Matt, how is it teaching something that you do not believe in?
It's not too bad. I think everyone should learn about evolution - even Christians. One should learn about this theory, as many people do believe it.
How much is evolution a part of your current curriculum?
It's a big part. For my advanced placement students, questions centered on evolution make up about 25% of the AP exam.
How have your students reacted to a formal presentation of evolution?
Well, the students that already have religious beliefs do not accept it and see problems with it. The students that are not religious tend to think that evolution has its holes but that it is the best thing going. A small percentage of the non-religious students do not accept evolution after it has been presented. Sometimes students ask questions that I can only answer after class.
So, in your opinion what is/are the best argument(s) for evolution?
The fossil record. It tends to go from more simple to complex.
What is/are the best argument(s) against evolution?
One is irreducible complexity. Certain parts within an organism can only be broken down so far and still be able to function. All components of an organ or system need to be present at the same time and placed in a certain order if being constructed/developed, in order to function in any capacity.
The other problem is a lack of information-increasing mutations. Humanity has yet to discover or see mutations on a mass scale where information in a specie's DNA code has increased.
What has changed in the last 150 years in regards to how man regards origins?
At first, the idea of design was dominant to exclusive and that gave way to evolution. Evolution was dominant to the point of exclusive until about the last 20 years. Design is now making a resurgence but evolution is still dominant. We have discovered that certain things, like microorganisms, are far more complex than Darwin or his contemporaries could have ever imagined.
Thanks Matt and keep up the good work.
Published by David Whitsell
Dark child tying to make it in the world. View profile
- 'Darwinism' is Still a Fighting Word in the Culture WarsA look at the continuing controversy over the teaching of evolution in the classroom. How proponents of Creationism and "Intelligent Design" continue to villify Darwin and turn school boards into battlefields.
- Evolution and Intelligent Design ExplainedIntelligent design and evolution have created one of the most controversial topics in the past few years. Many conservative groups have tried to put intelligent design into the science curriculum
- Diversity and the ClassroomStudents today will continue to experience growth in the climate of the changing classroom, if they as individuals are given the tools to practice openness, willingness and acceptance.
- Evolution and Intelligent Design in the ClassroomThis article describes how intelligent design has become the new face of creationism, some of its fallacies, and how it is making inroads into public education in the United States.
- The Impact of the Separation of Church and State on EducationThe United States of America was founded on the basis of religious freedom. Its school systems were centered on religious education. Theology was weaved into every song, every thought, and every act of Americans.
- Scopes Monkey Trial Returns
- Theory, Not Law: The Real Problem with How Evolution is Taught
- Teaching Origin in Science Classes
- Curriculum Trends: Changes Occurring in Schools Throughout the World
- The Teaching of Evolution in Schools, and the Intelligent Design Camp's Agenda
- Teaching Students to Create Their Own Religion - a Town Outrage
- Inherit the Wind Vs. The Scopes Monkey Trial



