Quotations and Punctuation in Web Writing - What's Right?

Advice from Personal Experience and the Yahoo! Style Guide

Y! Lyn
You're in the midst of a writeup and everything's going great. You just got an amazing quote from the perfect source. But suddenly, you've forgotten the rules surrounding that. Does the period go after the quotation? Or does it belong within? That depends on your sentence. In my years of experience in web writing, this has been a popular question. This tutorial combines my experience along with the time I've spent studying the online version of the Yahoo! Style Guide. The following is meant to help readers solve that and other mysteries surrounding punctuation and quotations.

Proper Punctuation When Quoting a Source

The general rule is to keep punctuation, such as periods, inside quotations. This is where many get confused. In fact, I have received dozens of emails and message from fellow writers about this. Some have assumed I was doing it wrong. Others wanted advice. If you are quoting a source, according to the Yahoo! Style Guide lesson entitled "Quotation Marks", it actually belongs outside the quotation unless the punctuation is part of the quote.

Example of correct placement of a period when quoting a source:

--Tina Baker stated that "fries are better than chips when accompanied by hamburgers".

Because the noted quote was the end of a sentence containing it, the period belongs outside the quote. Had the quote been by itself, the period would have gone inside the quote.

Example of correct placement of a period when the quote is a stand-alone sentence.

--Yesterday I spoke with Dr. Allen. His comments: "Looks like we're going to have to do surgery. This a rare occurrence."

Since this quote contains complete stand-alone sentences, the punctuation belongs inside the quotes.

Proper Punctuation When Quoting Exact Text

If there is a string of text that must be typed in an exact way, the punctuation belongs outside the quotation. For instance, if you want to put emphasis on a phrase, you would put any following punctuation after the quote. Some get confused on this because it may not look right to see a period after quotations. However, this is the correct way to construct such a sentence.

Examples of correct placement of punctuation when using exact text:

--To submit that assignment, click on the button labeled "submit".

--To check your daily views, first click on the "content" tab.

When In Doubt With Exact Text, Try Boldface Instead

If you are confused about the exact text and where to put the punctuation, consider using a boldface font instead. If you put emphasis on the text with bold characters, that avoids the need to use quotes.

Examples of using boldface to avoid quotations:

--To submit that assignment, click on the button labeled submit.

--To check your daily views, first click on the content tab.

Exclamation Points and Questions Marks Used With Quotes

When using question marks and exclamation points with quotations, unless that punctuation is a part of the statement being quoted, it belongs outside the quote. If a person exclaims something and you quote that, the exclamation point belongs inside the quotation. But if your sentence including the quote was an exclamation, it belongs outside.

Examples of correct placement of exclamation and question marks in quotes:

--Tommy said he "ran 150 miles today"!

--When Amy saw that yummy taste concoction, she exclaimed "It's all mine!"

--I ran into Brook today and she asked "How do you find the time to write so often?"

--Do you enjoy those sweet pickles - you know, the ones called "bread and butter"?

Source:

http://styleguide.yahoo.com/editing/punctuate-proficiently/quotation-marks

Published by Y! Lyn - Community Advocate

Lyn Lomasi is the Community Advocate at Yahoo! Contributor Network. Email her with community issues & ideas (contributor-lyn@yahoo-inc.com). Read her tips for success on the official Yahoo! Contributor Netwo...  View profile

32 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Lyn Lomasi2/23/2011

    Stephanie, this should help answer your question and also clear up some confusion on differences between the two: http://styleguide.yahoo.com/resources/web-editors-toolbox/differences-between-yahoo-style-guide-and-associated-press-stylebook

  • Stephanie Wiersma2/23/2011

    Hmm, AP Style says to always put periods inside quotation marks. Does Yahoo!'s guide say differently? So many style guides, so much confusion!!

  • Shan-Lyn Forsythe2/22/2011

    Helpful!! ;)

  • Cheri Majors, M.S.8/7/2010

    Excellent article Lyn! Very helpful!

  • Sherri Granato8/3/2010

    Thanks for clearing up the confusion. : )

  • Kim Keason8/2/2010

    It's amazing what you do without even thinking about it.

  • Charlotte Kuchinsky8/2/2010

    Excellent job on this. I know I make errors but I keep trying to improve.

  • Pauline Dolinski8/2/2010

    Those periods outside the quotation marks look so vulnerable and awkward, though, don't they?

  • Tracie Walker8/1/2010

    Thanks, punctuation takes constant checking up on!

  • Theresa Wiza8/1/2010

    I had an English instructor once who said ALL periods belonged inside quotation marks. I don't always follow her advice though ;)

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.