Knox County Missing Persons: When Tragedy Strikes a Small Town

Search Continues for Tina Herrmann, Kody Maynard and Stephanie Sprang

Debbie Henthorn
One week has passed since the rural community of Mount Vernon, Ohio and all of Knox County was rocked by the tragic disappearance of Tina Herrmann and her two children, a 13-year old daughter and Kody Maynard, and their friend Stephanie Sprang.

Mount Vernon is a small town. When I moved there from nearby Centerburg in 1983, I thought I had moved to the big city. I learned over the next eight years, especially once my children started school that it was just like Centerburg. You could get to know your neighbor or you could know the name of the person who bagged your groceries. I felt comfortable letting my kids walk through the field to their friends' house 100 yards away.

Knox County has had more than its share of media attention over the last couple of years. Scandals have divided the community while the whole world watched. Now, the community is tragically joined while the world watches again.

As word quickly spread the evening of Thursday, November 11 that four people were missing, the local forum - KnoxPages.com was the place for the most up-to-date information and speculation. Columbus media caught word of a lockdown at Kenyon College when Tina Herrmann's truck was discovered nearby and the road to international media attention was paved.

Volunteers began turning out to form search parties. Two Facebook pages have been created asking for prayers and support.

The community rejoiced when the girl was rescued early on the morning of Sunday November 14 and at the arrest of her alleged kidnapper, Matthew Hoffman. Still, it was a bittersweet morning upon the realization that only one of the four missing people was found.

Monday evening, the community held its collective breath while watching live coverage of a vehicle being pulled out of a lake at Foundation Park. A former gravel quarry, the entrance to the park is very near to Hoffman's home where he was holding the girl hostage, bound and gagged in a dark basement. In my own office, my boyfriend and I both realized quickly that the car that was being pulled from the water had been there far too long to be connected to the case. A sigh of relief went up, only to be deflated once again knowing that Tina, Kody and Stephanie were still missing.

The two children are students in the East Knox Local School District. Arguably the biggest sports rivalry in Knox County is the annual Devil-Dog football game, pitting the East Knox Bulldogs against the Blue Devils of Danville, just a few miles away. Students from Danville decided to show their support on Wednesday, November 17 by wearing purple, the East Knox school color, in honor of those still missing.

On Facebook, many people have changed their profile pictures to reflect three candles in honor of the three who have not yet returned home. Purple and white ribbons have been created and are being sold in order to raise money for the two families. Candlelight vigils are being held to offer prayers and support to the families left behind. Donation funds have been set up at various banks. Stephanie Sprang's father and children are receiving donations of meals. Via the two Facebook pages, anyone in the world can offer support in any way possible.

This is how small towns react in the face of tragedy. They help in any way they can. Strangers console one another. They pray alone or together. We give each other hope, no matter how dark things seem. And I can't imagine living in any different type of community.

The young kidnapping victim is recovering from her ordeal and is safe with her father. The search continues for Kody Maynard, his mother Tina Herrmann and her friend Stephanie Sprang. If you would like to offer your support visit the Facebook pages Pray for the Maynard Kids and Letters and Prayers for Stephanie Sprang's Family.

If anyone in the Knox County area has any information, no matter how trivial it may seem, please contact the Knox County Sheriff's Office at 1-888-363-TIPS (8477).

Local Forum: KnoxPages.com

Published by Debbie Henthorn - Featured Contributor in Business & Finance and Lifestyle

Debbie has been blessed with an incurable wanderlust. Former jobs included extensive travel throughout the United States, making it possible for this self-proclaimed "food/beer/wine geek" to taste the countr...  View profile

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Tiffany Booth11/19/2010

    Good reporting on such a tragic story.

  • Gentle heart11/19/2010

    I do believe someone has their signals crossed in the belief of God and Jesus. It would pay to take a course in Christianity, or Buddhism, or whatever. God never promised we would have a easy going life, He gave us free choice, what we do with that is our way we want to live. You answer to God upon judgement. He is not Santa, or the tooth fairy. He is God, our Heavenly Father that does promise to comfort us, help us through these times such as this, and we are never alone.
    Jesus Dust? I am sorry that is offensive.
    The out come was going to be one or two ways, God called them home, they never have to suffer at man's hand again.Praise be to God. Why this happened we won't know till the story is heard. Do not scorn God.He didn't kill these wonderful people. God Bless

  • RenelleAnnett11/19/2010

    Wonderful story on a horrendous tragedy.

  • Jolynne M Hudnell11/18/2010

    Good reporting on this tragic situation.

  • Just an observation11/17/2010

    Nobody is asking you to believe, Manticore. I respect your right to believe or not. But if their beliefs are helping them cope and getting them through this crisis, why should it bother you so much? I think most of these people realize where this tragedy is going, but their faith is what is going to give them the strength to face it. My God never promised I'd never go through hardship, only that he'd see me through it and go through it with me. I hold onto that.
    And you should take some of your own advice. You've brought your share of negativity to the table....

  • Candice L. Collins11/17/2010

    one can only hope they are found alive and well :)

  • Manticore11/17/2010

    Pardon me if I'm a bit too realistic to believe magic Jesus dust is going to poof these people from where ever they are.

  • Just an observation11/17/2010

    And you know what I've noticed about you, Manticore? You haven't posted one positive thing on the Maynard's site. All you do is run everyone else down. Granted, it IS wrong to talk of torture. But you also deride people who talk positively and share their faith. For some reason this seems to bother you too. No God would not approve of some of talk. But God understands that we get angry and frustrated sometimes.
    "The Speculation is what's turning this into a train wreck". Seriously? I can't even believe you made that statement.

  • Manticore11/17/2010

    The speculation is what's turning this into a train wreck. That and sick people who think it's ok to torture people. No matter what someone may have done, torture is sick. You people talking about God or Jesus, do you really think he'd approve?

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.