12

Miley Cyrus' Asian Woes: Apologies Unaccepted, a Billion-Dollar Lawsuit, and Slammed by Margaret Cho

Sometimes a Picture Not Only Says a Thousand Words, but Provokes Them as Well

Saul Relative
Sometimes a person just cannot win. Take Miley Cyrus, for example. Ever since those MySpace pictures of her nearly naked, with her posed provocatively, and those where she was in the shower - the girl can't catch a break. Even when she did a more mature type of photo spread for Vanity Fair, she caught tremendous heat and was told to act her age (which was15 at the time). Then someone took a picture of an unintentionally exposed breast, so it was her fault that the dress was ill-fitting. Now, she has Asian Americans so annoyed with her latest irresponsible picture that some have demanded an apology, one has filed a lawsuit, and another has written a stinging song condemning her insensitive act.

After the picture in question - Miley Cyrus and some friends sitting around slanting their eyes at the camera - hit the internet, the OCA (Organization of Chinese Americans) immediately branded it "insensitive" and immediately demanded an apology. Cyrus petulantly wrote on her blog that she was sorry if she offended people with her goofy face and her apology, according to MTV, was not accepted by most Asian groups. Then, a couple days later, the 16-year-old apologized in earnest. Again via her blog, Cyrus said on Monday, "I really wanted to stress how sorry I am if the photo of me with my friends offended anyone. I have learned a valuable lesson from this and know that sometimes my actions can be unintentionally hurtful."

It remains to be seen whether this more heartfelt apology will be accepted.

But one woman, Lucy J. Kim, is not accepting her apology, according to TMZ, and has filed a billion-dollar class-action lawsuit against the "Hannah Montana" star, taking it upon herself to speak for the entire Asian Pacific Islander population of Los Angeles - about 1 million people - and demanded roughly $4000 for each of them for Cyrus' remarks. The lawsuit was filed Wednesday in Los Angeles Superior Court and cited that Miley Cyrus "knew or should have known that her image would be publicly disseminated via the media, which Cyrus knew focused on her private life, specifically TMZ."

Comedienne Margaret Cho isn' t feeling too charitable about the picture, either. Writing on her blog, Margaret Cho, whose ancestors are Korean, recited a little poetic ditty that slammed Miley Cyrus for her offensive behavior. The first four lines alone are scathing:

"Miley Cyrus made some chinky eyes

Standing behind an Asian guy

I don't know if this should fly

As if there wasn't enough to despise"

Given as much trouble as she has gotten herself into over her private pictures, one would think that young Miley Cyrus might think twice before taking another picture of herself or allowing a friend to take a picture and posting said picture (or pictures) to the web.

Pictures do say a thousand words, and so do those that view them. And what the viewer sees can often be nothing that was intended by the creator of the picture. That should be the lesson Miley Cyrus takes from this.

Miley Cyrus is only 16 years old. She has a lot to learn, which is rather evident. Unfortunately, she is having to learn it publicly.

******

Sources:

TMZ.com

Margaretcho.com

MTV.com

Published by Saul Relative

WVU graduate, with degrees in History, English, Secondary Education, Computer Programming, and Psychology (and nearly a degree in Political Science). Originally from West Virginia, with stints in Virginia,...  View profile

  • Miley Cyrus / Hannah Montana has had several picture scandals -- some nearly naked, some not.
  • A class action lawsuit was filed for $4 billion dollars over her latest Asian picture controversy.
  • Margaret Cho took offense at Miley Cyrus' picture and wrote her a pointed poem.
The "Hannah Montana & Miley Cyrus: Best of Both Worlds Concert" film set the record in 2008 for the highest grossing movie in its debut week for a movie released to less than 1000 theatres.

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Michelle4/3/2009

    You are all dumb. As an individual of asian descent myself, I can state
    that I have been made fun of numerous times. BIG F-IN DEAL!!! If you
    are so sensitive about a photo that had nothing to do with you (Miley
    doesn't even know you exist) then you should really grow up. Everyone
    always gets teased for something, if its not the asian thing, its
    somethin else. Dont be so damn sensitive and leave the poor girl alone.
    She's only 16 and she deserves to have some fun without people like you
    giving her crap all the time for it! You did stupid stuff when you were
    little, how would like to be taunted about it in the media day after daya?
    Why dont these people get angry about real issues, like the economy, our
    poor health care system, and war? Let Miley be an teen!!! Lucy Kim is retarded, and should be ashamed for pressing a lawsuit against a young girl. She's just money greedy.

  • asiangirl2/26/2009

    im asian but didnt get offended.. whatever, apology is fine but lawsuit? too much!

  • samaira2/16/2009

    Good job done here.

  • Hotcat2/15/2009

    Lucy Kim's lawsuit is a joke, plain and simple. I hope she gets laughed out of court. What is this country coming to?

  • Bat Canary2/14/2009

    Public complaints = valid. Slammed (however illiterately) by Margaret Cho = valid. Billion-dollar lawsuit = bullshit.

  • Charlene Collins2/13/2009

    Oh good grief!!! These people need to get over themselves. She's a kid! How many kids haven't made faces with slanty eyes? I have done it too when I was a kid and it had nothing to do with pretending to be Chinese or making fun of Chinese people.. I slanted my eyes because I felt like it.. and to sue her is just being money hungry. These people need to grow up themselves.. they act younger than she is.

  • Anne Stjern2/13/2009

    A lawsuit over a teenager making a face? Talk about frivolous litigation! It seems like people are going out of their way to be offended, which frankly, is offensive.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.