Osama Bin Laden is Dead: Thoughts of a Victim of 9/11

My Thoughts on This Event

Peter Flom
I was in the World Trade Center when the plane hit. More specifically, I was evacuating 2 World Trade Center (the second building) when the plane hit. I was in the stairwell, and felt the impact. Compared to many, I wasn't that much affected. I wasn't hurt, I got home easily (I ran to the subway which was still running and got home; I watched the collapse from my living room). I didn't lose my job. But I am still a victim. I lost a lot of possessions, and my son was affected. My work suffered because we lost all our records.

Now, the mastermind of 9/11, Osama bin Laden, is dead.

I'm not sad. But I'm not cheering. I am reminded of a story my rabbi told at many Passover seders. (He didn't make it up, he just told it). It seems that when the seas parted to let the Jews go through and then drowned the Egyptians, the angels in heaven started to cheer. God roared for SILENCE. Then he asked "How can you cheer when my children are dying?"

I'm not sad that Osama bin Laden is dead. I can recognize the necessity of his death. I certainly hope that neither the United States nor any other country ever suffers from another terrorist attack.

But I'm not cheering.

Published by Peter Flom

I am a statistician, working with a wide variety of clients, mostly researchers in psychology, education, medicine, social sciences and other fields. I also have given talks and written articles on learning...  View profile

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Orchiolum5/3/2011

    Well said Peter...well said.

  • Jeff Musall5/2/2011

    Nicely said, Peter...

  • John Myers5/2/2011

    Very well said Peter!

  • Maria Roth5/2/2011

    I haven't been cheering either. Very nicely said, Peter.

  • Kathy Minicozzi5/2/2011

    I can't pretend that I am sad that Osama Bin Laden is dead. I am not at all sad; I am relieved that there is one less hate-filled, murdering leader in the world. But I, too, am not cheering. I am not Jewish; but I am Christian and Jesus told us we are to love even our enemies. So no, I do not cheer. Another reason I do not cheer is that there are more where he came from. We have not seen the end of the evil.

  • Donald5/2/2011

    Bravo, Peter. I feel the same way although I was 300 miles from the towers. Osama Bin Laden was a man and to hear of anyone dying is a sad occasion. The necessity for his death was obvious.

  • Adam Michael Luebke5/2/2011

    Thank you, Peter. For some reason it feels misplaced to cheer for this, and I fear America's reaction to Osama's death is the same reaction that continues to get us into unnecessary and dangerous war across the globe.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.