Foucault's criticisms of the authorial function are myriad and oftenconfusing, though ultimately they do make sense in a strictly theoretical way that may or may not actually be capable of application. Foucault states that only certain texts qualify as having an author, the rest have only writers. The result of this murky concept lies in his theory of what exactly constitutes the function of an author and for Foucault there is a very definite function, which is, again somewhat murkily stated, to characterize societal discourse. If Michel Foucault is being sincere in an attempt to apply authorial function only to certain texts, then one of the unfortunate aspects of this essay is that he is guilty of exactly that which he is criticizing.
If Michel Foucault is being ironic by arbitrarily assigning a function to the author, then he has weakened his overall argument by stating that readers are capable of finding meaning only in certain kinds of texts while other texts can never be subject to the question of theirmodes of existence of discourse. A more disturbing problem for a nominal text that ends with the author posting the question of what does it matter who is doing the speaking concerns the hypothetical impact of a newly discovered text by Sigmund Freud and how it would transform historical knowledge as well as the field of psychoanalytic theory. For good or bad, the most important factor of that book would not be the knowledge contained within, but the very fact that it was the name Sigmund Freud that appeared on the cover. That alone would seem to be enough to confirm the importance of why it matters who is speaking but that fact is actually eclipsed by the realization that the critic who is asking why it should matter who is speaking isn't some anonymous ahistorical Pierre Dupont, but is rather the very specific author named Michel Foucault who uses no less than five first person singular pronouns in the first paragraph of his essay.
Published by Timothy Sexton
Timothy Sexton was honored by being named the very first Writer of the Year of Associated Content, now known as Yahoo! Contributor Network. Timothy has published two novels and contributed chapters to S... View profile
- Sex and Social Order: The Transformation of Intimacy by Anthony GiddensTraces links between the development of human sexuality and the evolution of modern capitalist and democratic society. Applies Giddens' text to a number of nineteenth and twent...
- Series of Philosophy and Pop Culture Books Great for Fans of BothThe Philosophy and Pop Culture series of books from Open Court press prove to be entertaining and educational for both fans of philosophy and pop culture.
- Truth and LanguageDerrida and Foucault both discuss the relationship of truth and language.
- Madonna's Impact on SocietyMadonna is one of the most well-known woman in the world. Her career has spanned over two decades and has continued to influence popular culture. For almost each cultural and social trend, Madonna has contributed to t...
- Book Review: Discipline and Punish by Michel Foucault
- Musicology and Semiotics: A Non-Traditional Approach to Studying Popular Music
- Simpsons Web Sites
- Interview with an Author: Gregory Gaines, Jr.
- Was Michel Foucault Right About Jack Kerouac?
- Panopticism: Explaining the Concept Found in Discipline and Punish: The Birth of t...
- Michel Foucault: The Panopticon and Panopticism