Jill Greenberg: Democrat Photographer Admits to Altering McCain Photos

Dem Photographer's Photos of McCain Show Up on Her Website

Angie Mohr CA CMA
Jill Greenberg, a freelance celebrity photographer, has admitted on her website that she deliberately made photographs she took of presidential nominee John McCain negative and unflattering. The Atlantic Magazine hired freelancer Jill Greenberg to take photos of McCain for an upcoming edition of the magazine. According to her blog, Jill Greenberg used uplighting to portray McCain as devilish and did not airbrush or retouch his red eyes and skin tone. Correcting minor imperfections after the shoot is a common practice for photographers, including Jill Greenberg.

After The Atlantic rejected most of the photographs and went with a more traditional, although still unretouched, portrait of McCain, Jill Greenberg posted some of the photos on her website and Photoshopped scribbles on them, depicting McCain as a devil with horns and with blood dripping from his fangs.

In her blog, Jill Greenberg boasts "I left his eyes red and his skin looking bad." She blames Atlantic Magazine for hiring her in the first place. "Some of my artwork has been pretty anti-Bush, so maybe it was somewhat irresponsible for [The Atlantic] to hire me."

On The Atlantic's website, the author of the article photographed by Jill Greenberg apologized to readers and expressed his sheer disbelief at the level of unprofessionalism exhibited by Greenberg.

Is it okay to let your politics show in the workplace? Jill Greenberg sees nothing wrong with her actions. As a management consultant, I have many clients whose politics differ from my own. But they have hired me to do a job and that's when personal opinions are put aside and professionalism kicks in. If I chose to imbue the work I do for my clients with my own politics, I would rightly be fired and could likely expect to not work in the field of management accounting again.

Jill Greenberg has not done herself or the Democrats any favors. She will likely find her calendar less booked, even by Dem-leaning clients who may feel that her lack of professionalism could extend to other personal opinions. Greenberg's actions and admissions will lead her down the path of becoming an industry pariah. If Jill Greenberg's goal was to bring notoriety to her self and her business, she may have accomplished that in a very different manner than she intended.

Sources:

http://www.nypost.com/seven/09142008/news/politics/mac_hater_has_a_lousy_image_129007.htm

http://manipulator.com/

Published by Angie Mohr CA CMA - Featured Contributor in Business & Finance and Lifestyle

Angie Mohr is a Chartered Accountant and Certified Management Accountant who has worked with thousands of business clients from home-based entrepreneurs to rock bands to celebrity chefs. She is also the auth...  View profile

19 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Ulla Kelly11/14/2008

    This is really interesting ... fascinating read.

  • Sheri Fresonke Harper10/20/2008

    Excellent, it's amazing what you can do with technology :) Sheri

  • Chris Radtke9/17/2008

    Can't say I'm surprised. Good article.

  • Sylvia Cochran9/16/2008

    Excellent reporting! It is mind boggling that she blames the magazine for hiring her, when as a freelancer she should take the responsibility for turning down jobs that do not appeal to her. This kind of behavior gives other freelancers a bad name.

  • sweets9/16/2008

    Fab article. Time for war on the campagn front. McCain must lose and if she helps in the cause good for her. The shark picture is absolutely brilliant.

  • CJ Mathis9/16/2008

    The mud runs deep in a political campaign...Great report here Angie.

  • Moeursalen9/16/2008

    Interesting reading. The funniest thing was that she called the mag "irresponsible" for hiring her. Too complex for me to understand.

  • Anne Stjern9/15/2008

    Interesting article, Angie. Unprofessional behavior doesn't help forward a point of view, whatever it is. Ms. Greenberg will undoubtedly continue to work, but I'm not sure I'd want her future clients.

  • Jack Megela, Naples, Florida9/15/2008

    I forgot to post my name on the last comment criticizing Jill Greenberg's unprofessionalism.

  • Jennifer Metz9/15/2008

    Interesting- I hadn't heard about this. Some people have too much time on their hands....

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.