Juan Williams Loses His Job at NPR: Free Speech is Dying

Magnolia Miller
If you think you can say whatever you want to say in these United States of America, you better think again. Well, let me rephrase that. You can say whatever you want to say, but you also better be ready to face some pretty stiff consequences. Like: losing your job; being labeled a phobic, bigot, intolerant, hate monger and maybe even forced to lick the boots of someone like Al Sharpton.

Liberal news correspondent and frequent talking head on radio and television shows, Juan Williams, has been the recent target of the PC police. Juan Williams lost his job with NPR because of some honest comments he made recently on Fox News. More specifically, comments he made on Bill O'Reilly's show. Comments, I also personally heard. What horrible, bigoted, intolerant and hate mongering comments did Juan Williams make?

In the wake of the blow-out with Bill O'Reilly and Whoopi Goldberg and Joy Behar last week, Juan Williams appeared on Bill O'Reilly's show. When asked what he thought about Bill O'Reilly's comments on the television show, The View, Juan Williams responded with this:

"Look, Bill, I'm not a bigot. You know the kind of books I've written about the civil rights movement in this country. But when I get on the plane, I got to tell you, if I see people who are in Muslim garb and I think, you know, they are identifying themselves first and foremost as Muslims, I get worried. I get nervous."

Juan also went on to say that Bill O'Reilly or anyone, for that matter, should be careful not to paint all Muslims with a broad brush, but, he was simply being honest with what he felt when he saw Muslims on a plane. And guess what? Juan Williams is speaking for millions and millions of other Americans as well.

If you're going to tell me that you can see a Muslim man boarding a plane in this country wearing traditional Muslim clothing and you do not have one fleeting moment of pause, I will tell you that you are a liar. Because, to not have a response is to completely go against our psychological make-up.

Have you ever been in a serious car accident? Have you ever consumed too much Jack Daniels at a party and been sick for days over it? Have you ever been viciously attacked by a specific breed of dog? How about bitten by a poisonous insect?

Because if you have? I can assure you, that the next time you get inside a vehicle where you nearly lost your life, you will be apprehensive. If you threw up enough after your bender on Jack Daniels, you will have a tough time not recalling that unpleasant experience the next time you see it, smell it or taste it.

You will have an involuntary, visceral response the next time you see the breed of dog that attacked you or another insect that bit you. It happens because that is how we are biologically and psychologically wired to respond. It is called self-preservation and it is so deeply ingrained into your DNA that you cannot control it.

Because Juan Williams admitted what every, single American would feel if they boarded a plane and saw a Muslim man sitting there in traditional Muslim clothing, he is admitting he is human. However, that is the problem with politically correct speech. It's about an idea that is not based in reality or truth.

Furthermore, if you think punishing someone for saying something or attempting to stop certain words from exiting their mouths, is going to change the thought processes that occur on the inside, you are sorely mistaken and lack a genuine understanding of what it means to be human.

Controlling people with fear is called tyranny. If you honestly believe that it works, then you are as delusional as anyone who believes morality can be legislated or that you can create a greater society by force or coercion.

Mohandas K. Gandhi once said when leading the struggle for India's sovereignty from the oppressive rule of the British Empire, "They may torture my body, they may break my bones, and they may even kill me. But then, they will have my dead body. Not my obedience."

How blind and foolish we have become.

Sources:

NPR.org
Associated Content
IMDb.com
Washington Post.com

Published by Magnolia Miller

Magnolia Miller is a freelance health & medical writer and featured contributor for Yahoo! Voices in Women's Health. She holds a professional certification as a Health Care Consumer Advocate, and is also co...  View profile

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Andrew Coutermarsh10/26/2010

    (got cut off in my last post): so long as it isn't a violation of discrimination legislation (i.e. they didn't fire him because he's black).

    But don't make this out to be a Free Speech issue. NPR isn't the government and they can let him go just as easily as I would be let go if I were to walk into my own place of business and make political statements that MY boss didn't agree with.

  • Andrew Coutermarsh10/26/2010

    Juan Williams' statements had nothing to do with Free Speech. I don't know where anybody gets the idea that you can make political statements with impunity. Sure, the GOVERNMENT isn't allowed to do anything to you, but the Constitution doesn't apply to private entities. NPR had every right to fire Williams, whether it was wise or not (I don't believe they should have, but it's not really for me to say).

    Free Speech goes in both directions. Look at the NH paper the Union Leader, which came under fire last week for refusing to print a marriage announcement for a gay couple. As much as I disagree with their decision not to print gay wedding announcements, I certainly acknowledge their right to choose not to print it. Just as I acknowledge the rights of those who are boycotting the Union Leader as a result. And I also acknowledge Juan Williams' right to express himself politically, as well as NPR's right to fire himfor whatever reason they want, so long as it isn't a violation of discrimi

  • Magnolia Miller10/23/2010

    Thanks,Karla. I figured I was only stating the obvious, but I do appreciate the kudos.

  • Karla10/22/2010

    Magnolia, this is probably one of the best pieces on the Juan Williams debacle that I have read or listened to. Bravo for an insightful, thought provoking article.

  • Mark Beutler10/21/2010

    Free speech is not dying. It is dead. It died long ago, despite what the PC deniers say.

    First they came for the politically incorrect . . .

  • Magnolia Miller10/21/2010

    You are correct, Malina. We should always think before we speak. However, I think we have a much bigger problem in this country than reckless speech. We now have a culture that won't LET you speak if those that hold power over you do not agree with what you speak. We are in dangerous times, my friend. Dangerous times.

  • dana10/21/2010

    If muslims want to live in America they
    should live and dress like Americans - they can wear their traditional/religious clothing in their
    place of worship. If they don't like it they can go back where they came from. I, myself, am an imigrant that has adopted this great country as my and
    only coountry. In addition, these politically correct promoters should leave America for one of those Middle
    Eastern Muslim Countries for about a year and them come back to tell us how
    they liked it - these are people that have no idea what's it like to live outside USA. Juan should not have been
    fired for expressing his inner fear - a
    fear that mmajority of us feel. The
    people should have been fired this week
    should have been those two morans that
    walked off their own show - we all know who they are.

  • Malina Debrie10/21/2010

    For years, I held my piece when I knew something said or done was completely, totally and undeniiably wrong. I did this because I had to work to live and support my children. No Freedom is not free. Before we do anything, say anything or even look a certain way, we have to consider the consequences.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.