Pumpkin Pie

Or is It?

Elizabeth J. Baldwin
Pumpkin Pie is a Thanksgiving and Christmas holiday tradition in many American homes.

My husband grew up in West Virginia and I grew up in Texas. My family hadn't been east of the Mississippi since before the Mexican Revolution, which took place long before the Texas Revolution.

Despite the gap of centuries our families have so many things in common that it is hard to believe they aren't just extended branches of the same family. Since both families originated in the area along the border of Scotland and England being removed from there in the mid-sixteen hundreds to Ireland and from there to the New World we do both come from a small gene pool so maybe the likenesses aren't so unusual.

One thing we both learned as children was when a piece of apparently pumpkin pie was put before us never, ever say "Thank you for the pumpkin pie." We had a very good chance of being wrong.
If my mother served it then, most likely, it was pumpkin. If my grandmother or her sisters had baked it all you could be sure of was that it was pie and it would be good. My husband's family had a similar pattern. The thing is, the women in both families would use pumpkin if they had it. If they didn't, then sweet potatoes (sometimes called yams but most likely not) or any deep orange veggie, such as acorn squash, would do. One great-great aunt even served up a mean carrot pie.

Regardless of the base the recipe was the same. Simple, yet producing a good pie.

Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, Acorn Squash or Carrot Pie.

1 ½ cups of well mashed pulp (or 1 can of pumpkin)
2/3 cups of sugar (1/3 brown, packed down and 1/3 white sugar)
2 eggs
1 Tablespoon cinnamon
1 teaspoon ginger
1 teaspoon vanilla (my family's secret ingredient)
1 can evaporated milk (to this day a pumpkin, or whatever, pie doesn't taste right to me unless evaporated milk is used.

Add ingredients in the order listed and mix well. Pour into pie crust and place on a cookie sheet in a 450º oven for ten minutes. Reduce oven temperature to 325º and continue baking for about forty to fifty minutes. The pie is done when the center is firm to the touch or a clean knife comes out clean. Allow to cool for awhile

Published by Elizabeth J. Baldwin

I trained people to handle horses and other animals for several decades. My book Horses is for ages 9-12. The ISBN is 978-0778737759. Other books are available at http://shop.hollylisle.com/jamaffiliates/...  View profile

Almost any deep yellow vegetable can be used to make a good "pumpkin" pie. Besides pumpkin, sweet potatoes, orange winter squash or even carrots can be used to make a good pie. If I ever buy some orange beets I may even try them in the family recipe.

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Janet Roof11/22/2008


    Great recipe.

  • Janie Ellington11/22/2008

    sounds pretty darn good!

  • jcorn11/22/2008

    This is what I want to make today, nothing like the smell of pumpkin pie, freshly baked.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.