Public School Vs Homeschool Socialization

What Does True Socialization Look Like?

Joan Vasquez
"What about socialization?" This is the first question that pops out of the mouth of the uninformed when they hear about a family who homeschools. They seem to imagine children who act as though they were raised by wolves or who are totally unable to carry on intelligent conversations with those residing outside their own household.

Here is the official definition of the word "socialization":
so•cial•i•za•tion (s sh -l -z sh n)
n. The process of learning interpersonal and interactional skills that are in conformity with the values of one's society.

The public school's primary mission is to educate. Socializing is discouraged in most settings. Children are not supposed to talk in the classroom, in the hallway and in some schools, not even in the cafeteria. Thus, most socializing takes place at the unsupervised setting of the playground; the values most children pick up at recess are not exactly in conformity with the better morals of our society. Issues such as bullying, drugs, sexual talk and actions, and the establishment of an unfair pecking order do not meet up with the expected norms of adult life. What little bit of allowable socializing in the classroom setting is artificial, institutional and generic. Where in the "real world" or workplace are adults expected to interact with 20 to 30 people of one's own age and not those who are younger or older?

Homeschooling, on the other hand, provides children with more opportunities for real interpersonal and interactive life situations. The homeschooled student socializes daily with siblings and adults of all ages. They are more apt to go with their parents to the grocery store, bank, and other places of business so they can actively learn about the "real" world. They can choose to play with friends who have common interests and common values to their own family. When they do meet children with varying backgrounds, they are more apt to discuss this with their parents. They do not have to tolerate physical or emotional assault from bullies. This builds their self esteem and self confidence. Studies show over and over that home educated students are more capable of thinking for themselves and are not so peer dependent. This is why a lot of colleges actively recruit homeschooled students. When the family participates in a homeschool group activity, the children play with and learn alongside people who range from newborns to grandparents.

The public school setting is forced upon children whereas a homeschooled student can choose (much like an adult) with whom they will associate and in what setting. They usually have more time to pursue their outside interests such as sports, hobbies, church activities, volunteer opportunities, apprenticeships and clubs. This actually gives homeschooled students the upper hand when it comes to real world socialization skills. Therefore, the proper formation of social skills is more compatible with a reason FOR home education instead of a reason to NOT homeschool.

Published by Joan Vasquez

Mom of 6, editing from home. Dedicated breastfeeding and homeschool advocate. Life experiences range from moving over 70 times, living abroad, ex military spouse, and a son who almost died from formula int...  View profile

33 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Stewart Hall5/11/2011

    This article is ridiculously biased. I recently finished public school and I have to say that much of this is just blatantly incorrect.

    Yes, children are not supposed to talk during class, but no talking in the hallway or cafeteria? Please. That's just not true. That may be a tiny minority of public schools.

    As far as the comment on what kids learn at recess...I don't know where you're from, but where I went to school, we had recess until fifth grade. In elementary school I was pretending I was Harry Potter. Not talking about drugs and sex. I would suggest that you actually investigate this. It sounds to me like you're taking the shocking stories you see on the news and assuming they are commonplace. Sure there was bullying when I was in school, but exposing kids to this isn't a bad thing. I'm glad my first experiences with bullying were with 40 pound kids in close proximity to responsible adults. Sheltering kids from them isn't doing them any favors.

  • Bree4/29/2010

    Oh My word I Home school but Ive home school since 5th grade and im in 7th now and I surely can carry on a conversation with some one Im 13 now and I am Mature for my age I act like a 13 year old... I Take on conversations about gameing and movies and what ever else basicly you want to talk about : / why do some people think Homeschool kids have such socialization problems I meat with home school kids and other people like from church who dont homeschool and We get along just fine and carry conversations on as normal... Dont miss judge us and I do my work from getting up at 7 in the morning eating breakfast then going to school at 8 then take lunch at 12 for 30 mins and take P.E. for 30 mins then Get out of school at 3 so really all day I sit and do my work and only get hour break for lunch / P.E. and that 7 hours : / so dont miss judge us please

  • zastawnik3/22/2010

    I'm attempting to write a term paper in sociology by conducting a survey so if anyone is interested in helping with this important study on the aspects of education please go to http://freeonlinesurveys.com/rendersurvey.asp?sid=zlvtvcniwcq9u2a709947

  • Neil Frazer2/4/2010

    You're all douce bags.

  • puzzled12/2/2009

    I went to a public school so I know that nothing about them gets you prepared for the real world. To be completely frank they lure you into a false sense of security. Not to bash them or any thing , because my fondest memories were during times when I was attending school. I also feel that home schooling isn't any better for children then public schooling. the reason being is this: you only learn from one perspective that of your parents or someone that you know so you never really get a chance to hear many differant oppinions and ideas. So to sum this up neither home schooling nor public schooling are truly right for children.

  • Proud student of a public school10/7/2009

    I feel that the topic of Homeschooling vs. Schools can be a generalization. Not all public school kids are deprived of being social. And many of us don't have terrible grammar skills. I believe that when one is going to form an opinion, it is important to view the subject from both sides.

  • Home Taught9/21/2009

    It's funny the most intelligently written comments posted on here are people who were either home schooled or interested in home schooling. You public school kids need to watch your grammar and spelling. Just because all your friends write or talk that way doesn't mean that it is acceptable or right.

  • Pendragon7/25/2009

    A lot of people mistake socialization with socializing. See my piece about this regarding homeschooling.

  • Ashley5/10/2009

    I was disappointed with the article. I am looking for something more factual than biased. I didn't feel the comments made about public schools were accurate or lengthy enough. As a parent considering home schooling, this article turned me away.

  • ritethur5/7/2009

    YEZZZIR! LES GET IT POPPIN

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.