Makers Vs. Takers: Class Warfare in America
I've been thinking about something Fox correspondent John Stossel said recently, that there is a war going on between the "makers" and the "takers". It occurs to me that his erroneous position is at the core of what's wrong with much of the modern right-wing platform.
His error is not in concept; he has the general idea right. He is simply backwards in its application.
Remember the criticism of President Obama following the death of Osama bin Laden? "All he did was give an order," was a common phrase.
Isn't the same true of many of the rich?
Who is it that really "makes" things in this country? Is it the fat cats, sitting in their board rooms, or the workers whose sweat keeps the factories we still have left running?
Who is it that is really "taking"? Is it the people who work two full-time jobs just to be broke, or is it the billion-dollar bonus bozos on Wall Street and their ilk at Exxon?
Of the two groups, which sends our jobs overseas? Which controls the giant bottom-line driven insurance companies that tell our doctors to let us die when a treatment costs too much? (Death panels? Already have them, thanks.)
Can an executive 'make' a wall? No, but a mason can. Can a captain of "industry" operate his own factory? Not bloody likely.
Who really are the makers, the people who built this country and made it great? And who really is doing nothing but taking?
Now don't get me wrong - there are several very wealthy individuals in this country that earned every penny they have, either through incredibly hard work or brilliant innovation. By the same token, there are definitely people out there who 'leech' off the system.
However, when Mr. Stossel tries to tell me that those among us who have devoted their lives to helping others, or have labored to exhaustion for the enrichment of another who has never lifted anything heavier than a pen in his or her entire life, are doing nothing of value but only "take," I have one thing to say.
To "take" Mr. Stossel's favorite phrase: "Give me a break!"
Published by Bryan Belrad
The mind behind Zero Sum Theory, author of best-selling fiction and non-fiction, see what else he's up to on Facebook. View profile
Jesse Jackson and Michael Moore Call for "Class Warfare."Aren't Jackson and Moore's threats "treason?"- One Nation Rally Attendee Issues Threat of "Violent Class Warfare."Can you say idiot?
President Obama Had to Cave as Republicans Successful in Holding Middle...If the tax cuts being extended for the wealthy had been used for the countries physical, educational, and other infrastructure the multiplicative nature would have been much lar...- Union Victory Will Be Short Lived Without Narrative Pivot to Class Warfa...I tend to agree that the push by Republicans in Wisconsin to destroy unions have the potential to backfire. My fear however is that unlike the Republicans (Tea Party) we tend to...
The Movie Fight Club Uses Aggression and Masculinity as a Vehicle for Cl...While appearing to focus on gender issues and railing against consumerism, corporatism, and capitalism, 'Fight Club' powerfully reveals the limits of our political imagination.
- Class Warfare Rears It's Head at Obama's News Conference
- Class Warfare, Ideology, and the Ways in Which Rap and Country Music Are Identical...
- Class Warfare?
- Ben Bernanke on 60 Minutes Should Be a Call to Class Warfare by the Middle Class
- Class Warfare a Must as the Wealthy, the Plutocrats, the Oligarchs Responsible for...
- Obama, Biden, Progressives Play the Class Warfare Card
- Class Warfare: Are the Rich United in Their Efforts to Sustain the Status Quo?
2 Comments
Post a CommentI arrived at my "verdict" through logic and personal experience. Pledging allegiance to a particular flag or nation no longer serves the corporate bottom line, and most corps have expressed a keen interest in having two classes...the wealthy and the poor. The wealthy will own the land, housing, energy, food, the power and political machine, and the poor will do their bidding because all other games have been removed. The societal landscapes will be bleak for most, and stunning for the few. Stossel's phrase is as tired as those who struggle every day on this planet. Good write Bryan.
I think the verdict is still out on this one. I also think that someone has to take the whole picture into consideration before making a decision on it. It's like the yin and the yang, you can't have one without the other.