Is She Vegan or Anorexic? 3 Signs to Watch Out For

Ann Olson
Some people call veganism the new anorexia. With the elimination of animal-based foods such as milk, cheese and meat, vegans have a hard time finding a nutritious meal meeting their dietary guidelines, which is advantageous for anorexics. Many anorexics use vegan diets to hide their food problems, leaving many people-and real vegans-frustrated.

On the contrary, the Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine shows that vegan and vegetarian teenagers were four times more likely to use extreme dieting methods. They were also eight times as likely to abuse laxatives, a common behavior associated with purging anorexia nervosa.

Not all vegan teenagers become anorexic, however. Veganism can be a healthy lifestyle choice if done for the right reasons. If you are having trouble figuring out if your teenager is vegan or anorexic, here are 3 signs to watch out for:

Sign 1#: She avoids eating food prepared by a family member, even if it is vegan.

Answer: There is no reason why vegans would refuse clearly vegan meals-this usually indicates she is concerned about its caloric or fat content. Anorexics will use any excuse to avoid eating, be it a vegan diet, a sudden stomach ache or suddenly becoming preoccupied with an activity. But whatever you do, don't force your teenager to eat: it only reinforces negative behavior and increases anxiety, making her anorexia worse.

Sign 2#: She also eliminates other vegan food essentials, such as tofu, nuts and pasta.

Answer: Vegans rarely eliminate essentials from their diet-it helps them stay healthy while filling them up. Some vegans may not like certain foods, but if she begins eliminating several high-calorie or high-carb vegan items from her diet, it may indicate she is anorexic.

Sign 3#: She displays compulsive, ritualistic behaviors.

Answer: Whether it's eating her food in a certain way, only eating at certain times or exercising excessively, these eating behaviors are not healthy. Many anorexics develop compulsive behaviors to control their food intake. If your teenager starts controlling her food in ritualistic ways, she may be developing anorexia nervosa. Avoid drawing attention to her eating behaviors, though: criticizing her or telling her to stop can breach her "safety" zone, which anorexics develop to cope with their feelings. Destroying this barrier can make her eating behaviors worse.

Is She Vegan or Anorexic? What To Do

If your teenager displays obvious signs of anorexia-denying food on a regular basis, engaging in compulsive behaviors, being too concerned about her appearance-she may need medical intervention. Check with your local hospital for resources. Additionally, websites such as SomethingFishy.org also have resources for finding treatment for vegan anorexics. Force feeding her or ending her vegan diet will only escalate matters, but professional treatment can help her heal.

Sources:
"Vegetarian or Anorexic?" (HealthyPlace.com)

Published by Ann Olson - Featured Contributor in Health & Wellness

When I'm not lifting 200 lbs. off the ground with my bare hands, I moonlight as a freelance reporter and diet consultant. What I do: I write regular diet and exercise-oriented columns for Yahoo! Sports, Yah...  View profile

  • Many girls use vegan diets to hide their anorexia.
  • Teenagers on vegetarian diets are four times more likely to develop anorexic behaviors.
  • Anorexia should be treated by professionals because of its complexity.

19 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Amy2/12/2011

    I am vegan with many food allergies and sensitivities. I started out vegan because of ethical reasons and then found that by eliminating animal sourced foods it eliminated most of the stomach discomfort, bloating,blah feelings. Because I strictly avoid certain foods and the fact that I am super skinny people often accuse me of having an eating disorder. This is an unfair assumption because if you spend 5 minutes with me you will know love to eat. My parents refer to me as 'the hollow leg' because of my healthy apetite. I have been to doctors and nutritionists, so I know I am perfectly healthy. I am just blessed with an active metabolism. My point is to keep an open mind - the article seems to suggest if you are vegan and skinny you probably have an eating disorder. My advice to teens and parents - If you/your child says they constantly feel fat, bloated, etc. find a doctor/nutritionist who is into food sensitivities and allergies. You might be surprised at what you fin

  • Abby10/2/2010

    "With the elimination of animal-based foods such as milk, cheese and meat, vegans have a hard time finding a nutritious meal meeting their dietary guidelines,"

    Although overall this is a great article, I really disagree with this statement. What are we supposed to have trouble getting? We need to supplement B12, but really everything else is much more accessible than people think in a vegan diet.

  • becky3/25/2010

    i mean it is not as bad typo

  • becy3/25/2010

    being vegan is as bad

  • Rebecca2/28/2010

    I had never heard of this before. Hopefully parenst will stay involved and active in their child's eating and choice to be vegan to help prevent such a thing from occurring. It seems the kids themselves actually believe they are vegan and are unaware of what it is they are doing. Good article.

  • Kimberly Moore2/21/2010

    Great and insightful article!

  • Jennifer Waite2/2/2010

    Very nice job!

  • Tal Boldo1/27/2010

    Fascinating. I watched an old movie recently and was struck by how much fuller women were then, that is women who were considered beautiful.

  • Jaipi Sixbear1/27/2010

    Interesting article. Never heard of teens using this excuse for their anorexia before. Thanks for making us aware!

  • Marilisa Kinney Sachteleben1/26/2010

    excellent points, Ann- our bilimi-rexic daughter hid it behind vegan, lactose interance, gluten intolerance...

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.