing team was out of time-outs but the browns called time-outs and this allowed the other team to set up a play with seconds left. They almost lost todays game because of this action.
I have a little more respect for the Browns than some other people would myself. I could definitely see Cleveland go 7-9, but the biggest issue is their quarterback play. If Mangini can coach Delhomme to avoid the mistakes and Harrison can continue his success from last year, 7-9ish isn't unquestionable.