Questions About a Mysterious Death? Exhume the Body for a Second Autopsy

Vickie Bertram: 30 Years Later, Her Death Remains a Mystery

Todd Matthews
Vickie Robin Bertram died in Livingston, Tennessee in 1976. The cause of this young girl's death remains a mystery; her case is still unsolved after 30 years.

There are so many things that Vickie brought into my life, years after her own death. Her story was always one of the urban legends in our town. She supposedly "fell" from a cliff on Rock Crusher Mountain. I lived on that mountain myself for the first 9 months of my life.

The story of Bertram's death broke in the Thursday Oct. 7, 1976 edition of the Livingston Enterprise. According to the article, on September 10, 1976, the 16 year old girl fell to her death into the rock quarry on Rock Crusher Mountain.

But did she?

This was a fall of more than 100 feet. The original autopsy claimed..."No broken bones." Is this possible? Imagine the years of turmoil for those who knew and loved her.

I first became involve when her brother, a local deputy in 1998, came to my door and ask for help. I knew Ryan Allred from school, but I had not connected him to this old story. He was older than me, but I remembered him as a bitter person. It was only when I heard the rest of the story I knew the reason.

I knew the only way to know for sure was to exhume the body. We worked to acquire local permit..and we exhumed the body to transport to the University of Tennessee, more specifically the legendary "Body Farm."

I was disappointed that Ryan, now one of my closest friends, was the only deputy on the scene of the exhumation. His peers not there to support their peer in one of his most difficult tasks. He himself helped to lift the remains of his sister form her grave. He did what he knew he had to do for his sister.

The 2nd autopsy....many years after the initial autopsy, did indeed reveal broken bones. But were they enough to confirm a fall of more than 100 feet into a solid limestone basin?

Did Vickie die in the stone quarry, or was she places there to cover a more sinister scenario?

Will we ever know?

-Todd

A poem by Vickie - -shortly before her death -

Dismissed

I know that I shall soon fade away,
as the day fades into the night.

I am not afraid for all things that begin
must surely draw to a close.

I wonder why all my possessions
seem so like treasures and jewels
that just so recently I have uncovered.

I watch each day in silent solitude
Quietly as so not to disturb
even the smallest of molecules.

I (at first) would long for one more decade
to fulfill and satisfy the ambitions and
expectations of my forefathers.

In the beginning I would weep in awesome agony
with a desire to rid myself of
this evil illness.

I know, at least have expected my fate
as you would have to endure a broken heart.

Seven months and three days have passed
since I have learned of my new nature.

I feel myself slowly slipping from this reality
into the reality of the universe.

Each minute reveals the answer to a question
that hasn't been asked, before, even in the greatest books.

Today is the day I must leave and go
to the place where they have been calling
and waiting for me.

I walk slowly into a field of sunshine
Fields of tall waving grass,
delicate flowers and tumbling hills.

A field like the one where my brother and sister passed
there time running, jumping and playing.

Mine eyes have suddenly gone blind to this landscape
as the wind blows, I fall into the grass
softly and peacefully.

My spirit is gone from my bones and flesh
I see myself lying ever so gracefully in a bed
of green satin.

As I descended into the clouds
I feel no sorrow that I must leave
only regret that I couldn't give more love
to my home and my friends.

-Vickie Bertram

Published by Todd Matthews

Todd's calling to be a voice for missing and unidentified persons began when he solved the identity of the "Tent Girl" case, Barbara Hackman-Taylor, after a ten-year journey that ended in 1998.   View profile

  • "I still believe there might be more to it"
  • The orinal autopsy said that Bertram did not have any broken bones or signs of trauma.
  • Bertram's body was found face down at base of cliff

10 Comments

Post a Comment
  • RYAN ALLRED 9/3/2010

    THIS WAS MORE THAN LIKLEY A (HOMOCIDE),
    NOT A SUICIDE. HOW DO I KNOW? BECAUSE I
    WAS THE ONLY PERSON IN LAW ENFORCEMENT THAT INVESTIGATED THE DAMN! CASE. I OWE LAW-ENFORCEMENT EXACTLY WHAT THEY DONE FOR ME "NOTHING"!!!!!!

  • Carol 1/12/2007

    My brother feel 40 feet and broke his back, arm, both legs,both feet. 100 feet should have broken almost all her bones.

  • Shana Dines 1/7/2007

    That is so sad, and I feel so bad for her brother and family. It does sound like either suicide or premonition. I understand her feelings, and wish that she could have lived. I sometimes feel like I , and many of us are too fragile for this harsh cruel world. Thanks for the lovely tribute, to this dear girl and her brother

  • Catherine Neal 1/6/2007

    Its sad that her brothers comrades were not there to help him. I really hope that he is able to find peace now.

  • Kayla McClure 1/5/2007

    Great article....Everyone is right..Did she know she was going to die soon or was she just fascinated with death and so forth. I hope that he can find peace with everything...What makes you wonder is why the first autopsy didn't show any broken bones but the second one did...Doesnt make sense...It makes you wonder...

  • Nicole 1/5/2007

    wow, it does sound like, whether her death was self-inflicted or not, she knew she was going to die. her poem gave me goosebumps. great article

  • Daniel Doyle 1/4/2007

    She had a fscination with and perhaps a pre-occupation with passing from life and into a better place. Clearly she was sorry that she was not going to be able to give love any longer.
    Sure sounds like a good bye in which she knew of an ill condition and perhaps wanted to leave before it became serious...
    tantalizing story. I hope her brother finds peace.

  • D Armenta 1/4/2007

    Todd: The poem almost sounds like a suicide note. Could that have been the case? In any event, thanks for a most interesting story.

  • Jasmine Starr 1/4/2007

    Very Touching.. The Poem makes you really think.

  • Veronika Fevers 1/4/2007

    I would have loved to read your article, but could not do to the fact the left part of the page is missing?

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.