COMMENTARY | Famed fashion designer John Galliano was found guilty Thursday of using anti-Semitic slurs after going on a long and hateful rant in a Paris bar earlier this year. The flamboyant Galliano was obviously drunk and, during his trial in June, stated that he could not recall making the extreme comments. The rant had been caught on tape. After Galliano watched it, he apologized and remarked that he had a "triple addiction," according to Fashionista.
Galliano was given only a monetary punishment of 6,000 Euros (though the amount varies depending on the report at this point). He will only have to pay his fine if he repeats his offense over the next five years.
This brings up a lot of questions. Many Americans believe their First Amendment rights allow them to say almost anything without fear of punishment. Not true. If statements are made that are meant to invoke violence or represent threats, it is a crime. And it should be.
In France, there have been several other well-known people who have been convicted of using racial slurs. Jean-Marie Le Pen, a French far-right politician, has been found guilty of racism and Antisemitism several times. According to Economics Newspaper, he has frequently commented that the gas chambers used in the Holocaust were not "particularly inhumane," among many other hateful remarks.
Brigitte Bardot, the famed sex kitten of the 1960s, has been charged and convicted five times for inciting racial hatred. TIME reports the french actress has gone on record numerous times stating that Muslims were destroying her country. She has called them "invaders" and associated them with terrorist attacks.
Does it go too far to convict a person of a crime for just words? Of course, it depends on what those words are, but if it is meant to invoke violence against people who are of another race, religion or gender, it should be taken seriously and punished accordingly.
There are too many violent incidents in this world that were born out of "just words." The horrific murders at the Norway island summer camp are just one that comes to mind. It's sad to say, but there have been many others, and likely many more to come in the future if it isn't stopped at its inception.
Galliano was given only a monetary punishment of 6,000 Euros (though the amount varies depending on the report at this point). He will only have to pay his fine if he repeats his offense over the next five years.
This brings up a lot of questions. Many Americans believe their First Amendment rights allow them to say almost anything without fear of punishment. Not true. If statements are made that are meant to invoke violence or represent threats, it is a crime. And it should be.
In France, there have been several other well-known people who have been convicted of using racial slurs. Jean-Marie Le Pen, a French far-right politician, has been found guilty of racism and Antisemitism several times. According to Economics Newspaper, he has frequently commented that the gas chambers used in the Holocaust were not "particularly inhumane," among many other hateful remarks.
Brigitte Bardot, the famed sex kitten of the 1960s, has been charged and convicted five times for inciting racial hatred. TIME reports the french actress has gone on record numerous times stating that Muslims were destroying her country. She has called them "invaders" and associated them with terrorist attacks.
Does it go too far to convict a person of a crime for just words? Of course, it depends on what those words are, but if it is meant to invoke violence against people who are of another race, religion or gender, it should be taken seriously and punished accordingly.
There are too many violent incidents in this world that were born out of "just words." The horrific murders at the Norway island summer camp are just one that comes to mind. It's sad to say, but there have been many others, and likely many more to come in the future if it isn't stopped at its inception.
Published by K.C. Dermody - Featured Contributor in Travel
K.C. Dermody is a freelance writer, writing for YCN, Yahoo! News, Yahoo! Sports, and OMG! Yahoo as well as other web content projects, and working on a historical fiction novel based in ancient Ireland. She... View profile
French Words to Learn Before Leaving for Your Trip to ParisLearn twenty basic French words before your trip to Paris to promote smoother American/Parisian relationships whether it's asking for directions or simply being courteous.
Paris Fashion Week A/W 2011-2012 Was All About GallianoJohn Galliano, former head of Christian Dior, brought scandal to Paris Fashion Week and quite possibly a little fashion redemption.
Casualties of the First AmendmentThe First Amendment is misunderstood, allowing extremists in the United States to cause group libel, defamation of character and violations against individual's civil rights wit...
Tattoos, Tattoo Parlors, and the First AmendmentAccording to the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, tattoo parlor ban is unconstitutional. Tattooing is deemed a purely expressive act warranting full First Amendment protecti...
When the First Amendment Crosses the Line, OnlineA look at how the usage of our First Amendment rights and opinions can cause a reaction that is not welcoming and sometimes harassing. Does the First Amendment allow us to be b...
- Ex-Dior Fashion Designer John Galliano Faces Prison in Paris After Trial for Racis...
- Charlize Theron and John Galliano at the CDFA/Vogue Fashion Fund
- John Galliano Spring / Summer 2008 Fashion Collection
- Dior Suspends Galliano After Anti-Semitic Remarks
- Galliano, Ex-Dior Designer, Joins Charlie Sheen and Other Celebrities Accused of A...
- Why I Hate "Hate Crime" Laws
- The Concert for Racial Harmony in North Texas to Honor J.D. Tusan and Dennis Scales




1 Comments
Post a CommentYou raise good points in this article. I do wonder if France has a similar right to freedom of speech as we do...?