Public Education School Reform Ideas: Can the World's Best Teachers Reform Education and Public Schools?
Are the Most Innovative and Excellent Teachers Who Have Proven Abilities in the Classroom Enough to Reform the Broken and Outdated Public Education System?
Let's review a real case from Central Florida shared in a letter to the President on his educational policies and reform initiatives.
April 23, 2010
Dear President Obama,
In your education reform initiatives, you state that "Teachers are the single most important resource to a child's learning," and you explain that you plan to remove ineffective teachers from the classroom and invest in innovative strategies to help teachers to improve student outcomes.
In Florida, our middle school had an excellent principal Mrs. P who was moved to another school to help improve them. Then a new principal from elementary school came in. He changed all the classroom locations and changed the school colors. He let the students vote on this and my students-I taught an elective allowing me the pleasure of teaching several hundred of them-wrote in that they desired that the school colors remain the same and new technology was purchased for the school instead. We even crunched the math for the proposal. The new principal was not too happy with the results, my students, or me.
He also changed my courses. I taught keyboarding and business education in one class to 6th, 7th, and 8th graders. I remember how boring typing for an entire semester was when I was a youth so in my courses, we typed for 15 minutes a day and then learned graphic arts and web design. The students flourished, they typed 35wpm (6th), 60wpm (7th), and up to 100wpm (8th) and they learned how to make entire websites. They also learned to make and illustrate digital books, write covers letters and resumes, and create future detailed goal plans. I customized their typing lessons to type college level writings and research in every subject to cross curriculum and improve student achievement in their other subject areas.
My former principal promoted me to TIMs where I taught other teachers to integrate technology in the county, yet my new principal took the web design and use of the internet sites like StartSomething away (which had exposed my students to online forms and web design & interactivity meeting the state standards for my course as well as gave them scholarship opportunities). The following year, this principal required the courses to be 100% keyboarding. My middle school students were previously doing COLLEGE level work, they loved it, they were achieving, and they were learning about all the other subjects and business education before him.
You can get the absolute best teachers in the classrooms but if they are limited by a principal or a school system that punishes students who are too advanced, then it is a waste of federal money and efforts. Part of the problem in our school was that when the 6th and 7th grade students were finished with my course, they were too advanced for the next year's typing or computer course or even some high school courses since I had taught them college level web design and business education as a reward since they mastered typing at an employable level for adults. And the tenured teachers did not want to alter their curriculum or teaching style to accommodate this.
Please CHANGE THIS for the students. The school system, principals, and tenured teachers are draining our student's brains through boredom and sub-standard busy work and contributing negatively to our economic and academic competitiveness worldwide.
Thank you,
Heather Inks
Experienced Educator
Experience includes:
Valencia Community College Tutor (most college course offerings)
Early childhood, Pre-K, and K-5 All Subjects
Math K6-12th
Business Education K6-12th
Gifted Education
Delinquent and At-Risk Youth
Critical Shortage Areas
Continuing Education and Professional Training for Teachers and Adults
Sources:
President Barack Obama, Education Issues - Reform and Invest in K-12 Education, The White House [4/23/10]
Published by Heather Inks
Heather is a social entrepreneur who educates on how to improve communities & the world. Heather's site has crafts, home improvement ideas, & social issues: www.HeatherInks.com She's an active writer, teache... View profile
- School Reform and No Child Left Behind ActThe time period of this piece will start in the early 1950's and extend into the next century. This paper will reflect upon the four principles of the No Child Left Behind Act and will present an essay on contemporary...
- The Paradigm of EducationThis article discusses some of the conflicts with funding public education in the United States. It also discusses some of the problems with growth in public education.
Online Education as a True Agent of ChangeU.S. public education system has been under intensive criticism for its inefficiency and tremendous cost. In a search for solution, remote learning model, a.k.a. online educatio...- Restructuring EducationWhole-school reform, also referred to as comprehensive school reform, contains various programs that include efforts by educational institutions, parents, and the community in the academic and personal achievement of...
- Management of Change in Public Schools and the Success of MemphisThe report on Memphis's restructuring of its public school system is a prime example of comprehensive school reform, site-based management, and systemic change.
- Structural Violence in the Public School System
- The Absolute Failure of the Public Education System
- Public Education Falling Short
- Cheating Our Kids Exposes the Real Problems in America's Public Schools
- Public Education and Its Human Rights Violations
- It's Time to Abolish the Public Schools, Part 2
- School Reform: Progression
- Educate to Innovate - The White House: www.whitehouse.gov/issues/education/educate-innovate
- Why the Public Schools Don't Work Well Anymore: www.heatherinks.com/education/public_schools_articles/what_is_wrong_with_public_schoo
- How to Fix the School System: www.heatherinks.com/education/public_schools_articles/how_to_fix_the_public_school_sy
- Can The World's Best Teachers Reform Education and Public Schools?
- Are the Most Innovative and Excellent Teachers Enough to Reform the Broken Public Education System?
- My middle school students were previously doing COLLEGE level work before the new principal.





13 Comments
Post a CommentThe entire vocation of teaching has become overly programmed, systematized, and paralyzed. It's like "may the best robot win."
I worked with teachers for about 15 years and discovered they have the best ideas. Unfortunately, administration doesn't or can't always listen. Then there is the fact that good teachers get lumped with bad ones and they get discouraged and eventually give up even trying.
This type of unfortunate incidents happen in other areas as well. I think that in many cases, it's usually caused by so-called good intent that is not followed up by adequate enforcements of measures. In other words, if someone is going to improve the school system, this should mean, not just teachers, but also school administrators and so on.
Wow, a real eye-opener, Heather! I usually recommend homeschooling! Thanks for highlighting such a key problem!
Excellent article. SO much needs to be done, but hopefully things will improve.
Great points, Heather. I'm afraid innovative teachers aren't rewarded down here...it's all about the students' grades. Our legislators want teachers pay to be based on government tests. We're fighting it.
If the public schools were paid based on graduates with a bonus for early graduates, then we would see less students failing and hundreds of thousands of early graduates nationwide. Right now, schools get more money per child for ADD and ADHD as well as for each day attended (in many states), so it should not be a surprise to find lots of children with ADD and ADHD as well as lots of children being held back for another year. If a parent wants to hold their elementary school child back one year, they allow it but they don't allow a parent to push for the child to be "skipped" a grade. Why? Funding. God bless.
Heather, you are a wonderful teacher who challenges her students, sorry you had to endure such a principal!
New York already has 30-40 kids in a class. It's no wonder no one learns. Schools overcroweded, classes over crowded, and not all, but some bad teachers.
Teachers are being cut - I didn't see how many in TX, but NY 15,000, 22,000 in CA. there will be classes with 50 kids now.