But does this biography offer any new information that Oprah herself has not shared with viewers over almost twenty-five years of her television show?
According to the New York Times review of Oprah: A Biography, which criticizes Kelley's interpretations on her questionable sources (the number of which increases, the review says, from 2,732 in the text to 2,932 in the closing acknowledgments), "Ms. Kelley simply replays the televised version [of The Oprah Winfrey Show]. She has nothing new to add to these stories."
The only real "gotcha" in Kelley's biography, says the Times, is that Kelley claims to know the real identity of Oprah's biological father. While interviewing Oprah's cousin Katharine Esters, Kelley says the woman revealed the name of Oprah's biological father and swore Kelley to secrecy.
Kelley's brand of gossipy biography often reveals intimate details of a her subjects-the meaning of such details she feels free to interpret as she likes. In her previous writings, she has suggested that Nancy Reagan and Frank Sinatra had an ongoing affair, and claimed that George W. Bush snorted cocaine at Camp David during his father's term as president.
In Oprah, Kelley apparently sticks to her protocol. Reviews say that the biography includes ruminations on the most personal details of Oprah's life: her history of teenage promiscuity, her experience of giving birth to a baby boy when she was fifteen, and the sexual abuse she endured from a family member.
In addition, it seems that Kelley opens yet again the often-debated discussions on Oprah's relationships with her boyfriend Stedman Graham and her best friend Gayle King. USA Today lists among the "dished" details that acquaintances have labeled Stedman "boring," and that a friend of Oprah's "wouldn't be surprised if Oprah was gay."
However, Kelley is careful not to declare a definitive accusation on that subject. "Relax, people," she says in an interview with USA Today. "I know people are expecting me to 'out' her. But I think she's just asexual. She's poured all of her energies into her career. And if she is, she is never ever, ever going to come out."
Many of Oprah's celebrity friends, like Maya Angelou and Maria Shriver, declined to be interviewed by Kelley for the biography. And as Kelley makes the rounds to promote her book, she is being shunned by many of Oprah's friends in the business. Barbara Walters, Larry King, and David Letterman have all declined to have Kelley on their shows to promote Oprah.
Though Kelley has received criticism for her tell-all biographies, she has also received awards and accolades for her writing. Her work has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, the Washington Post, and yes, even the New York Times, who ultimately declares Oprah: A Biography relatively innocuous, saying that it "aims for the jugular. It doesn't draw blood."
Sources:
Maslin, Janet. "The Queen of Talk Declined to Speak" http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/12/books/12book.html
"Kitty Kelley's new Oprah bio has plenty to talk about" http://www.usatoday.com/life/books/news/2010-04-12-kelley12_CV_N.htm?csp=34&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+UsatodaycomBooks-TopStories+%28Life+-+Books+-+Top+Stories%29&utm_content=My+Yahoo
Kitty Kelley, Amazon.com
http://www.amazon.com/Kitty-Kelley/e/B000AP77I8/ref=sr_tc_2_0?qid=1271091015&sr=1-2-ent
Published by Stacey Laatsch
Stacey Anderson Laatsch holds an M.A. in English and creative writing. Besides providing web content for Yahoo!, she blogs about travel, Illinois, and the writing life and is currently working on a novel for... View profile
- What Will New Oprah Book RevealWhat will the sensational new tell-all book about Oprah Winfrey reveal about this super famous, yet super private star.
- Unauthorized Biography of Oprah to Hit the ShelvesNovelist Kitty Kelley picks Oprah Winfrey for next book
Life with Cat: Part II: KelleyKelley is another of our "throw-away kitties," who has added a lot to our lives.- Biography of Dave Chappelle, Star and Host of Comedy Central's Chappelle's ShowThe Biography of Dave Chappelle is basically a list of television and movie appearances. Dave is known mainly for "The Chappelle Show" on the Comedy Central network. He is reserved when it comes to discussing his pers...
- Should the New York Times Review Self-published Books?It seems self-published books don't exist in the world of the New York Times. But isn't it about time?
- Kitty Kelley Book Alleges Oprah Winfrey, John Tesh Affair -- and Racial Pressures...
- Oprah Winfrey and John Tesh Were Lovers According to Kitty Kelley
- Will Oprah Winfrey Get into Politics to Become the First Female Vice President?
- Can Oprah Winfrey Teach Barbara Walters & "The View" How to Handle Political Candi...
- Oprah Winfrey Blasted By 50 Cent
- How to Get Reservations for Tickets to The Oprah Winfrey Show: Be in the Audience
- Oprah Winfrey: A Biographical Essay





2 Comments
Post a CommentWhen I was with Washington Independent Writers, I spoke with a researcher of Kelly's. She did the dumpster diving thing, which I have nothing against in this sort of genre. I would think she'd have a tough time digging up stuff on Oprah. Oprah started as a news reporter and has that mentality, so she's always made it a point of getting out in front of sketchy items. In organizations like the NSA and CIA, it's not whether or not you've done something, it's whether or not you are keeping it a secret. If you keep it a secret, you can be blackmailed. I don't think there's much Kelly could get on Oprah. Now, with Sinatra who had a mega PR machine, her style would work.
Nice review and analysis.