Kentucky Basketball; Overrated?

Ankur Amin
Just weeks before his Florida Gators captured a second consecutive NCAA title, reports broke out that Billy Donovan was being lured to Kentucky. The media brass reasoned that the glory of the Kentucky program was enough to steal almost any coach away. Some Wildcat fans even went as far to claim that a move to Lexington should be Donovan's, and any other coach's, dream as a basketball guru.

My only question is what is the big deal?

It is true that the Wildcats have indeed won seven national titles. Only two of the titles, however, have occurred after the NCAA switched to a sixty-four team format in 1985 for their famous tournament. Of the other five, two were won in an era where only eight squads competed for the national title. Another was won in a field of sixteen. In fact, Kentucky did not win a single title against a field of greater than thirty-two before 1996.

Indeed, if we were to compare the modern-era success of Kentucky with Florida in tournament play we would see that both teams have won the same amount of titles while appearing in the same number of Finals. A both teams' success in the past twenty-plus years is overshadowed by Coach K and Duke; the Blue Devils have won three championships and appeared in a total of seven title games.

But of course, we still cannot overlook the past success of the Wildcats. After all, they were the best team during the years when the NCAA would switch the format of their tournament every couple of years, right?

Wrong.

In actuality, the aforementioned UCLA Bruins were much more impressive in the pre-1985 NCAAB years. The team won ten titles, including seven straight at one point, during the sixties and seventies. Of the five titles Kentucky won in this time, only one came after the Bruins' reign over college athletics against a bigger field.

So again, what is the big deal?

Maybe this is just the viewpoint of an outsider looking in. Maybe the Wildcats really do have a better basketball program than Florida. But from my standpoint, the Gators are the team with two rings from the 21st century and Kentucky fans are the ones bragging about teams they probably never saw in person.

Take away the façade of past success translating into present success and Donovan does not have a tough decision to make. So what if Kentucky offers more money? There is no question that the Gators will match. Billy should just stay put and continue to do what he does best; win games.

And who knows? Maybe in fifty years young fans from Gainesville will be blasting a successful Kentucky coach for spurning the prestigious program that Billy Donovan built.One thing is for certain, these Wildcats are certainly not the same legendary teams of old.

Published by Ankur Amin

I am a college student who loves to watch, talk and write about sports. My favorite teams are based in Detroit, but I try my best to say unbiased.   View profile

69 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Cats Forever!! 3/13/2010

    Dude, how freaking stupid can you be? Have you ever actually watched UK basketball? Have you ever been to Rupp Arena and experienced it? That, my friend, is why UK has the greatest basketball pragram in history. You say that we shouldnt take such pride because we weren't alive when those championships happened, but you most likely weren't either so you shouldn't be talking about how we're overrated. In case you haven't noticed: Florida sucks. Sure a few years ago they were great, but they will NEVER be that good again. Kentucky keeps getting better. All of UCLA's titles were basically one after the other, with the same players, coaches, and everything. Kentucky has the best throughout history, you cannot deny it. So go shove your stupid statistics up you butt, because doing research and comparing over the past two or three years is nothing. You have no clue what you're talking about. I can't believe someone actually published this, YOU'RE AN IDIOT!!! Kentucky basketball was t

  • Kyle 11/17/2009

    This may be the dumbest basketball article I have ever read. You are comparing Florida's success to that of Kentucky? Ok, sure... they have the same amount of National championships since 1985... but that isnt because Florida has a great basketball program. They had some really good players for a couple of years and now will not be heard from again for another 10 years or so. Kentucky however even in their down years is usually the favorite to win the SEC, which is not the powerhouse that they are in football... but still a very competitive conference, and can always make a run in the tournament. The reason UK fans are so proud of their team is that they do have 7 national titles as you mentioned, but also... they are the winningest team in college basketball history... regular season and NCAA tournament. And i'm just guessing here, but have something like 40 SEC titles. I dont feel like doing research but Florida probably has 5 or less SEC titles.

  • Ankur Amin 1/18/2009

    Let me again say, I am not a Gator fan. I am an impartial, unbiased fan who went to a school from the Big 10. I don't see why current fans, some of whom weren't born when Kentucky won the bulk of their titles, take such pride in past history. Sports is a "what have you done for me lately" world, and as of today, Florida has a better basketball program than Kentucky. They don't have as good of a fanbase, but they do have better results on the court.

  • jerry gaunce 1/18/2009

    its not about black and white.this is 2009 stop living in past its ok to let it go.see what we can do when black and whites come together.cut us dont we bleed blue i am sorry i mean red.lets all grow up the white man is no better than the black man and the black man is no better than the white man we are the same.

  • Cat Furniture 12/5/2008

    Back 2 Back titles with an NIT loser.

    You sir, are an idiot!

  • flordiasucks balls 1/19/2008

    all of you guys suck for flordia because the only reason why u were good last year is because of jokimnoah that gay dude haha flordia sucks and ky is beast lol
    byeee

  • GAtOR HATER 12/5/2007

    Louisville you guys will always be second best you can take every coach weve ever had and we will still be better than you thats just the way it is. Havent we beaten you the past 3 years. Good luck keeping that number 11 ranking without padgett. How many national titles do you guys have, what conference were you in until Pitino saved you from embarrassment thats right the Conference USA. Go C A T S
    CATS CATS CATS.

  • TIM WAYNE 6/30/2007

    UKFAN1971, UCLA HAS MORE TITLES,SO NOW THEY HAD TO BE CHEATING.LIKE I SAID BEFORE IF IT'S A SCHOOL THAT HAS SOMETHING BETTER THEN UofK THEN SOMETHING WRONG WITH THAT PROGRAM. BY THE WAY IF UofK DIDN'T NEED BLACK PLAYERS TO WIN THEY WOULD NOT HAVE ANY.

  • Ukfan1971 6/30/2007

    It's funny how a band wagon rider can try and insult the greatest program of all time. Then, to mention a few UL fans. If you chumps don't like UK, then why read this bull$hit? I know it and you know it's BS. You mention the NC titles, but forgot to mention the NIT games too. Yes, UCLA has won more titles and they should have. Hell, who else could afford to put a team like that together legally? NOONE, not unless the horse barons of Kentucky wanted to throw their money at UK players instead of putting the money into their horses. Read you history before you dorks start talking about UK not starting a black player too.

  • TIM WAYNE 6/28/2007

    HISTORYDIVA, I WAS TALKING ABOUT UK PLAYING TEAMS WITH BLACK PLAYERS, LORD KNOWS UK WAS NOT GOING TO PUT ONE ON THE TEAM. I DON'T HAVE TO READ HISTORY I'M OLD ENOUGH TO KNOW.AARON LIKE MOST UK FANS THEY GO TO HISTORY WHEN THEY ARE LOSING.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.