If You're Opposed to Same Sex Marriage, Don't Get One

Why Does it Matter to You Who Marries Whom?

W.R. Murphy
Many conservatives are vehemently opposed to gay marriage. This fact has always puzzled me. I have one question for them: why do you care?

I mean really, what's going to happen to the narrow minded conservative world-view if gay people can marry each other? Anarchy in the streets? A second Flood? See the rainbow, people. Where there's love, there's love - I can't imagine God intended it any other way.

Some religions hold homosexuality to be sinful. Good for them. Many also hold drinking and premarital sex to be sinful as well, but there aren't many laws against those. This country has freedom of religion, which means that, although one person may practice their religion to their hearts' content, they may not force their religious beliefs on anyone else, which means that preventing people of a different religion from getting married because it would objectionable under one's own is unconstitutional, it's wrong.

I live in Virginia, which recently added and amendment to the state's constitution banning same sex marriage. There's a worthy addition. Now we have, in the state constitution, the equality of all people before the law, the monition that all power is derived from the people, and the firm prohibition of same sex marriage? How is that sufficiently fundamental to be in our state's constitution alongside the state's Bill of Rights?

Conservatives may say that marriage is sacred, that allowing gays to enter it would in someway taint it, or devalue it. Marriage may be sacred before a given church, but it is not sacred before the law. Before the law, it is an agreement between to people to live in support of one another for the rest of their lives. It is a beautiful thing, but the religious views of one group of people should not be allowed to deny it entirely to another group of people.

Living next door to me are two retired gay men who having been living together for over thirty years. These men are kind. They walk their dog together, keep their lawn meticulously, and always wave to their neighbors. They would have married decades ago in a more equitable society. Now, they have to deal with all kinds of unnecessary issues - they can't be taxed as a couple, and instead are taxed as roommates. They have to have separate health insurance, separate car insurance. If one is in critical condition in a hospital, the other may not be allowed to visit him because most hospitals have a policy that only immediate family members can visit patients in critical condition, all because the state recognizes no official relationship between to people who have been living together in love and harmony for over three decades.

Wake up and smell the love, people.

Published by W.R. Murphy

I know a fair amount about music - performing, recording, and just listening. I read Ancient Greek and Latin pretty well, and generally appreciate things that have been around forever, like ruins, old saying...  View profile

  • VA passed gay marriage ban as a CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT
  • Why do people care if gay people get married?
  • If you're opposed to gay marriage, don't get one, and shut up.

5 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Jody10/24/2007

    Great article! I agree with you 100%. I also don't see how a woman (or man) marrying someone of the opposite sex who does not treat them right is any better than them marrying someone of the same sex. To each their own.

  • Jack Oceano10/21/2007

    Well stated, W.R.

  • Amy B10/8/2007

    exactly to each his or her own. God made us all different for a god reason.

  • W.R. Murphy10/8/2007

    It's not a question of religion. It's a question of basic rights - married couples have tax and insurance benefits unmarried couples don't. I just think that this arrangement should be available to any couple.

  • Mrs. Micah10/8/2007

    I was raised in a conservative Christian context and I still never got how one could "taint" someone else's marriage. But then, I don't think the government should really be able to say who's married. Maybe who's registered to live together and have lots of benefits. But aren't we grown up enough to say "Hey, this is my husband/wife" just as we can say "This is my boy/girlfriend or fiance/e?"

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.