Name Brand Vs. Store Brand Foods

Cee Belair
Cornflakes to Macaroni and cheese, peanut butter and bread. The staples of a frugal diet for most of us high debt, low-income wage earners. Is there a difference between name brand and store bought? Yes, there absolutely is. In price.

I was a brand-name junkie up until a year ago or so. Kraft Macaroni and Cheese, Kellogg's Cornflakes, which I have an eternal craving for cornflakes... Jif Peanut Butter and JJ Nissen bread. Cutting corners entered into my life, and at first it was quite a shock to have to give up my "names." After all, I had to give up all the other important things in my life, like gas for my car, hair and nail appointments, and every other frivolous thing I had come to enjoy. I was fighting with myself that I wanted to at least enjoy the little thing that comforted me in times of trouble, my food.

Down to the store I wandered... I winced when I looked at the store brand bread. This was the first on my chopping block of my new found frugal lifestyle. Surely, my family would reject it and I could happily prance back to the store for my old faithful, JJ Nissen. Lo and behold, the store brand bread was softer and didn't rip when I buttered it. Ok, so we can knock and extra $1.50 off a loaf of bread. That wasn't so bad! Next came the macaroni and cheese, then the peanut butter. One by one they surprised me, not only in better taste but also at the checkout. I was cutting several dollars a week off of my grocery list! The best thing about it, the family was asking me to never buy Kraft again! They loved the new Stop & Shop Macaroni and Cheese! Store brand peanut butter really tastes the same as Jif, so no big announcements there, other than 50 cents to take off the price.

Last, and most certainly not least, I had to ditch the Kellogg's. Corn flakes are my comfort food, cheap, soggy, everything I like... Don't ask me why, I don't know. Slowly I wandered the cereal aisle, looking for a sale on Kellogg's, unfortunately there was none. I hesitated as I picked up the Hannaford brand corn flakes and saw a good $1 difference in price. I prayed that I was making the right choice. Of course, in my depression of having to give up my name corn flakes, I immediately had to go home and pull out a bowl and drown myself in sorrow amongst my sugar and milk. Pleasantly surprised, they tasted just like the Kellogg's.

All in all, my shopping list was getting better by the day. So the moral of the story here is, don't give up on those store brand goods. You might be pleasantly surprised as I was, and the rest of my family. The store brand was not only similar in taste, but some of the foods were actually better tasting. The price certainly was better on the wallet, which in the end made it all worthwhile. I do have to admit though, I really miss that cute little rooster on the Kellogg's box!

Published by Cee Belair

Working mom of 3.  View profile

20 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Neal1/30/2011

    If you live in the southeast USA, I believe that the Piggly Wiggly pop tarts taste better and better texture than Kelloggs.

  • William1/30/2011

    Most store brand food & drinks are pretty darn good. The only store brand that I do not like, is Clover Valley from Dollar General

  • Momizzle11/24/2010

    Generic food is gross, and it has poor packaging. Unless, of course, you're shopping at Target, but, then you wouldn't really be saving by buying generic. There are very few store brand name foods that can even compare to name brand. The cereals taste stale, the rice never softens, the peanut butter tastes salty. . . And trust me, I've certainly on a budget - but, I think it pays off to spend the extra 13 cents if it means you'll actually eat it.

  • Amy Brantley3/20/2007

    Great article! Companies sometimes make several brands, including the store brands. So it's not unheard of for a company to make your favorite brand name and the store brand as well. There are several store brands I prefer over name brands. For example, Walmart brand flavored rice is much better than Rice-a-Roni.

  • Jeff T. Blade3/20/2007

    Soda is one product that I noticed that has a huge difference in taste. I always buy the name brand stuff

  • nyjdmr3/20/2007

    I found one thats huge difference recently. Toilet Paper !!!! Get the good stuff!!!!

  • Charlotte Kuchinsky3/19/2007

    Good article, nicely written. I buy store brands as well, whenever I can. Some of them are even actually better than name brands.

  • Jonna Tharp3/19/2007

    i always buy walmart brand food and it tastes the same as the expensive brands, glad you're tryin to convert the world too!

  • Jacques Boulerice3/19/2007

    Stop & Shop--one of my favorites, along with PathMark, when I lived in New Jersey. My wife is fairly addicted to brand names, whereas I've always been willing to give the store brands a chance. When I lived in Tennessee, Kroger's store products always were equal to or better than the big brands, and now that Kroger and Ralphs are one and the same, I can get Kroger branded food at Ralphs here in California. Most people don't realize that "generic" products are made by "big label" companies. Even the largest grocery chains don't have the finances to have their own processing plants.

  • Cee Belair3/19/2007

    Thanks for all the comments! You guys and gals are great :)

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.