Naomi Wolf and the Republican Police State

What was She Thinking?

Erin Thursby
I've been sighing with annoyance every time I've heard a far-right political pundit say that Obama will usher in Muslim rule and a Communist State. I remember thinking; do they know how stupid this makes them sound? This sort of thing just undermines Republicans.

Well the right certainly does not have the market covered on crazy. The left has their share of idiotic hyperbole. Case in point, Naomi Wolf's recent post on The Huffington Post www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/the-battle-plan-ii-sarah_b_128393.html It's titled "Battle Plan II: Sarah "Evita" Palin, Muse of the Coming Police State.

She asserts that that if the McCain/Palin ticket wins "Under the Palin-Rove police state, there will be no further true elections."

That's right, the Republicans are Fascists.

It's true that Republicans are using Palin as the figurehead for conservatives, but Wolf goes too far. So far, in fact that her rhetoric will be fodder for Republicans.

First, she totally dismisses the entire electoral process.

"Remember, Russia has Presidents; Russia holds elections. Dictators and gangs of thugs all over the world hold elections. It means nothing."

Yep. Doesn't mean a thing. Why vote? Apparently it's fixed anyway, according to Wolf:

"A gang or cabal seizes power, usually with an affable, weak figurehead at the fore. Then they will hold elections -- but they will make sure that the election will be corrupted and that the next affable, weak figurehead is entirely in their control."

Then there's this paragraph:

"I realized early on with horror what I was seeing in Governor Palin: the continuation of the Rove-Cheney cabal, but this time without restraints. I heard her echo Bush 2000 soundbites ("the heart of America is on display") and realized Bush's speechwriters were writing her -- not McCain's -- speeches. I heard her tell George Bush's lies -- not McCain's -- to the American people, linking 9/11 to Iraq. I heard her make fun of Barack Obama for wanting to prevent the torture of prisoners -- this is Rove-Cheney's enthusiastic S and M, not McCain's, who, though he shamefully colluded in the 2006 Military Tribunals Act, is also a former prisoner of war and wrote an eloquent Newsweek piece in 2005 opposing torture. I saw that she was even styled by the same skillful stylist (neutral lipstick, matte makeup, dark colors) who turned Katharine Harris from a mall rat into a stateswoman and who styles all the women in the Bush orbit --but who does not bother to style Cindy McCain."

Horrors! Palin got a makeover! Not only that but the relatively inexperienced VP pick has speechwriters who spout the Republican party-line/rhetoric! It's PROOF, proof I tell you that it's all a conspiracy.

The really annoying part is that some of the things she's talking about, such as this mass arrest: www.alternet.org/blogs/peek/99433/incredible_documentary_footage_of_mass_arrest_in_st._paul/ really are things we need to be talking about. But all that gets discounted when you start calling the opposition a "cabal" and start sounding frankly, really paranoid:

"Almost everyone I work with on projects related to this campaign for liberty has been experiencing computer harassment: emails are stripped, messages disappear. That's not all: people's bank accounts are being tampered with: wire transfers to banks vanish in midair. I personally keep opening bank accounts that are quickly corrupted by fraud. Money vanishes. Coworkers of mine have to keep opening new email accounts as old ones become infected. And most disturbingly to me personally is the mail tampering I have both heard of and experienced firsthand. My tax returns vanished from my mailbox. All my larger envelopes arrive ripped straight open apparently by hand. When I show the postman, he says "That's impossible." Horrifyingly to me is the impact on my family. My childrens' report cards are returned again and again though perfectly addressed; their invitations are turned back; and my daughters many letters from camp? Vanished. All of them. Not one arrived. Try explaining that to a smart thirteen year old. Try explaining it in a way that still makes her feel secure and comfortable."

THEY want your daughter's camp letters! Or your 13-year-old didn't write and knows you're paranoid. Smart kid. Sigh.

Published by Erin Thursby

I read. I write. I eat. I'm intensely interested in the world and the people around me--hence my MySpace account. Currently writing for EU Jacksonville and I've also had pieces in Jacksonville Magazine.  View profile

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • saul relative10/7/2008

    Wolf is not altogether wrong, Erin. However, she appears too strident. You can tell she fears the fall of our democracy and sees its demise in the orchestrated centralization of government implemented by the Bush administration. It isn't too far of a jump from democracy to police state. Ask the Germans. Remember: the Constitution is just a piece of paper with a few good ideas written on it that means absolutely nothing if no one defends it. Give Wolf credit where she deserves it -- she definitely defends the Constitution.

  • Erin Thursby9/24/2008

    All of the things she's talking about-- hacked e-mails, bank fraud, letters disappearing, wire transfers going missing, bank cards never arriving, pre opened mail-- they've all happened to me and my friends at one point or another. Sometimes frequently. And we don't think there's a conspiracy.

    Some of what she's saying has validity, but it gets lost in the roaring sound of crazy. Which was really my point. If you want people to listen to you, talking this way will only help your opposition.

  • Julia Bodeeb White9/23/2008

    Paranoid ?? Bush put her name on the terrorism watch list. Journalists are being harassed. That is a key sign of a communist nation.

    Wake up and see the reality.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.