Pleas for Help Ignored: Woman Dies on Floor of E.R.
Woman Dies on Hospital Floor, While Medical Staff Ignore Her
As the woman's boyfriend pleaded with those around her for help the mother of three and grandmother of four, she bled all over the E.R. floor from what a Country Coroner found was a perforated bowel.
Nearby a janitor for the hospital mopped up the woman's blood. After Mrs. Rodriguez had made three visits to King-Harbor Hospital for her severe pain, she lay down on a bench outside the hospital. Finding her condition deteriorating, her boyfriend escorted her back inside where Rodriguez collapsed. Through an interpretor, the woman's boyfriend called 911 and pleaded with no avail to police dispatchers. He was told that there was nothing they could do to assist him as he was already at a hospital.
During the days prior to the death of Edith Rodriguez, the couple had sought relief for her pain at the hospital receiving only prescription pain medications and being told that she could go home.
During the evening of her death, her pain increased to the point that she returned once again to the E.R. The woman who collapsed on the floor in agony began spitting up blood. In the news article from the L.A. Times, Jose Prada pleaded with dispatchers on a pay phone located outside the emergency room saying, "My wife is dying and the nurses don't want to help her out." Prada's tone grew more and more desperate as he watched her deteriorate. The L. A. Sheriff's Dept. dispatcher struggled to make sense of the call and urged him to instead contact the doctors and nurses at the hospital, as they were already there.
Eight minutes later an unidentified woman, apparently another patient, placed another call to 911. She pleaded with dispatchers for 2 and 1/2 minutes while being repeatedly interrupted and admonished for making unnecessary calls to 911.
While trying to convince dispatchers of Rodriguez's predicament, she was told that 911 was only for life and death situations and she should hang up and call the regular phone number if she wasn't happy with the service she was getting at the hospital. Frustrated the woman finally told the dispatcher, "May God strike you too for acting the way you just acted." The dispatcher replied with, "No negative Ma'am, You are the one." The call then disconnected.
The L.A. County Coroner ruled that Rodriguez might have been saved if her condition had been detected sooner.
The 911 recordings were released by Sheriff's Department in response to the California Public Records Act, after requested by the L.A. Times. Rodriguez lay unattended on the floor of the hospital emergency room for 45 minutes without attention before succumbing to her illness. She was pronounced dead at 2:17 a.m. Sheriff's Captain Steven M. Reller, who is in charge of Century Station, which handled the call, said that the dismissive tone of the dispatcher was "inappropriate." The worker later received written "counseling" for his response.
In another prior situation at the same hospital, a man with a brain tumor had languished for four days in the same emergency room before being removed by family members and taken to another hospital for emergency surgery. The hospital medical director was replaced after the incident.
Edith Isabel Rodriguez was one of 13 siblings. Rodriguez's funeral service was held after family members raised money by making tamales and having car washes to pay the $7,500 bill. A wreath of red roses and white carnations covered the woman's pastel pink casket while 30 or so family members and close friends sobbed nearby.
LA Times, Tragic Catch-911 for dying woman, http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-calls13jun13,0,3172164.story?page=4&coll=la-headlines-california
Published by M.S.Medina
M.S.Medina is a free lance writer who lives in Southern California. This is her favorite quote. "Speak the truth with compassion." View profile
- How to Prepare for an Emergency Room Visit With Your ChildEmergency Room visits can be scary when your child is the one being taken in. Here are some things to grab before you leave that will make things a lot easier.
- Senior Tips for Going to the Emergency RoomMost seniors expect to make one or more visits to the emergency room but lots don't prepare themselves in advance. Senior tips for going to the emergency room can help to lower anxiety and reduce confusion when it...
- What to Know Before Visiting the Emergency RoomTen insider tips that can help any patient maximize treatment and care on an unexpected visit to the emergency room.
- CT Scans in Emergency Room May Become Standard to Determine Heart DiseaseResearchers have announced a win-win treatment for hospital emergency room patients who have chest pain. By using a CT scan, patients are treated quicker, safely, patient turn-over is improved, and hospital costs are...
- When Parents Should Avoid the Emergency RoomBringing your child to the emergency room can be pretty costly, here are some tips to remember before doing so.
- Woman Dies as 911 Calls from Inside Hospital Are Ignored
- Preparing Your Child for a Stay in the Hospital
- Children in the Emergency Room
- Parents: The Emergency Room and Your Child
- Emory University Hospital Emergency Room
- Kids Will Be Kids - Avoid Trips to the Emergency Room
- An Embarrassing Trip to the Hospital Emergency Room
- A L.A. woman lay dying on the floor in a local E.R. while staff ignored her.
- Calls to 911 were brushed off as the woman's boyfriend pleaded for help.
- Another call by a woman who observed the incident, was also ignored by Sherrif's 911 dispatchers.


33 Comments
Post a Commentthat is amerika.its so sad and sick.no words for that typ of behavior. this would NEVER happen in germany or other civilized countrys.that peole that let her die gonna burn in hell!!!
This is incredibly sad and truly pathetic. When you can't even get proper care at the hospital, where can you go? The dispatcher should be fired, and criminal charges should be filed for his or her lack of concern and inappropriate behavior that contributed to the death of this woman. I've never been overly impressed by emergency room care, but this is about as bad as it gets. Unreal...
This incident is so tragic and bizarre...frightening that this happened right inside a hospital.
Frightening story!!! I hope you do a follow up article on this situation.
I read this story and was sickened by the behavior of the "people" (and I lose that term loosely) who should have been helping this woman. I don't care who she was or what she had done, she was a human being who deserved compassion and care and what she got was a horrifying death. Great reporting!
I live in the L.A. area and the hospital is undergoing some major investigation due to this incident and a couple of past things that happened there. I just don't understand how everyone just stood there and watched the woman writhe around on the floor in agony. I will update you all when the outcome is made known.
I think the end to your comment must have been cut off Margo though I could see where your comment was going. It is a sad commentary about our health care and society in general when these kinds of things become acceptable. I worked in health care and know that most of the caretakers and medical personel are dedicated and overwhelmed by their jobs. Thanks for your comment.
I stayed in a "prestigious" hospital in San Francisco overnight and heard an old man's cries for a nurse for an hour and a half! I had just had surgery that day and wasn't supposed to move. I tried the entire time to get the nurses or SOMEONE to help him! I was pushing the call button the entire time and he probably was too. Finally, after pressing the button so many times and calling out "NURSE" myself (I could hardly speak because of the surgery) I got out of my bed and had to figure out how to get to his room because I was hooked up to so many things. I finally did it and got into his room where he was sweating, shaking and crying. What I went through after that to get help for this poor man would have to be published in a book, but finally I got two "nurses" and a "DOCTOR" to come in to his room there they dismissed me with "we can handle this - go back to bed now". I said - what's wrong with this picture? A PATIENT has to take care of another patient? I found out the next
I can't even believe such a thing could happen. Oh my gosh - I am stunned. Bless this poor family and please keep us posted on the disciplinary actions taken against these professionals. I hope it is swift. Thanks for the report.
That womans family should own that hospital! I hope they sue.