Questions for Politicians Who Oppose Gay Rights
Some Thoughts on Theodore Bilbo, John Stennis, George Wallace, Gay Rights, Bigotry and Remembrance
The other day, my mayor, Michael Bloomberg, gave a stunningly good speech in support of marriage equality.
One of the things Bloomberg said is that history has not been kind to the people who oppose the march of freedom in America. Indeed not.
I decided I would expand a little on this. I'd like to ask politicians who oppose GLBT rights some questions:
Do you remember Senator Theodore Bilbo of Mississippi?
Did you know that Theodore Bilbo built veterans' homes, made school attendance mandatory, built a tuberculosis hospital and banned public hanging as a punishment? Did you know that Bilbo fought against corruption? Did you know that Bilbo helped (through scurrilous means, but nevertheless.... ) Al Smith win Mississippi and helped pass FDR's new deal? No. Probably not. When you think of Bilbo, you remember a bigot. You remember someone who railed against the "mongrelization" (his word) that was inevitable if Blacks lived with Whites
What about Bilbo's successor as Senator from Mississippi, John Stennis?
Did you know that John Stennis wrote the first ethics code for the Senate? Did you know that Stennis was the first Democrat to criticize Joe McCarthy? Did you know Stennis voted against Robert Bork for SCOTUS? Did you know that Stennis eventually changed his views on civil rights quite a bit, to the extent that he campaigned for Mike Espy, who became the first Black congressman from the south since reconstruction?
Probably not. You remember a bigot.
And now, another question.
How do you want history to remember you?
Because you're going to lose. It's not a question of if, it's a question of when. The arc of history bends against you; sometimes that arc is slow, but it keeps bending. Kids today look at gay marriage differently than even the liberal adults.
Recently, a kid asked a teacher if he had kids. The teacher said "I've told you I'm gay" and the kid replied "What does that have to do with it?" In my son's school, each kid in his class was asked to write a letter to Obama. More than half said "let gay people marry". So, yes, you are going to lose. You are bigots.
And while Stennis is remembered as a bigot, the memories of George Wallace, another more-famous southern bigot, are somewhat different. No mistake that Wallace was a bigot for much of his life and career. He "stood in the schoolhouse door" to prevent integration. He said people who supported integration should be given "barbed wire enemas". But he changed. And he said he was wrong. And that is remembered too.
How will history remember you?
One of the things Bloomberg said is that history has not been kind to the people who oppose the march of freedom in America. Indeed not.
I decided I would expand a little on this. I'd like to ask politicians who oppose GLBT rights some questions:
Do you remember Senator Theodore Bilbo of Mississippi?
Did you know that Theodore Bilbo built veterans' homes, made school attendance mandatory, built a tuberculosis hospital and banned public hanging as a punishment? Did you know that Bilbo fought against corruption? Did you know that Bilbo helped (through scurrilous means, but nevertheless.... ) Al Smith win Mississippi and helped pass FDR's new deal? No. Probably not. When you think of Bilbo, you remember a bigot. You remember someone who railed against the "mongrelization" (his word) that was inevitable if Blacks lived with Whites
What about Bilbo's successor as Senator from Mississippi, John Stennis?
Did you know that John Stennis wrote the first ethics code for the Senate? Did you know that Stennis was the first Democrat to criticize Joe McCarthy? Did you know Stennis voted against Robert Bork for SCOTUS? Did you know that Stennis eventually changed his views on civil rights quite a bit, to the extent that he campaigned for Mike Espy, who became the first Black congressman from the south since reconstruction?
Probably not. You remember a bigot.
And now, another question.
How do you want history to remember you?
Because you're going to lose. It's not a question of if, it's a question of when. The arc of history bends against you; sometimes that arc is slow, but it keeps bending. Kids today look at gay marriage differently than even the liberal adults.
Recently, a kid asked a teacher if he had kids. The teacher said "I've told you I'm gay" and the kid replied "What does that have to do with it?" In my son's school, each kid in his class was asked to write a letter to Obama. More than half said "let gay people marry". So, yes, you are going to lose. You are bigots.
And while Stennis is remembered as a bigot, the memories of George Wallace, another more-famous southern bigot, are somewhat different. No mistake that Wallace was a bigot for much of his life and career. He "stood in the schoolhouse door" to prevent integration. He said people who supported integration should be given "barbed wire enemas". But he changed. And he said he was wrong. And that is remembered too.
How will history remember you?
Published by Peter Flom
I am a statistician, working with a wide variety of clients, mostly researchers in psychology, education, medicine, social sciences and other fields. I also have given talks and written articles on learning... View profile
Gay Rights Groups Should Leave Tony Dungy AloneGay rights groups are upset at Tony Dungy for speaking at an event sponsored by a group against gay marriage. These gay rights groups should pick on somebody else.
"Day Without a Gay" is "Call in Gay Day" to Show Support for Gay RightsDecember 10 is "Call In Gay Day." It is also being called "Day Without A Gay." And December 10 is International Human Rights Day as well. The conflation is not a coincidence.
Why I Believe in Gay Rights, Glenn Beck, Ford Automobiles and Teaching...I believe in Gay rights, Glenn Beck, Ford Automotives and English as a Second language because we can't all fit in one box. It would be boring and that is not what makes America...- How George Wallace Saved the WorldA poetic mythology concerning how George Wallace saved the world.
- Are Americans Becoming More Accepting of Gays and Gay Rights? Armistead Maupin Thi...
- George Wallace: Controversial Leader
- Who is to Blame when Gay Rights Become Deadly?
- Reasons for Recent Gay Rights Advancements in the USA
- The Status of the Gay Rights Movement Today
- Former Gay Rights Leader Becomes a Christian
- Gay Rights: A Moral Travesty, or a Human Rights Issue?



