Motherhood: Examining the Effectiveness of Differing Parenting Styles

Cicely A. Richard
Every mother has her own parenting style. Some of these styles are shaped by the way they were raised, while other mothers try to be completely different from the way they grew up. Some mothers are a combination of the various methods of motherhood. These styles vary in extremes, and there are pros and cons to all these different parenting styles. Here are a few common ones seen today.

"The Working Mom" has become more common in the past 20 years. Before, most mothers stayed at home and a working mother was an anomaly. Most women now work out of need rather than want. A pro of the working mom is that she demonstrates her ability to financially support her family. At a time when even two-parent families are struggling, she illustrates the need for a woman to have a marketable skill. A con of the working mom is the guilt she feels because she misses a lot of milestones in her children's lives. Instead of rallying around the working mom, some stay-at-home moms compound this guilt by criticizing her decision to keep working.

"The Academic" is the mom who may be educated. Thus, she feels the only way to succeed in the world is by excelling in academics. She pushes her children to do well in school. This is a pro because she wants her children to do their best. They may even put their children in advanced placement classes. The con of the academic mother is that she can become pushy, neglecting to let her children be children. She may restrict things that are fun or over schedule her children. It's hard to strike the balance between academic success and children having fun.

"The Friend" wants her children to come to them with all of their problems and may even participate in some of their children's activities. Children feel comfortable with her because she may act younger and not act like everyone else's mothers. She may even dress in trendy clothes. Although nothing is wrong with dressing in fashionable clothing or being current, the mother who wants to be a friend with her children may have a hard time balancing motherhood with friendship. Sometimes, she may have a hard time laying down the law when she needs to do so. I think this is a common style of motherhood because we want our children to come to us, but we also need to discipline them when the situation warrants it.

There are a number of types of mothers in this world, and no style of parenting is perfect. There are pros and cons of different parenting styles. Usually, the best option is use a combination of all of the techniques. In this way, we can try to be good mothers. Of course, we will all make mistakes along the way.

Published by Cicely A. Richard

Cicely was born and raised in a small town in Southern Louisiana, located approximately 30 miles outside of Baton Rouge. She has been published in ForeWord Magazine and the Arizona Daily Star. She currently...  View profile

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Artisttia Yarns5/25/2009

    Awesome article. Are you thinking of doing a book?

  • Secretsides3/9/2009

    One of the most important types of mothering is disciplining but with love and still being the kind of mother that a child can confide in and feel close too.

  • Secretsides3/9/2009

    Very interesting article and so true about different mothering styles.

  • Secretsides3/9/2009

    Very interesting article and so true about different mothering styles.

  • Kristie Leong M.D.3/4/2009

    This would form a good basis for a book. I could see it being a top seller. :-)

  • Gillian Wilk3/4/2009

    Great article. You're so right about there being a lot of different parenting types out there. I'm still trying to figure out which one works best for me!

  • Stephen Joltin3/3/2009

    My wife's technique is unconditional love and patience. Sometimes I think you have to be more of an authority figure tempered with love, especially during the teenage years. Great article.

  • Patricia Sicilia3/3/2009

    I learned that "the friend" mother, often called "the cool mom," is not really what kids want. My daughter told me years later that she never felt she'd be able to live up to me. I was devastated.

  • Onemargaret3/2/2009

    Excellent advice. Every mother is different, therefore, their parenting techniques will be different but, at the same time, quite effective. Very good article.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.