Is NBC's 'The Voice' Just Another 'American Idol'?

Five Key Differences Between Two TV Talent Shows

Linda Ann Nickerson
NBC TV debuts "The Voice" on Tuesday, April 26. This singing contest is likely to rival FOX TV's "American Idol," although several key factors are supposed to make the series unique.

What are the primary differences between "The Voice" and "American Idol"?

Based on a Dutch show, "Voice" pairs teams of contestants with celebrities to lead them through the contest. "Idol," formatted after a British program, pits singers directly against one another.

"Voice" is produced by "Survivor" creator Mark Burnett, "Big Brother" force John de Mol and Warner Horizon Television, while "Idol" comes from Simon Fuller, Fremantle Media North America and 19 Entertainment.

A handful of interesting contrasts may be found between the two programs, aimed at crowning the next "American Idol" and "Voice of America." Here are five differences.

"Voice" has celebrity coaches, rather than judges.

Randy Jackson, Jennifer Lopez and Aerosmith's Steven Tyler preside as judges for "Idol," offering candid or comic critiques on contestants' auditions each week. On "Voice," however, celebrities serve as talent coaches. Christina Aguilera, Cee Lo Green, Maroon 5's Adam Levine and Blake Shelton build their own teams of contestants for the competition, choosing from a group of finalists.

"Voice" begins with blind auditions.

Initially, the quartet of "Voice" celebrity coaches does not even face the singers, who perform to the backs of the coaches' big red chairs. Contestants, chosen from previous nationwide auditions, are selected for teams on the basis of voice alone. For later episodes, the coaches mentor their chosen candidates.

On "Idol," the judges face the contestants and frequently even comment about their attire and appearances.

Public voting is saved for the end in "Voice."

After the initial auditions, coaches and their teams will battle it out until the final four weeks, when "Voice" goes live on TV. At that time, American audiences will be invited to vote for their favorites. Contestants will be eliminated until each of the four coaches has one remaining team member for the finale.

"Idol" looks to public voting for most of the season, once the judges have whittled the group of contestants down to a reasonably manageable two dozen singers.

"Voice" offers a record contract and cash prize to the winner.

Unlike "Idol," which promises a 19 Entertainment record deal to America's favorite singer, "Voice" gives the winner a $100,000 prize and a major label contract to boot.

Of course, the top two finishers on "Idol" usually drive away in brand-new Fords.

"Voice" has a radio and TV personality emcee.

Carson Daly, of "Last Call with Carson Daly," is host of "Voice." The 37-year-old is clean-cut and looks good in a suit. The former Los Angeles deejay is single, partial to actresses and fancies himself a comic wit.

Aha! Perhaps this is not so different from "Idol" and 36-year-old host Ryan Seacrest, after all.

The two shows will coexist for more than a month this spring.

Beginning in April, "Voice" will overlap with "Idol," which is expected to wrap up by the end of May. "Voice" airs on Tuesdays at 9 p.m. ET on NBC, while "Idol" is on Wednesday and Thursday evenings on Fox.

Similar shows also include "America's Got Talent" and "The X Factor."

More from the Yahoo! Contributor Network:

Hell's Kitchen Season 8: What Happened to Jean-Philippe?

Oprah Winfrey Tops Forbes' 2010 List of Hollywood's Top 20 Earners

Pick a Perfect Fit for Glee Wannabee Leona Lewis

Published by Linda Ann Nickerson - Featured Contributor in Lifestyle and Sports

Linda Ann Nickerson brings decades of reporting and a globally minded Midwestern perspective to a host of topics, balancing human interest with history, hard facts and often humor.  View profile

  • "The Voice" debuts April 26 with Christina Aguilera, Cee Lo Green, Adam Levine and Blake Shelton.
  • This singing contest is likely to rival FOX TV's "American Idol," although several key factors make
  • What are the primary differences between "The Voice" and "American Idol"?
Linda Ann Nickerson brings decades of reporting and a globally minded Midwestern perspective to a host of topics, balancing human interest with history, hard facts and often humor.

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  • weileai4/17/2011

    welcome to -- http://www.cn2bizz.com --


    ...... http://www.cn2bizz.com .....


    welcome to our websit:
    ╭══════════════╮
    http://www.cn2bizz.com
    ╰══════════════╯
    ***★Nike☆jordan s-h-o-e-s $30--35★***
    ****☆ Best online store ☆****

    ---------http://www.cn2bizz.com-------------

  • Abby Willow4/13/2011

    I think I will like "The Voice" more than Idol, although the only vocal coach who I think will prove any benefit it Christina. The others? Well, not so much. Unless by "vocal coach" they mean "how to survive in the business". I dunno-looks interesting

  • Honora James3/30/2011

    Thanks for the format background info on the show.

  • J.C. JORDAN3/30/2011

    Great job!

  • Charlotte Kuchinsky3/29/2011

    Good info.

  • Lady Samantha3/29/2011

    The first time I heard the show "the voice" I thought it was going to be another show starring Alec Baldwin. Then I saw what it was and said-eh. I don't even watch American Idol. So I am going to pass on this...although I may have to watch once in awhile just to see Adam Levine :)

  • Patti Walden3/29/2011

    Well done!

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.