I discovered Trader Joe's no longer carried Mud Pie. Nor did the Smart and Final stores closest to our house. And no one had Jamoca Almond Fudge ice cream. I was stuck at home nursing the dog after a visit to the emergency pet hospital when I sprang in to action and drove to our neartest Ralph's Grocery store. I'll make something better than Mud Pie and it will be ready when everyone gets home! Here's my recipe:
1 box vanilla wafers
1 box Disney character graham crackers (I only bought this since it was less expensive than a box of graham crackers)
1 box fudge sticks (I bought 2 boxes but only used 1)
½ gallon vanilla ice cream
½ gallon Black Cherry Chip ice cream
½ gallon English Toffee ice cream
1 16 oz jar Mrs. Richardson's Fudge topping (I also bought a generic store brand but didn't need it)
The total price was $ 23.00 and this included what I didn't use. I was going to be serving 12 people.
1 I set a cutting board on the kitchen counter and spread out a handful of the wafers, graham cracker cookies and fudge sticks.
2 I grabbed a rolling pin and started crushing the cookies. This is the really fun part. Try to keep scooping the uncrushed cookies to the middle of the cutting board. And then crush some more until it's not quite dust.
3 Layer the cookies on the bottom of a rectangular pan. Heck, it can be any shape pan!
4 I kept the ice cream out so it would be soft and then I scooped each flavor into the pan. Next, I crushed some more cookies on top, melted fudge sauce in the microwave and poured it over the mixture.
5 Then I repeated until there was another layer.
6 I stuck it in the freezer knowing I had slightly more than a hour to have it harden. I placed a couple of ice cubes on top of the fudge where it was still a bit warm.
And then I took a smaller pie pan and repeated for the second ice cream cake. Except on this I only used vanilla ice cream. Then I made a mound of ice cream on top of the mixture and poured melted fudge sauce on top.
The sauce slid down the mound and spread along the sides. It was really fun to watch!
I stuck that in the freezer, too.
I named one "Patio Ice Cream Cake" since we had just built a patio in our back yard and the crushed cookies reminded me of the dirt and sand mixture.
Then I named the other one "Snow Field" since it looked melting snow at a high elevation in the early summer.
But you know what guys? You can call it anything you want!
Finally, make sure you sweep up the counter and the floor when you're done. Magician's don't give away their secrets.
And that's it. Everyone liked it and I felt accomplished.
Also, the puppy was still alive to take it to our regular vet for treatment the next morning!
Published by Don Simkovich
Works with small business owners to keep them healthy and run healthy businesses. Don interviews small business owners, writes about those who shape the culture around Los Angeles, and journals his hikes and... View profile
- The Homemade Ice Cream Cake"Are you sure you don't want me to pick up a cake at the ice cream store?" I ask my twenty-five-year-old son on the phone. He whines like a three year old. "You try to talk me out of it every year, Mom.
- How to Make an Ice Cream CakeWe love those delicious ice cream cakes from local bakeries, but boy can they be expensive. After all it is just a cake then there are other party costs. Here you will learn how to make a simple ice cream cake for you...
- Blue Bell-Oreo Ice Cream Cake: A Recipe Great for Birthdays or Any TimeThis is a homemade ice cream cake I made for my daughter's birthday party. It's great for birthdays or any time.
- Pina Colada Ice Cream CakeImpress your friends with this easy to make, rich ice cream cake.
- Fourth of July Recipes: Ice Cream CakeIf you want a fabulous ice cream cake recipe, this is it. It takes a little time but it is worth the effort.
- Everything You Didn't Know About Vanilla Ice Cream
- Ice Cream
- Review of the Play & Freeze Ice Cream Maker (The Ice Cream Ball)
- July is National Ice Cream Month!
- How to Make a Great Ice Cream Cake
- The Top Ice Cream in Knoxville, Tennessee
- The Top Places to Eat Homemade Ice Cream in Newton, Massachusetts




6 Comments
Post a CommentGreat idea . . . why didn't I think of that??!! Ah, the power of community!
Next time throw the cookies in a large ziploc bag and crush them. That way there is no mess and you keep them all in one place .
Yum! :)
Thank you both for your comments! Lightwriter, you don't need to be the one who eats it!!! But I know how you feel!!!
I am printing this out, super thanks!!!!
Don, I'm already size 40, I DID NOT NEED this article! lol Oh well, u explain the process well. Good job!