Public Executions: Is This the Right of Condemned Inmates?

Dee
When Timothy McVeigh, Oklahoma Bomber, received an execution date, he requested that his execution be aired for the whole nation to see. His request was denied. Capital Punishment has always been debated, and public executions have been one of those debates.

Execution chambers in the US are closed to the public, and only a handful of witnesses are able to attend. Family and friends of the victim, and family and friends of the condemned as well as clergy and media are the only people allowed to attend the execution.

If executions were to be aired on our television sets, would people view this as the newest "Reality TV" show? Or would the reality of executions change the minds of people about Capitol Punishment. The polls show that more Americans are for executions than against them, so why are they not able to see something they voted for?

The only known tapes, audio tapes only, are of those from the Georgia Department of Corrections. They had been taping executions as a safe guard that they made no mistakes, or botched the executions. There are no know video tapes, however.

With the recent controversy of botched executions, do the condemned inmates have the right to have their executions taped, for legal and moral reasons? Do they have the right to have those tapes viewed to the public? Will taping executions protect the inmate from a cruel and unusual punishment?

The First Amendment reads: The First Amendment of The United States Constitution protects the right to freedom of religion and freedom of expression from Government interference. Freedom of expression consists of the rights to freedom of speech, press, assembly and to petition the government for a redress of grievances, and the implied rights of association and belief. The Supreme Court interprets the extent of the protection afforded to these rights.

Recently 9 year old Mubasher Ali, hung himself while imitating the hanging of Saddam Hussein that he watched on his TV.

http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/115252/child_dies_while_attempting_to_imitate.html

Will this raise more controversy and debates about public executions?

Published by Dee

I am a prison activist/advocate writing about prison issues, hoping to make awareness, and bring reform. One out of every thirty-two people in the USA are currently on parole, probation or in prison. I am ow...  View profile

1 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Doreen (Dee) Hawk5/16/2007

    Deez, this could work 2 ways. If the execution is botched, legal action could be taken, and oh no! they might even halt all other scheduled executions.

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.