Poetry.Com and The Longevity of Their Scam

Jan Castagnaro
It is amazing that Poetry.com still has so much life even though it is a scam. This site and its sister sites all work on the same principle---preying on the hopes and dreams of innocent people.

I remember learning about Poetry.com when I was 10 years old and my Great Grandmother Trudy was teaching me about poetry, writing, and entering contests. She was a pro at winning writing contests back in her day, when magazines would host contests looking for unique jingles for common household products. She even won a new car, which she happily gave to my Great Grandfather Frank, since she did not drive. But, it has always been her sound advice that has kept me clear of companies that charade as honest legit contests. Grandma said, "You should never have to pay someone to see your work published, especially a contest." This has always kept me away from places like Poetry.com.

The whole premise behind Poetry.com is to get some hopeful person to submit a poem, no matter the quality. Then, Poetry.com declares the person a winner, no matter the quality. Yet, you cannot see your work published unless you actually buy the anthology volume it is going to be published in, along with other hopeful and wanting poets. In many cases, they also make you pay for the trophy or plaque you won and other nice items that showcase the poem you won with. You never see any actual winning, just a promise that now you are eligible to be submitted into the next level of the contest. Oh, and if you win the next phase, you will again get the chance to buy the book. It is a never-ending process of buying a book to see your work and more luring words to keep you hooked on submitting more poetry.

They try to make it look legit with their periodic conferences held all over the country, which you can once again pay them to be part of. Yet still, people keep paying them money to be part of this, which keeps fueling and helping them lucratively advertise their scam, enticing yet more naïve hopeful people. Does anyone ever stop to wonder if anyone has ever reached that final phase and received the large cash prize that Poetry.com claims to offer? They are good at showing winner's testimonies, but are they real?

Interestingly, all one really has to do is research Poetry.com through the Better Business Bureau and discover that they have been perpetrating this scam for quite a long time, sadly. Now, you can even go to any search engine and type in "Poetry.com scam" and turn up page after page of information on this site and their sister sites that all work the same way.

Poetry.com works on vanity. Everyone would like to see their name in lights, right? Well, that is exactly what Poetry.com is hoping for. They hope that you want to see your work and name published in their book, and they feed off that honest hope to sucker a person in to pay for the rights to see their work published.

The unfortunate reality is that any work you submit will be published amongst every other hopeful person that submitted. There is more mediocre work bound in those books than there is anything wowing and powerful. You, the author, never really get an honest critique, which would be like watching an episode of "American Idol" and seeing all the non-singing wannabes make it through and overshadowing any true talent. But again, that is what Poetry.com is counting on, those not so great hopefuls that never had anyone give them a professional and honest critique of their talent. So, you keep on trusting them, you keep on scrounging up money you may not even have to keep buying the newest edition of their anthology which contains your poem. Have you stopped to ask yourself what you really have won through Poetry.com? Chances are, you have been just too excited in the thought that someone is publishing your poem, but are they really publishing your poem or are you paying them for the right to have your work included?

It is also important to note that Poetry.com is just one of the affiliate sites associated with this company. Before the Internet, unsuspecting people would find advertisements from this company, "International Library of Poetry" and "National Library of Poetry" placed in backs of magazines and television guides. Those two organizations are linked to Poetry.com. Here are some of the other sister sites:

International Society of Poets
International Poetry Hall of Fame
Watermark Press
Birthwrites
International Lib
Pegasus Press
International Society of Photography
picture.com
Arts and Kids

They all work the same way. You enter a submission, they notify you that you are indeed a "semi-finalist" and then they request you to pay for a product to see your submission. If you do not pay, you do not get published.

The best advice for someone that wishes to publish their poetry and even make honest money doing so is to hang around professional writing forums. There you can learn all about the market for poetry and learn where to submit your work. Also, invest in a copy of "Poet's Market" and "Writer's Market". These books will point you toward legit companies that are looking to publish your work.

Remember what my Great Grandmother Trudy once told me, "You should never have to pay someone to see your work published, especially a contest." It is time to teach Poetry.com a lesson by not buying into to their scam. If more and more people would take the time to research this company and learn about the type of scam they promote, less people would pay them any mind, which would help put this company and sister companies out of business.

Published by Jan Castagnaro

Jan is a mother of 3, with a husband in the Air Force. She has worked in the medical field on and off for over 12 years, and is presently back in school, working on her degree. Recently, Jan has relocated to...  View profile

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Jan Castagnaro3/16/2010

    Charlene...why don't you make an ebook containing your poetry and then you can sell it online yourself and profit, while getting your work out there.

  • charlene3/16/2010

    i have been submitting poetry to poetry.com for years,mostly because i got free copyrights out of it...however!!! i am not happy about the fact they want me to buy by own stuff just because they published it.
    i have recieved a few letters from the edtor also,(anybody else)? i also feel i should recieve all the anthologies that my poetry is in for free simply because when i agreed to the free copyrights,it was so they could use my poetry to put on items and recordings,etc.to make money,with the promise it would always be "my poetry" and no one else could claim it but they could sell it.i have not sent a poem since the trophy thing because,i got sick of the fact everytime i won something i had to go out of state to get at my own expense and i could never afford to,not to mention afoording the anthologies or plaques with recordings,etc....it goes on and on. i want to make money with my poetry! not pay for my own talent! anybody out there who can help me?
    i'm 53 and been writing since i

  • Catherine Caldwell9/16/2009

    where do I view my poems the last 30 years of writting for Poetry ,com I havent the anthologies of them all Wheres the site Catherine

  • Jan Castagnaro1/2/2009

    Dustin, here's another site that may interest you on poetry.com and its sister sites of scam: http://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/0/005/RipOff0005389.htm

  • Jan Castagnaro1/1/2009

    Dustin, How much did YOU have to pay to go to their convention where you supposedly won something? If you win something you should not ever have to invest money to to get what you have won. Poetry.com is the oldest scam you can even look them up at the BBB and see all the complaints filed against them as well as numerous other sites. Several years ago I even wrote a piece of garbage dribble and submitted it just to test them and sure enough a few months after I received all their lovely "YOU WON" mail now pay us to see your winning entry in an anthology. It's a smack in the face to real talented poets when they actually are scammed and buy it to see their work next to garbage. But any professional writer knows that this place has been scamming for years.

  • Dustin Edwards1/1/2009

    by the way my trophy and stuff was free when i got there and there was no registration fee or anything like that when i went. so if i'm wrong i'm sorry but if i'm not then well i'm not sorry. and i seen my book, i dont own a copy but they were selling them during the convention.

  • Dustin Edwards1/1/2009

    That is not true. I was entered in the poetry.com contest and i actually went to their convention, i have a trophy a plaque and a medal from them, even though i didnt win the money someone else got it. if it was a scam i dont think they would have famous people involved (the mom from the brady bunch) was there when i went. so if you want to point fingers at a scam make sure you do the full investigation on it. go to a convention, get the facts. false accusation is garbage just like your POETRY.COM is a scam crap. sorry for being rude. its not a scam though. i have proof that it isnt. have a good day.

  • juliesam34/5/2008

    Thanks for the article. It is so true.

  • Christi Bowers1/31/2008

    I agree, yet somehow I found myself buying four books to see my poetry published. Dumb me.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.