Is Simon Cowell Really that Bad?

There's a Fine Line Between Brash and Brutally Honest

Eric Thomas
If you live in America you've undoubtedly heard of, or even watched the show American Idol. Any show that allows relatively unknown people compete for the chance at stardom is a winner. American Idol is no exception as it draws in millions upon millions of viewers each week. So, it is up to the celebrity judges to determine whether or not these contestants have talent. Among them are producer Randy Jackson, former singer/songwriter and Laker cheerleader Paula Abdul and the notorious Simon Cowell. Cowell is known for being mean and cold hearted with the off-color remarks that he makes to those that are, well, untalented. But, is Simon Cowell to blame for the contestants being so brutally bad? Let's take a look.

Simon Cowell is an executive for Sony BMG Music, which gives him clout right off the bat. Basically, he knows what he's talking about when it comes to singing and the pop music industry. Simon Cowell has an ear for music and can tell within seconds whether or not a singer has the "it" factor, or not. He's been doing what he does for years now, and the fact that ordinary people with no musical experience think they know more than him is ridiculous. How many times do you see a contestant with their family get rejected and immediately start bashing Simon Cowell saying, "He doesn't know what he's talking about"? It happens almost every time! Come on, people! Sony BMG wouldn't hire some moron off the street and turn him into an executive. Simon Cowell is world renown for what he does, and that is to judge singing talent.

And what about all of these terrible auditions? Where are these people's friends and family to tell them how bad they are? It amazes me that these contestants even make it to American Idol. How can you be that bad, but still be encouraged to audition? I blame the parents, family and friends of these people. They should be the ones telling them that they need practice, or to simply not make a fool out of themselves. But instead, people turn to Simon Cowell and think he is this monster who enjoys hurting the feelings of aspiring performers. Cowell is honest in his opinion. What we don't see is how many bad auditions that Simon Cowell is forced to listen to throughout the course of a day, let alone an entire city of contestants. Anyone in his position would be grumpy, irritable and downright annoyed by the thousands that literally waste American Idol's time with their audition. So, you can't blame Simon Cowell for telling it like it is. He doesn't fill these kids up with false hope of being a star. For some, it is a possibility. For the vast majority, it will never be a dream that they realize.

American Idol is one of the greatest opportunities to become a star overnight. Most of the contestants realize this, and try out even if they are lacking talent. But, if that it is what you choose to do, make sure your friends and family give you the "thumbs up" before trying out. That is your best defense against Simon Cowell and a public humiliation. You just might save yourself the embarrassment on national television!

Published by Eric Thomas

I currently work in a large suburban high school as a Guidance Counselor/College Advisor.  View profile

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.