National Novel Writing Month

Pros and Cons

Kelly Greene
NaNoWriMo, the abbreviated version of National Novel Writing Month, was designed to help motivate would-be writers to finish a 50,000 word novel within a month's time. While the idea seems impossible, insane even, thousands of people complete this challenge every year.

There are both pros and and cons to being a member in such a contest. The pros include the following: feeling accomplished when you cross the 50,000 word line, turning off your inner editor, and being able to say to yourself that you finally did what you always wanted to do- you wrote a novel.

Crossing the 50,000 word line is fantastic and it creates a thrill since it demonstrates that the participants do have the capacity to tackle such a task.

Being able to turn off the inner editor is a task that most writers find difficult to do. The inner editor is that voice always telling writers that they need to go back and fix a spelling or grammatical mistake and almost seems to force them back to rewrite one line or paragraph until it's perfect. NaNoWriMo forces a writer to turn off the inner editor, because to keep such a voice active would spell chaos- the 50,000 word line would never be crossed.

Also, reaching that 50,000 word line means, for most of the writers participating, that they have completed a novel. And for first time novelists, especially, there is a thrill and confidence that comes from that impossible to explain.

Those are the pros of NaNoWriMo.

The cons are the following: fast-paced writing, no real plot development, no inner editor.

Fast-paced writing is hard for nearly all authors. 50,000 words in a month seems almost ridiculous, if not impossible. And yet, it can be done. But should it be done? Ideas that could be further developed sometimes get pushed under the rug because there's 'no time' to expand on them, no time to develop them more fully. Some writers just aren't built for NaNoWriMo, for such a fast-paced environment, and that isn't a bad thing.

Also, having no real plot makes writing anything difficult. There's a book that goes along with NaNoWriMo, called "No Plot, No Problem," which defines the strategies necessary to get through one month and write 50,000 words. But most of it will end up as gibberish and lots of writers will be dissatisfied wih the novel they have written. It is junk because it was written too fast, and for anyone serious about writing, NaNoWriMo is not the place to go. Serious novelists should take their time and develop their plots.

The last con of NaNoWrimo is the absence of having an inner editor, as they are the voices who help improve a writer's work. Inner editors point out grammatical errors until the writer fixes them so that they're satisfied, and with a real novel, that's definitely not a bad idea.

A serious novel takes time to develop, a good sense of grammatical skills, and the ability to write at your own pace. So if you are a serious writer, NaNoWriMo is not the place you want to be. But if all you want to do is prove to yourself that you can write 50,000 words in a month, then take the challenge and visit the site next November at www.nanowrimo.org and see if you are up to such a fast-paced world.

Published by Kelly Greene

I have a High School Diploma and I am currently working on obtaining my Associates Degree in Business Administratin and Management from Kaplan University.  View profile

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Jennifer N.5/11/2007

    I disagree about NaNo not being for serious writers. I did NaNo last year and won it with a reaserch heavy police procedural mystery. It not only makes sense, but it was fully plotted and fully researched prior to the start of NaNo. Everything down to the placement of each clue was noted ahead of time. Once November came all I had to do was to get the words down on the PC.

    With the proper planning you can do NaNo and be serious AND have a coherant and serious novel in the end.

  • Cassandra Bertolucci5/7/2007

    The good thing about NaNoWriMo is just what it says in "No Plot? No Problem!": most humans do must better under the pressure of a deadline. I have been working on a novel for six months and I had written barely thirty pages and had completely run out of steam. I picked up "No Plot, No Problem" at the library after laughing at the title...and subsequently finished my first 130 page novel on the thirtieth of April 2007, thirty days after beginning.
    Yes, what I've produced is a mass of words which may or may not make sense when I read it again...but I've taken the mystique out of writing a novel. Forever I can say, "Yeah, I've done that." It will never seem as daunting again!

  • Mike Jameson11/24/2006

    I like what you said. Everytime I write a short story or an editorial, I just sit down and start typing and I'm finished 10 minutes later. It's nothing for me to bust out 1 or 2 pages of interesting material. But I started a comedic murder mystery about 6 months ago and I have three paragraphs done. It is difficult to sit down and write that much, that fast. This article makes me feel better in acknowledging that I may not be finished with my book for probably the next two years.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.