Alice: The question is, whether you can make words mean so many different things.
Humpty Dumpty: The question is: which is to be master - that's all."
It is said that civilizations and sophisticated societies need a veil of hypocrisy, to smoothen the wheels of human intercourse. If you call a spade a spade, then you are a cave man and not fit to cavort in dainty company. It would be a Himalayan blunder on your part, if you happened to mention the age of a lady, who was on the wrong side of the current 'benchmark age'. If you want to show, that you schooled at Eton or Harrow or were a 'propah' Bostonian, then you had better refer to her as 'a lady of certain age'. I doubt if this usage confers any magical transformation in the attributes of the lady, but you yourself are assigned a proper niche in the upper crust. Such is the magic of words! Having grown up under the British Raj in India, I may be pardoned for being an Anglophile. Going by the British penchant for the understatement, one could take it that they must be the most civilized souls on earth!
I don't think that things were that prim and proper in the England of Chaucer's days, better known for their ribaldry. Perhaps, this prudish trend was set into motion by the Ruler of the Realm, Empress Victoria, who was seldom amused. From her days till India's independence in 1947 and a little later, this Victorian prudery prevailed. Soon the more boisterous Indian English took over. In the days of the Empress, one could not utter, even to oneself the uncouth word 'underwear'! If you did not want to be ostracized, then you had better say, 'I must buy a few 'unmentionables'. As if this prude and proper word did not trigger off even more improper imagery in one's mind! Genteel ladies were supposed to swoon and drop to the floor, on hearing the word 'underwear'. In those days, the cockney coachman eavesdropping on the conversations emanating from inside, would have been foxed, trying to understand sentences after sentences punctuated with, 'you know what I mean ' and 'you know what I mean', etc.
America of 19th century was still laced with English cultural influences. So in deference to the ladies present, one used the word' limb' and not 'leg' - otherwise there was sufficient swooning to make their elegant suitors run for the smelling salts! Linguist, Peter Farb describes how over a period of time the Americans have dealt with the subject of death: "In the United States 'undertaker' drove out 'mortician' until it in turn was replaced by 'funeral director' as result of a PR campaign.........'coffin' has become 'casket'. 'Hearses' are now 'coaches' and the 'cadavers' they used to transport from the 'funeral parlor' are now the 'loved ones' escorted from the 'chapel' ". I do hope and pray that the grief of those left behind has become more bearable, thanks to this word play. I also do pray, that the passage of the dear departed to their heavenly abode, has become that much more blissful, thanks to proper use of words.
Dictionaries define 'euphemism', as replacing an offensive word with a more socially acceptable word. I often wonder why we have to play this charade. Does this change the reality of the situation at all? In the 60s, I was bugged by the American craze for being considered as socially and politically insensitive, if we called anyone 'poor'. The right word, if you were a caring member of a civil society, was to say 'He belongs to the low income bracket'. Congratulations, civil society, by waving this magic wand you have made the hapless subject richer by few thousand dollars, every year. Earlier, I used to lampoon fairy tales, but now I am a true believer - by just waving the magic wand of word play, the bitter reality can be redeemed, and so easily!
In India also, the way the delicate news of someone's death is conveyed, has often taken me by surprise. As a north Indian, when I started my career in Bombay, I had to get used to the local lingo and mores. There was a knock and as I opened the door, there stood my neighbor, who solemnly declared, 'Mr. Patel is off.' Has Mr. Patel taken a day off or is he off mood - was the thought that crossed my mind. It took this dull head some time to realize the sad truth that, Mr. Patel had indeed died! So over a period of time, I learnt that in the Gujarati community, in their version of English 'off' means, that the person is dead! Not bad by any standards! Come to think of it, the electrical switch of the life force of Mr. Patel was permanently switched 'off' by the Lord above. What a true description of that cosmic reality!
Politicians are past masters at the game of word play and sadly enough the media also falls for their ploys. For Pentagon, the Viet Nam war not a 'war', but 'international armed conflict'. Both in Viet Nam and Iraq, when American soldiers got killed by fire from American soldiers, because of goof ups by the generals, the immense tragedy was written off by Pentagon as ' collateral damage due to friendly fire'! 'Friendly fire': how do they explain this to the mourning bereaved families? Where are the generals? Let's see them engage in such a public display of friendly fire themselves, right in front of our eyes: This sort of logic is lamented in Julius Caesar:
"O judgment, thou art fled to brutish beasts,
And men have lost their reason!"
To survive in a society run by manipulative presidents, manipulative politicians, manipulative salesman, etc. one has to understand their word play. They are past masters in the use of euphemisms - thereby painting a rosy present and a still rosier future. They make you feel rich, when there are holes in your pockets! To paraphrase from Hamlet:
"Words, words, words, Hamlet, what IS the matter?' Hamlet replies to his inquisitor: "Words ARE the Matter!'
Our understanding of our condition and its imagery is purely based on the words we use or the others use to describe our 'reality'. It is not experiential. Perhaps the cave man was closer to his 'reality', than we are to ours!
Published by Shyam Saksena
Electrical and electronics engineer. Retired as Director of German MNC, Siemens. Thanks to assignments from my company, I could savor 25 countries and get to know their people and culture. View profile
Everything You Need to Know About Humpty DumptyEverybody knows the nursery rhyme Humpty Dumpty, it's about an egg that falls off a wall and nobody can put him back together again. But what does it mean? Where did ti come f...- Humpty Dumpty: The Origin of This Nursery RhymeMost of us know that Humpty Dumpty was portrayed in Lewis Carroll's 'Through the looking glass' and in the nursery rhyme as an egg, well it turns out that Humpty Dumpty was not really an egg.
- Humpty Dumpty: You're No Nursery RhymeA Little Look at Humpty Dumpty
- English as Global Language, TEFL International
- Commonly Used Latin Words and Phrases in Modern English
- The "N" Word and 20 Other Offensive Words
- Humpty Dumpty: What's All the Hoopla About This Egghead?
- Careful Humpty Dumpty
- Humpty Dumpty Sees a Psychiatrist
- Friendly Fire Takes the Lives of Five Soldiers at Camp Liberty, Baghdad, Iraq



6 Comments
Post a CommentSo well written and hallarious!
It was such a nice read ! Like Wizard I also take the 3rd class..............but it is not the "Coach" for me, it the "Economy Class"...................at least the word "Class" has been assigned to me !!!!!!!!!!!!
Very entertaining! And may I say that I believe the Wizard's parlance was in the same lighthearted vein as your witty article. He has a wily wit, that one! Watch out for him!
Dear Wizard, don't take me seriously. Life would be very boring without a sense of humour.
This is just a teasing observation and not any value judgement.
Very funny and very true. Frankly, I feel better knowing I fly in "coach" rather than 3rd class as was in the day way back when there was only 1st, 2nd and 3rd class when traveling either by plane or by boat. Today we get 1st class, business class and economy, not so offensive sounding I guess. Of course, having a "spot" of tea doesn't make me look so piggish as having a "cup" or even worse, a "mug" of tea. A spade is only a spade if one can deal with the realty.
Great job on this, very nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1