The much anticipated number starts off sounding like Madonna's "Express Yourself" and there's even a Vogue-like spoken part later on. Yet Lady Gaga has made the claim that she wrote the song in 4 minutes.
You would think after all the comparisons of "Alejandro" to "La Isla Bonita," Lady Gaga would avoid Madonna sound- alikes like the bubonic plague.
But let's back up a moment. Lady Gaga has acknowledged that Madonna has been one of her influences, as well as the late Michael Jackson, David Bowie and Grace Jones. She names Freddie Mercury of Queen as her number one influence.
So when does borrowing a style from another singer cross the line from an influence into being just a plain ol' copycat? Am I a copycat for paraphrasing a line from Madonna's "Like a Virgin" in my title? No, I'm just trying to be cute.
But, I would say you probably cross the line when you have more than one part in the song that reminds you of another singer and that has certainly occurred in "Born this Way" with the "Express Yourself" and "Vogue" imitations. Maybe even three, because some people are even hearing some "Ray of Light" in there (although I didn't notice that myself).
Will this hurt Lady Gaga and make her look like a phony, particularly after she told the Scottish Daily Record that she is unique " and can't be copied." She said that "millions of girls" have tried to copy Madonna but are now gone while "Madonna is still there because she is something special."
Is Lady Gaga now one of those millions of girls who will soon be gone? Probably not, but even if it came true, she's already made a bundle on her other hit songs, like ""Paparazzi," "Poker Face" and my favorite, "Bad Romance."
So the real question is: why does she need to copy anyone? Has she run out of original inspiration?
Sources:
The Fear Factor; Lady Gaga uses tough times as inspiration
Hollywood Reporter: Lady Gaga's 'Born This Way' Criticized for Similarities to Madonna Songs
Published by Valerie Ferrari - Featured Contributor in Arts & Entertainment and Movies
In addition to being a Y!CN Featured Entertainment Contributor, I run a classic poetry site and am the webmaster for several online entertainment businesses. Email me at info@vjwebs.com View profile
- A Mom's Review of Lady Gaga's "Born This Way"Lady Gaga's much anticipated single "Born This Way" was released yesterday with great fanfare. The song sends a great message and with it's pumping beat it will be a favorite in clubs.
Lady Gaga to Perform "Born This Way" at Sunday's GrammysComing up this Sunday (February 13), Lady Gaga is all set up to take over the airwaves with a great deal of TV time being devoted to the 24-year-old star.- Lady Gaga's 'Born This Way' - Uplifting or Racist?Delving into the debate on whether Lady Gaga's new single is an uplifting anthem or racist dross.
Lady GaGa and Pussycat Dolls Rock IrelandThe folks over in Belfast, Northern Ireland got a double dose of American sex appeal as the Pussycat Dolls and Lady GaGa hit town on the latest stop on the Doll Domination Tour...
Lady GaGa: Gone Purple!She's always had a flair for the dramatic, and earlier today (April 16) Lady GaGa was spotted sporting a bold purple hairdo.
- Madonna's Influence on GaGa's "Born This Way" Causes Intergenerational Rift
- Madonna's Camp on Lady Gaga's "Born This Way" - Not Liking How She "Expressed Hers...
- Lady Gaga New Song "Born This Way" a Remix of Madonna's "Express Yourself" Listen...
- Lady Gaga to Release New Album "Born This Way" in May
- Lady Gaga Finishes Recording Her New Album, Titled "Born This Way"
- Lady Gaga's New Song "Born This Way" Debuts at Fashion Show in Paris
- Born This Way Lyrics Finally Have Musical Support





9 Comments
Post a CommentThe Ga dazzles but doesn't deliver much more than the sparkles. Good read Val.
The Lady's got talent, she had talent long before she had an "outrageous costume" department. I'm not sure shes covers any new ground, but she will always have her fame and gazillions of fans, to which my favorite response is "yeah, so does Ric Flair and the WWF HOOOOOOOOOOO!"
Lady Goo-Goo is not in the same league w/ Madonna. Madonna broke ground, had talent. This girl is medium lukewarm. Nicely written, valerie.
Great comparrison.
Please , Madonna has been sued numerous times for "borrowing" other peoples work:
Chavez v. Madonna (1992)
Easy Street Publishing v. Madonna (1993)
Salvati v. Madonna (1997)
D'Onofrio v. Madonna (2002)
Bourdin v. Madonna (2004)
Acquaviva v. Madonna (2005)
Hamilton V. Madonna (2005)
Besides, she "borrowed" part the chorus for "Express Yourself" almost verbatim from the Statple singers "Respect Yourself" - all the way down to the hey hey hey's...
Another comparison to Madonna: They both market themselves very well.
There's definitely a Madonna influence in her music. She admitted to writing "Born This Way in ten minutes, and she hyped it way too much.
Interesting angle on this subject! Time will tell whether or not GaGa can linger.
Great job Valerie!
Let's talk again in five years...Lady Who?