"Women who use Lybrel would not have a scheduled menstrual period, but will most likely have unplanned, breakthrough, unscheduled bleeding or spotting," Dr. Daniel Shames, a deputy director in the FDA's drugs office. "The bleeding can last four to five days and may persist for a year." Women who take other low-dose pills have reported similar issues. This is said to reduce over time as your body becomes adjusted.
University of New Hampshire sociologist Jean Elson pointed to advantages for what she characterized as a small number of women who suffer extraordinarily during menstruation, but overall she said the pill left her with mixed feelings.
"For women in that situation, I certainly can understand the benefits of taking these kinds of medications, but for most women menstruation is a normal life event -- not a medical condition," University of New Hampshire sociologist Jean Elson "Why medicate away a normal life event if we're not sure of the long-term effects?"
I recently read the following speech from Jean Elson and it really left me thinking, I thought she had some great points to add and wanted to share it with you, I welcome your opinions on it:
"Menstrual manipulation appears to be another in a long line of attempts to medicalize women's natural biological life events. The process goes something like this: Some women have problems with a natural body function, like menstruation or menopause; a biochemical treatment is devised; these problems are generalized to include all women who experience that natural body function; and medical treatment is then marketed to all women," Elson says.
"The rationales for using extended-cycle birth control therapy to suppress menstruation include 'hygiene mess,' embarrassment, expense, interference with athletic performance and 'traveling problems.' I am certainly an advocate for making women's lives easier, but I question whether it's appropriate for women to ingest additional hormone medication for what are really social, rather than medical, problems," she says.
"Extended-cycle birth control therapy may have value for a small number of women who experience extraordinary menstrual problems. For most women, however, menstruation is a normal life event, not a medical condition," Elson says. "Employing hormones to curtail normal menstruation strikes me as a very odd mix of feminism and medical authority - women are offered the opportunity to control their own bodies, but what are the real implications?"
"Our cultural beliefs and social arrangements make menstruation more troublesome than it could be. Women would be spared embarrassment if they weren't taught that menstruation is dirty and shameful. They might not find their periods so inconvenient if schools and workplaces provided opportunities for people to rest. And rather than viewing monthly menstruation as a disability, we might celebrate it as symbolic of women's emancipation from the continual pregnancies that disabled earlier generations," she says.
Published by Cara Lauren
Environmental Conservationist by day, Triathlete by night... I love the outdoors and work hard to protect it so I have a place to swim bike and run! View profile
- Harvard Women's Health Watch Discusses Safety and Efficacy of Using Oral Contracep...The September 2007 issue of Harvard Women's Health Watch discusses the new birth control pill Lybrel, which is the first oral contraceptive designed to be taken 365 days a year with no pill-free intervals. Women who u...
- Is it Okay to Not Have Periods?Outlines the risks and benefits of Lybrel
A Quest for the Right ContraceptiveA woman's quest To find the perfect contraceptive.- FDA Approves No-Period ContraceptiveRecently, the FDA has approved a drug that will alter a woman's menstrual cycle, in effect stopping it altogether for an indefinite period of time.
- Pills that Stop Menstruation: What Should I Take?Back in the day periods were a fact of life. We got them, we suffered through them, and we dreaded the passing of the next 21 day until it came again. Now, periods are being called inconvenient and passé.
- The Future of Birth Control: Lybrel
- Lybrel: No More Periods with this Birth Control Pill?
- First Birth Control Pill to Eliminate Menstruation Approved
- New Pill Promises No More Periods for Women
- Birth Control Methods - Could Some Be Dangerous?
- Lybrel: More Than an Oral Contraceptive
- No More Periods! The Facts About Lybrel
