There are two groups fighting against the music monstrosity. The first group says the collaboration can never be done. They are the younger generation of the church and some leaders of the church who wish they could be young again. They don't listen to what the church wants in the way of music, they assume. (This is just through my personal experience.)
The second group is the older generation and some of the young that have grown up with the hymns. They are not as tunnel visioned as the other, because they tend to accept, or at least deal with, the newer generation. The older generation feel as if they are being kicked out of church.
I personally can see both sides of the picture. However, each needs to give a little. The newer generation needs to respect the older and the older should allow for changes as well
However, I've always thought that there should be a way to collaborate both hymns and modern music, so it can please both groups. Arrangements have been made of hymns. But, why change the chorus melody and lyrics? Is that just to make it seem new? Probably a lot of the younger generation don't even know these hymns. Then, they are new to them. I personally would rather sing the "tried and true" version of the hymn, because that's how I know them. They can be tastefully done to fit both groups.
You can find excellent arrangements of the hymns that you could use in your service. Very orchestral sounding hymns are pleasing to the ear to most people. Some of those can even be pretty upbeat.
Hymns do not have to be slow! There are many positive, happy hymns, that are played slow, just because they are considered a hymn.
I was part of the worship scene for a lot of years, and this is was I think. I would like churches to bridge the gap for worship, so that everyone can enjoy going to church. Church should not be a big fight, it should be about bringing others to Christ.
Here are some examples of newer arrangements for hymns that could be used. http://www.audiblefaith.com/pages/cd000087
http://www.midimarvels.com/Sample_Page.htm
You can find more by searching in google for contemporary hymns, or instrumental worship.
Published by Alison Hasselquist
I'm a piano and flute teacher who graduated from college with a B.A. in Music in 2006. View profile
- Running in Church?Do you run in church? Why not? All my life, one adult after another admonish all children within hearing, "Don't run in church!" Is this really what God wants?
Clowning Around in Guatemala!I travel. I clown. I write. The article is a travelogue of one such trip to the Highlands of Guatemala, playing with the local kids, spreading a sense of laughter as healing in...- Manchester, Connecticut Live Music VenuesIn the Hartford, Ct suburb of Manchester, there are several live music venues that host regular performances by a variety of acts.Most of these venues are bars and restaurants. Each has its own musical identity, leadi...
- Beautiful Wedding Sites in the California Gold CountryInformation on seeral wedding venues in the California Gold Country
- Spend the Christmas Holiday in ItalyConsider a visit to Italy during the Christmas season, rich in traditions and special events.
- Churches and Places of Worship in New Prague, Minnesota
- The Church's Attitude Toward Music in the Medieval Era
- The Best Places to Enjoy Classical Music in London
- Christian Hip Hop Music; A Controversial Musical Approach
- Music and Prayer in the Jewish Tradition: Where Are Our Songs?
- Beautiful Wedding Venues in the Peninsula Near San Francisco, CA
- The Rare Voice of Women in Music History: Females Singing Tenor and Bass Lines




1 Comments
Post a CommentI grew up in a traditional conservitive Southern Baptist church listing to Hymns from the Broadnall and other updated Baptist hymnals. Some are quiet, some can be lively but that is just as our worship is. Sometime you want to be quiet and reverant, sometime you feel excited and want to sing praises and Hallaluah!!! I think Christian music should fit those slots and everything inbetween. The problem is I may be feeling revelrant, quiet and thoughtful while you on the other hand may be praising and shouting. That is when the rub comes in. The answer to that is to just respect each other. When you have two or more listening to a radio, you do not always agree on the song playing but you just enjoy the music til your song comes on. Christian music of any gengre WILL speak to you if you open your heart and let it. Music can actually speak deeper than words.
I enjoy all types of music. Music fills my heart or quietens it. If I am sad, disappointed, angry or downhearted, I sing