Plastic Church: Part 1: The Burn Factor

Uncovering the Cultural Relevancy of Today's Real Christian Community

Joshua Givens
Can you recall a time in your life when someone in a church hurt your feelings? A pastor? A fellow congregant?

Have you been ignored by a church? Shunned? Judged? Insulted?

Does the very idea of going to church disgust you?

The phrase "I was burned by my last church" is becoming increasingly spoken within Christian circles and religious culture as a whole. What exactly is this phenomenon of church burning?

Church attendance surveys and investigative research from 2008 reveal some rather striking percentages.

According to current religious data gleaned from multiple sources and polls and cited by ReligiousTolerance.org, "Confidence in religious institutions has hit an all-time low." Although there is a supposed increase in the interest of spirituality in North America, it has yet to manifest itself in the form of increased church attendance.

The data shows a gradual decline in attendance of church services within the Protestant denominations since 1992. Between 1992 and 2003, attendance dropped by as much as 13 percent. Interestingly, graph charts reflect a sudden leap in church attendance just after the September 11th, 2001 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon.

However, Only 53% of Americans consider religion to play an active and important role in their lives. This number has been steadily declining since the aforementioned September 11th attacks.

Over the past ten years, there has been a significant increase in the number of church home groups and small group Bible studies. Unfortunately, this may very well be reflective of the poor perception many longtime churchgoers have adopted concerning churches.

Pat Howell, 60, has attended several churches since childhood and admits he hasn't been "burned" by a church.

"I think hurt is the right word," he clarified. "Not burned."

However, during the course of our interview and subsequent discussions, Howell reminisced of one particular church in which individuals even drove away the pastor.

"Someone in the church decided they didn't like him [the pastor]. They started to say things about him that weren't true. There were questions about the sexual preferences of the music minister. Someone brought all of this up. To this day I still know who it was and I hate them. I hate to say that, but I do. [This person] started just enough of a rumor to kill the spirit in that church. They did everything horrible that you could possibly do to a preacher. They cut the power off to his house. They were mean to him. After about six months, he left."

Howell recalled the blatant hypocrisy present in the church community.

"You wind up going to churches and looking at people that you knew had caused someone else's pain and suffering. The church did not split, but it was not the same." He added, "They didn't turn me against my faith, they turned me against that [particular] church and the idea of attending that church."

Unfortunately, Pat is not alone. There are too many stories like his.

More and more men and women are referring to their churches and fellow believers with such disheartening adjectives as: condemning, tactless, smug, fake, unforgiving, arrogant, ignorant, homophobic, intolerant, pushy, rude and unloving.

But what is at the heart of church attendance decline? Is there a problem with the people? Is there a problem with the churches? Why are more and more Christian men and women church hopping? And perhaps the most important question to be pondered: "What does a real, honest and healthy church look like?"

©2009 Joshua D. Givens & The Underground Christian E-Magazine

This article was originally published here: http://theundergroundsite.com/index.php/2009/09/plastic-church-part-1-uncovering-the-cultural-relevancy-of-todays-real-christian-community/

For more feature articles, news and commentary on pop culture from a Christian perspective, visit The Underground at: www.theundergroundsite.com.

Published by Joshua Givens

Public relations, media coordinator and web developer/designer for Northside Bible Church, freelance journalist, reporter and feature writer for Mobile Bay Monthly, the lifestyle magazine for Mobile, AL and...  View profile

  • Recent surveys & data reveal decline in regular church attendance among Protestant denominations
  • Only 53% of Americans claim that religion plays an important & active role in their life
  • What does it mean to be "burned" or hurt by a church?
Over the past 10 years, there has been a significant increase in the number of home church groups--congregants forming their own churches in someone's house.

4 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Will Stape10/11/2009

    If more people involved in organized religion paid attention to this, more followers would not only be appreciative, but obviously probably stick around as loyal parishioners. Great work here.

  • Rachelle Dawson9/24/2009

    Jerry Jenkins wrote a novel called Riven. It's an excellent read, and one of the main characters deals with problems like this. He's a pastor that churches keep hurting. I think Christians who've been hurt by the church or feel as if the church didn't appreciate their gifts would be encouraged by the story.

  • Mimi Bullock9/24/2009

    Good article. I appreciate the research it took. Thanks!

  • Sheryl Young9/24/2009

    Hah! We could easily add this one to my "Today's Christianity" series.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.