Purdue Professor Cleared Over the Confiscation of a Student's Ringing Cell Phone

Brian
Nearly a decade ago owning a cell phone was a thing of movies. Nowadays, it is beginning to seem that not owning a cell phone is a thing of fiction. Moreover, cell phone usage in schools are becoming quite a distraction to both teachers and students alike in schools nationwide.

According to 9News.com, six weeks ago at a business law class at Purdue University, Professor Meade was teaching class as he did every day. However, when one of his student's cell phones started ringing, Meade confiscated the phone. According to Meade, the student failed to promptly turn it off. Meade said he had every intent to turn over the cell phone to the dean's office the following morning. However, in a rush to get his phone back, the student contacted Purdue police. The officers informed Meade that failure to return the phone to the student would be considered theft. Therefore, while Meade was speaking with the police officers, the dean of Purdue's School of Management, Richard Cosier, arrived to retrieve the phone and return it to the student. Cosier lectured the student about the importance of not using cell phones during class, as per the school rules.

Ironically enough, the special prosecutor in charge of this case could not have experienced worse timing for informing the judge that he was clear of theft for confiscating the phone, as his own phone began ringing when delivering his report in Tippecanoe Superior Judge Meade's packed courtroom on Friday. The prosecutor quickly left the courtroom. On his exit, he passed a posted sign asking those who enter the courtroom to turn off all cell phones.

The prosecutors own cell phone mishap amused the judge. The judge enjoyed the prosecutors ringtone - "I Fought the Law (and the Law Won)."

"It was the perfect ending to this little annoyance," Meade said to the Associated Press.

According to an M:Metrics report, thirty-eight percent of teenagers surveyed text-message friends and family during school. Many high schools have cell phone policies in tact, in an effort to avoid an escalating situation such as the one previously mentioned. At Shelby Junior High in Shelby Township, MI, cell phones are not to be seen nor heard during school hours. This rule is common nationwide.

According to U.S. Cellular statistics, an estimated sixty percent of teenagers in America own a cell phone. In addition, U.S. Cellular statistics found that most of these teens spend an hour per day on the phone, which is the average time a student sets aside for homework completion.

Published by Brian

I've found that writing is a passion of mine that I am actively pursuing.  View profile

  • Thirty-eight percent of teenagers surveyed text-message friends and family during school.
  • Meade confiscated the ringing cell phone to the owner's displeasure.

4 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Kimberly Schimmel4/3/2010

    I have to sympathize with the prof, because I'm married to a professor. When cell phones fist surged in popularity, my husband was thoroughly disgusted to hear them ringing in class. I would have told the student to leave the class if he did not turn it off immediately AND apologize for disrupting class for everyone else. Why risk a theft charge from a spoiled brat who can't set a phone to "silent".

  • Preston5/30/2007

    Why didn't the teacher just give the phone back to the student right after class? He has the right to also ask the student to leave if the phone ringing problem persists. I've had my phone ring in class after forgetting to turn it off beforehand several times. I'm learning to remember to keep it off though, or not bring it to class. No teacher should have to contend with ringing cell phones in their classroom. If the high schools are employing zero tolerance policies, then the colleges need to allow their instructors the freedom to keep it out of the classroom. In other words, their should be consequences to the student that will discourage the use of cell phones as opposed to completely restricting them on campus.

  • vic_elor5/29/2007

    I always find it funny when people got mad at me for having my cell phone off for hours on end. I can't understand how most people have it on all the time. It is too much of a nuisance. That's why I use skype now instead.

  • Amanda Roddy5/29/2007

    We got along fine without cell phones in the classroom during the 70;s and 80's. Students today are so out of touch with reality. Cell phones have turned into a social status symbol rather than for the purpose they are intended to serve.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.